InnerWeb
Skip to main content

FAQ: GPS, Wi-Fi and RFID in a plant

GPS, Wi-Fi and RFID are already present in most plants, so it is natural to ask whether they are enough to locate people. The answer depends on what each of these technologies actually measures. Below are the limits of each one and the point where the need for BLE transmitters begins.

25–50
transmitters for a 5,000 m² hall (1 per 100–200 m²)
Source: calculation from InnerWeb facts
approx. 100 m
spacing of transmitters on plant roads
Source: InnerWeb facts

Why does GPS not work in a hall?

GPS does not work inside buildings and in tunnels, because the satellite signal is attenuated by the structure. The roof, ceilings and walls weaken it so much that the receiver loses a stable reading or reports a position with a large error. This is why InnerWeb locates people using BLE transmitters and does not require GPS.

GPS can be useful on an open yard, but a plant is usually a mix of yard, hall, canopy, covered passage and basement. If the system is to show one continuous position, it cannot depend on a technology that disappears behind the first wall.

Is the Wi-Fi network we already have enough?

Location accuracy based on Wi-Fi signal strength is usually in the range of a few metres and depends on the density of access points and on calibration. Wi-Fi access points are designed for throughput, so they are placed sparsely and often high up, which does not favour precision.

The second problem is the worn device: a watch or badge with Wi-Fi uses more energy than a BLE transmitter in a low-rate transmission mode. For the worker, this means more frequent charging.

What each technology returns: position continuity (0 none, 3 full)

What each technology returns: position continuity (0 none, 3 full)Chart rates the position continuity inside a hall for GPS, RFID, Wi-Fi and BLE.0123pktGPS in a hall: 0 pkt0 pktGPS in a hallPassive RFID: 1 pkt1 pktPassive RFIDWi-Fi: 2 pkt2 pktWi-FiBLE, many transmitters: 3 pkt3 pktBLE, manytransmitters
Source: Qualitative rating by the author based on the technology descriptions in the text, not a measurement

What does RFID measure and why is it not a position?

Passive RFID registers a passage through a gate or a read point, not a continuous position, and requires the tag to be brought close to the reader. We know that a card passed a point at a given time, but we do not know where the person is after 5 minutes.

It is an excellent source of events: entry, exit, passage between zones. This is why InnerWeb, as an independent complementary system, receives such events from the client's existing systems instead of replacing them.

Is BLE not too variable?

Bluetooth Low Energy operates in the 2.4 GHz band, and battery-powered BLE transmitters can work for years with a low transmission rate. Signal variability is real, but the algorithm solves it: the position results from the signals of many transmitters averaged on the map, not from a single reading.

How many transmitters are needed to replace other technologies?

Plant roads are covered with transmitters about every 100 m, and inside a building the design assumes one transmitter per 100–200 m². For a 5,000 m² hall, this gives 25 to 50 transmitters. A detailed calculation can be found on the page about the infrastructure cost in a hall.

Can the technologies be combined?

Yes, and this is often the best setup. Events from RFID gates or access control readers tell who entered, while BLE transmitters tell where that person is inside. InnerWeb combines this data with qualifications, permits and attendance, and does not replace the access control or time attendance system.

Which technology works in which part of the plant?

Yard and plant roads: BLE transmitters about every 100 m give a continuous trail without GPS, and GPS can be an addition in places without a roof. Production halls and warehouses: BLE at a density of one transmitter per 100–200 m², supplemented by gate events. Offices: an entry event from access control and a sparser transmitter grid are often enough, because the risk is lower here. Explosion-hazard zones: the design of the device matters; the InnerWeb industrial beacon has a CE declaration and ATEX design for zones 2 and 22.

Does active RFID solve the problem of passive RFID?

Active tags transmit on their own and can provide continuous information, but they require their own receiver infrastructure and a battery in each tag. As a result, you get a second system with separate maintenance. If you need transmitters across the plant anyway, it is more sensible to base location on a single BLE network and connect the events from existing access control readers through integration, rather than maintaining two parallel networks.

How does the power supply of transmitters compare with Wi-Fi?

Battery-powered BLE transmitters can work for years with a low transmission rate, so they need no cable or socket, and installation consists of hanging the device and marking its position on the map. Wi-Fi access points need power and a network connection, which in a hall with a high ceiling means installation work. The difference is visible in the deployment costs, which we compare on a separate page about the infrastructure in a hall.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does GPS work on the plant yard?

In open space it usually does, but under canopies and near tall buildings quality drops. A system based on BLE transmitters works without GPS and behaves the same on the yard and inside the hall.

Do I have to replace RFID readers?

No. InnerWeb does not manufacture or replace access control readers; it only receives events from them.

Is Wi-Fi suitable for an SOS alarm?

As a supplement, yes, but continuous position at zone accuracy requires a denser grid than is usually installed for data transmission.

What is the first step?

Draw a map of the plant with its buildings and floors, then plan the placement of transmitters by the density given on this page.

Let's talk about location in your plant

We will show how a system based on many BLE transmitters behaves in a hall similar to yours. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.

Let's talk