Accuracy and how it is measured
The first group of questions concerns numbers. Ask for the average, the median and the 95th percentile of the error, because with a location supplier the average alone hides rare large deviations. Ask for a description of the facility where the measurement was made, the density of transmitters and the number of control points. For comparison, InnerWeb states an average accuracy below 1 m from many measurement points, and in a city project 11,000 transmitters reached an accuracy below 1.5 m in 95 facilities with a combined area of 120,000 m².
Also ask about an acceptance measurement in your hall and whether the result is written into the contract. Lack of readiness to measure on site is a warning sign.
Equipment: who manufactures, what we buy, what we integrate
The second group concerns the supply chain. Ask which elements the supplier manufactures and which it buys and integrates. InnerWeb is the manufacturer of the software; the industrial beacon has an industrial design, a CE declaration and ATEX design for zones 2 and 22, and the remaining equipment is bought and integrated. Such a division is honest and sufficient, provided the supplier clearly states who is responsible for the service of each element.
For explosion-hazard zones, require the documents of the specific device for the specific zone, not a general declaration of conformity.
Example: importance of the question groups (weight 1–5)
Infrastructure, power and installation
The third group covers what must be prepared in the plant. How many infrastructure points the offer foresees for your area, which of them require power or a cable, and how long installation takes. The InnerWeb system assumes 1 transmitter per 100–200 m² inside a building and transmitters about every 100 m on plant roads, and the transmitters are battery-powered. UWB requires a dense infrastructure of anchors that are powered or cabled, so for such an offer ask about the installation schedule and downtime.
Wearable devices and battery
The fourth group concerns batteries. The battery operating time of a device is not guaranteed as a product constant and depends on the configuration and conditions, so require a description of the conditions under which the operating time was measured and propose a test on a dozen or so devices over two weeks. Ask about the method of charging or replacing cells, the number of spare units and how the system signals a low battery. The heartbeat should report the battery state and the status of the device.
Integrations and independence
The fifth group concerns the place of the system in your plant. InnerWeb is an independent system complementing the client's existing systems (access control, time attendance, HR, ERP), not a replacement for them. Ask the supplier which interfaces it offers, how it receives events from existing systems and whether it requires their replacement. The answer "we will replace everything" usually means a longer and more expensive project.
Map documentation and maintenance
The sixth group concerns work after installation. The plant structure (buildings, floors, equipment) is drawn in a map editor, and a map is built for each facility during the deployment work. Ask who maintains the map after deployment, how a correction of a transmitter position is carried out and whether changes are recorded in the audit log. Edits made in the administration application go to the audit log, while changes made outside the application bypass it, so ask about the change policy.
Scoring the answers
To compare offers, give each group a weight and rate the answers on a scale of 0 to 3. No answer scores 0, a general answer scores 1, an answer with a number but without conditions scores 2, and an answer with a number, conditions and readiness to measure scores 3. A weighted total does not replace conversations with references, but it reveals suppliers who avoid specifics. Transfer the records of the most important answers into the contract as acceptance parameters.
Checklist
Video
Frequently asked questions
Must all the questions go into the request for proposal?
Ideally yes, because then the offers are comparable. Questions about equipment and integrations can be narrowed to the elements relevant to your plant.
Does requiring a measurement in the hall discourage suppliers?
A reliable supplier has a test procedure. Resistance to measurement is information about the quality of the offer.
Who should evaluate the answers?
A team made up of IT, safety or maintenance and purchasing, because each group has a different expert.
Can this checklist be used for UWB and Wi-Fi?
Yes, it is technology-neutral, and that is why it is suitable for comparing BLE, UWB and Wi-Fi.
Let's talk about location in your plant
We will show how a system based on many BLE transmitters behaves in a hall similar to yours. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.
Let's talk