InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Wi-Fi or BLE location: recommendations for the IT department

The plant's IT department has to choose whether to base people location on Wi-Fi signal strength or on BLE transmitters. The choice determines the network load, the work of the maintenance team and what happens when an access point fails. Here are six recommendations.

Who the recommendations are for and what question we settle

The recommendations are addressed to the head of IT, the network administrator and the specialist for plant maintenance. The question is: which solution will load the network and the team less, if both are to provide the position of an employee on the plant map.

Location from Wi-Fi signal strength uses access points that the plant already has. BLE location requires transmitters placed separately, but it does not depend on the corporate network. The difference only becomes visible in operation.

Recommendation 1: separate location from the production network infrastructure

Location accuracy from Wi-Fi signal strength is usually in the range of several metres and depends on the density of access points and on calibration. If the same network serves production, the placement of access points follows data transmission needs, not location. Adapting it for location means changes in the network that may affect critical applications.

BLE transmitters are independent of the network: they operate in the 2.4 GHz band, on batteries, and do not send data through the IT infrastructure. As a result, a change or failure of a transmitter does not affect the plant's network traffic.

Sample heartbeat traffic by number of devices

Sample heartbeat traffic by number of devicesBar chart of heartbeat frames per minute for 100, 500 and 1,000 devices at two reporting frequencies.0500100015002000frames per minuteReporting every 30 s (100 devices): 200 frames per minute200Reporting every 60 s (100 devices): 100 frames per minute100100 devicesReporting every 30 s (500 devices): 1000 frames per minute1000Reporting every 60 s (500 devices): 500 frames per minute500500 devicesReporting every 30 s (1,000 devices): 2000 frames per minute2000Reporting every 60 s (1,000 devices): 1000 frames per minute10001,000 devices
  • Reporting every 30 s
  • Reporting every 60 s
Source: Sample calculation: number of devices multiplied by the number of reports per minute

Recommendation 2: count the traffic generated by employee devices

In the InnerWeb system, an employee's device periodically sends a list of heard transmitters, signal strength, battery status and state, that is a heartbeat. These are small frames, but their number grows with the number of devices and the reporting frequency. Calculate the traffic as the product of the number of devices and the frequency before you set the network parameters for location.

Sample calculation: 500 devices report every 30 seconds, that is 1,000 frames per minute, each on the order of a few hundred bytes. For an industrial network this is usually a negligible load, but it is worth knowing rather than assuming.

Recommendation 3: plan transmission coverage separately from location coverage

An employee's device needs a route for sending heartbeats, but this route does not have to coincide with the placement of transmitters. BLE transmitters are placed along plant roads about every 100 m, and inside a building at 1 per 100 to 200 m2. The way data is sent is chosen independently, for example through the cellular network or Wi-Fi, depending on what is available in the plant.

Recommendation 4: assess the maintenance effort of both variants

Wi-Fi requires calibration and recalibration after changes to the placement of access points or the layout of the hall. BLE requires checks of transmitter batteries and updates of the map after a change in layout. The system tracks the battery status of employee devices in the heartbeat, and periodic inspection of transmitters is planned in the maintenance schedule.

The battery life of a device is not a product constant and depends on configuration and conditions, so in the maintenance plan include an inspection rather than a replacement on a fixed calendar.

Recommendation 5: check the behaviour in case of failure

With Wi-Fi location, the failure of several access points lowers accuracy or stops location across the whole area. In BLE, the position is calculated from the signals of many transmitters, so the absence of one of them worsens the result but does not remove it. In the specification, require a description of what happens to location when 1, 2 or 3 neighbouring signal sources fail.

Recommendation 6: independence from GPS and integrations

GPS does not work inside buildings and in tunnels, so it is not a solution in halls. The InnerWeb system works without GPS and is an independent system that complements the client's existing systems, including those managed by IT: access control, working time recording, HR and ERP. Add to the requirements that the integration does not require changes to the production network.

Finally, agree with the IT department who is responsible for measuring location quality after deployment. The simplest is to assign this to the maintenance team, which once a month reviews the control route and the battery status of the devices. The result is recorded in the register, and deviations from the established median and 95th percentile of the error trigger a review of the transmitter placement.

Example calculation

Heartbeat traffic in the plant network

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Number of employee devices500 pcs
Reporting frequencyevery 30 s

Result: 500 devices × 2 reports per minute = 1,000 frames per minute.

Note: Sample calculation based on the assumptions above; actual parameters are set during the pilot.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does BLE location load the plant's Wi-Fi network?

BLE transmitters do not use the Wi-Fi network, because they run on batteries in the 2.4 GHz band. The network is only used to transmit the heartbeat from employee devices, and its traffic can be calculated from the number of devices.

What is the accuracy of Wi-Fi location?

Usually in the range of several metres, depending on the density of access points and calibration. The InnerWeb BLE system achieves an average below 1 m across many measurement points.

Does location require GPS?

No. GPS does not work inside buildings, and the InnerWeb system works without GPS, relying on signals from BLE transmitters.

What about transmitter batteries?

BLE transmitters can work for years when they transmit rarely, but battery life depends on the configuration and conditions. A periodic inspection is planned in the maintenance schedule.

Sources

Calculate the network load before choosing

We will help you estimate heartbeat traffic and plan the placement of transmitters without changes to the production network. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.

Let's talk