InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Checklist for choosing location technology by plant environment

Choosing a location technology is not one decision for the whole plant, but a series of decisions made for each environment. A production hall, a warehouse, an explosion-hazard zone, a yard and an office have different limits on signal, power and risk. The checklist below takes the maintenance manager through each of them and ends with a shared list of checks.

2/22
ATEX zones of the InnerWeb industrial beacon
Source: InnerWeb facts
approx. 100 m
spacing of transmitters on plant roads
Source: InnerWeb facts
100–200 m²
floor area per transmitter in a building
Source: InnerWeb facts

Step 1: define what the system must indicate

Before you choose a technology, write down the scenario: SOS alarm, no movement, evacuation, presence check in a zone, vehicle trace. For most people safety scenarios, indicating the zone and the floor is enough, and centimetres do not change the decision of a rescuer. InnerWeb locates people on BLE transmitters and does not require GPS, and the algorithm reaches an average accuracy below 1 m from many measurement points. If your scenario requires the position of a detail, for example a tool at a workstation, UWB may be justified in that one place.

Step 2: production hall

In a hall with metal machines and racks, the radio signal is reflected and attenuated, so the density of transmitters matters. Plan 1 transmitter per 100–200 m² and densify in critical zones. The position from the signals of many transmitters, averaged on the map, is more stable than the position from the single strongest one. Check where the device hears only one transmitter, and add a second one there.

Floor area per transmitter in a building (m²)

Floor area per transmitter in a building (m²)Horizontal chart shows the range of 100–200 m² per transmitter in a building.050100150200m²Lower end of the rangeLower end of the range: 100 m²100Upper end of the rangeUpper end of the range: 200 m²200
Source: InnerWeb facts

Step 3: warehouse and high-bay storage

In a high-bay warehouse, racks form aisles, and metal shelves attenuate the signal between them. Place transmitters along the aisles, not in a grid drawn on the plan. If you need pallet records, passive RFID registers passage through a gate or a read point, but not a continuous position, and it requires the item to be close to the reader. For people and forklifts in the aisles, BLE is used, and RFID gates are kept for passage events.

Step 4: explosion-hazard zone

In Ex zones, what matters is the approval of the device. The InnerWeb industrial beacon has an industrial design, a CE declaration and an ATEX design for zones 2 and 22. For a zone with a different classification, or for wearable devices used in that zone, require the documents of the specific device and confirmation by the person responsible for explosion protection. Powered UWB anchors or Wi-Fi points in the zone need a separate assessment, because every cabled device is an additional source of risk.

Step 5: yard and plant roads

GPS does not work inside buildings and in tunnels, because the satellite signal is attenuated by the structure, but it is sometimes available on the yard. Do not, however, build two systems. Plant roads are covered with BLE transmitters about every 100 m, and this works without GPS both on the yard and under a canopy. As a result, a vehicle or a worker has one continuous trace from the gate to the hall.

Step 6: offices and buildings with low risk

In offices, the risk and the required accuracy are lower. An access event from the existing access control system and a sparser grid of transmitters are often enough, and InnerWeb as an independent system takes events from the client's existing systems instead of replacing them. Do not spend the budget on UWB in an office if nobody asks about centimetres.

Step 7: record the decision and plan the test

For each environment, record the technology, the density, the power supply, the scenario and the acceptance criterion. Plan a test at control points and repeat it after the equipment is set up. The record of the decision is sometimes more important than the decision itself, because when the plant is extended, it allows the logic of the choice to be repeated in new buildings.

Whenever the hall layout changes, for example after a new line or racks are placed, return to this list and check whether the density assumptions still hold.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Can I have several technologies in one plant?

Yes, but each additional technology is a separate maintenance task. Usually one BLE network plus events from existing systems is the simplest.

Does an Ex zone rule out BLE?

No, but it requires devices approved for that zone. The InnerWeb industrial beacon has ATEX design for zones 2 and 22.

What about cold stores?

Low temperature affects the battery of the devices, so plan a test of operating time in the cold store and a stock of devices.

When should I consider UWB?

When the scenario requires the position of a detail and you accept dense, powered anchors. For people's safety, BLE is usually sufficient.

Let's talk about location in your plant

We will show how a system based on many BLE transmitters behaves in a hall similar to yours. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.

Let's talk