InnerWeb
Skip to main content

UWB or BLE in a paint shop hall: a technology selection scenario

A plant director with a paint shop has one hall with spray booths and one question: does the site need UWB with centimetre accuracy, or is BLE enough at the concept stage? The scenario below shows how to settle this from the location task itself, not from a catalogue of parameters.

< 1 m
average BLE accuracy across many measurement points
Source: company data
25–50
BLE transmitters for a 5,000 m2 hall
Source: sample calculation: 1 transmitter per 100 to 200 m2

Starting point: one hall, several booths, one question

We describe a conceptual scenario for a production plant with a paint shop, where painters, line operators and maintenance staff work. This is not a description of a completed deployment. It is the reasoning we apply to people location requests in halls of this kind.

The plant director wants to know where people are in the hall during an alarm, who has entered a booth where painting is in progress, and whether anyone has stayed in the zone after the shift has ended. The purchasing department has received a UWB offer from one supplier with accuracy in the range of a dozen or so centimetres. The question is whether such accuracy is needed.

Before we compare technologies, we settle one thing: what operational decision the system has to make based on position. An evacuation alarm requires something different from locking a booth while a person is inside.

What each technology really delivers

UWB under IEEE 802.15.4z measures signal time of flight and, in favourable conditions, reaches accuracy in the range of a dozen or so centimetres. The price is a dense infrastructure of anchors that must be powered or cabled, which in a paint shop means an installation project, not just hanging devices up.

BLE operates in the 2.4 GHz band, and battery-powered transmitters can run for years when they transmit rarely. In the InnerWeb system, a person's position is calculated from the signals of many transmitters averaged on the map, not from the single strongest one. The BLE location algorithm inside buildings reaches an average accuracy below 1 m across many measurement points.

What below 1 metre means in practice

Below 1 m is an average over many measurement points, not a guarantee for each individual measurement. With any supplier, including us, it is worth asking for the median and the 95th percentile of the error, because an average alone hides rare large deviations. For the question of which booth or zone a person is in, such accuracy is usually sufficient, provided the booths are separated by walls and have their own transmitters.

Where UWB makes sense

UWB is justified where the decision depends on distances of single decimetres: for example, automatically blocking a machine when a person comes close to a hazard zone, or navigating a vehicle relative to a person. For people location used for alarms, presence checks and work permits, such a need usually does not exist.

Number of BLE transmitters by hall area

Number of BLE transmitters by hall areaBar chart of the number of BLE transmitters for halls of 3,000, 5,000 and 8,000 square metres at two placement densities.020406080pcsDense: 1 per 100 m2 (3,000 m2): 30 pcs30 pcsSparser: 1 per 200 m2 (3,000 m2): 15 pcs15 pcs3,000 m2Dense: 1 per 100 m2 (5,000 m2): 50 pcs50 pcsSparser: 1 per 200 m2 (5,000 m2): 25 pcs25 pcs5,000 m2Dense: 1 per 100 m2 (8,000 m2): 80 pcs80 pcsSparser: 1 per 200 m2 (8,000 m2): 40 pcs40 pcs8,000 m2
  • Dense: 1 per 100 m2
  • Sparser: 1 per 200 m2
Source: Sample calculation based on placing 1 transmitter per 100 to 200 m2 in a building

How many BLE transmitters a hall needs

The rule established in InnerWeb deployments is one transmitter per 100 to 200 m2 inside a building, with access roads covered by transmitters about every 100 m. The system works without GPS, which receives no satellite signal inside buildings because the structure shields it.

For a paint shop hall of 5,000 m2, this gives between 25 and 50 transmitters, depending on whether the booths and partitions require denser coverage. We choose denser placement where booth walls attenuate the signal and where a person inside a booth must be told apart from a person in the corridor next to it.

  • Hall of 3,000 m2: 15 to 30 transmitters.
  • Hall of 5,000 m2: 25 to 50 transmitters.
  • Hall of 8,000 m2: 40 to 80 transmitters.

Explosion hazard zone: what a paint shop changes

Paint shops often have an atmosphere that requires classification of explosion hazard zones. The InnerWeb industrial beacon has an industrial design registration, a CE declaration and ATEX construction for zones 2 and 22. This means that in this category of zones the transmitter can be mounted without additional enclosures, while zones 0, 1, 20 and 21 are decided by an analysis of the specific location.

With UWB, the anchors, which are either powered or cabled, must be assessed separately for approval in a given zone and for routing cables through the booths. This is not an argument against UWB, but a cost item that the purchasing department should see before comparing technology prices.

Recommended path: BLE as the baseline, UWB only where indicated

In the conceptual scenario we propose deploying BLE across the whole hall and assessing during a pilot whether individual zones require centimetre accuracy. InnerWeb is a software manufacturer; we produce the beacons, while other equipment is purchased and integrated, so the pilot does not close the way to supplementing the system with another technology where a measurement result justifies it.

The pilot covers one hall or part of it, a map built in the map editor, transmitter placement according to the rule from the previous section, and an error measurement along a defined control route. We assess the result by the median and the 95th percentile, and we take the decision on UWB in selected zones only after that measurement.

  • Step 1: list the decisions the system is to make based on position.
  • Step 2: for each decision, record the required accuracy in metres and the justification.
  • Step 3: build the hall map and place BLE transmitters according to the rule of 1 per 100 to 200 m2.
  • Step 4: measure the error along the control route and compare it with the requirement from step 2.
  • Step 5: only for zones that do not meet the requirement, consider UWB or another supplement.

Conclusions for the plant director

Centimetre accuracy is a parameter of the technology, not a business requirement. Instead of asking which technology is more accurate, ask what is the smallest accuracy that is sufficient for evacuation, permit and zone presence decisions to be correct.

If the answer is a level of single metres within the hall, BLE with averaging across many transmitters usually meets the requirement at lower installation cost and without powering anchors. If the hall contains a few places with particularly strict requirements, UWB can be planned as a narrow supplement.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is UWB always more accurate than BLE?

In favourable conditions UWB reaches accuracy in the range of a dozen or so centimetres, so it is more accurate. However, it requires dense infrastructure of powered or cabled anchors, and for many tasks, such as presence alarms in a zone, that accuracy does not change the decision.

Does BLE in a paint shop not get disrupted by metal booths?

Metal partitions attenuate the signal, which is why denser transmitter placement is used in a hall with booths, and the position is calculated from many transmitters at once. Effectiveness is verified by measurement along the control route during the pilot.

Can transmitters be mounted in an Ex zone?

The InnerWeb beacon has ATEX construction for zones 2 and 22. For zones with a higher hazard, the decision is taken after an analysis of the specific location, together with the person responsible for zone classification.

Is location in a hall possible at all without GPS?

Yes. GPS does not work inside buildings, because the structure shields the satellite signal, and the InnerWeb system relies on signals from BLE transmitters and works without GPS.

Sources

Plan a pilot on one hall

We will show the transmitter placement on the map of your hall and set a control route for measuring the error. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.

Let's talk