InnerWeb
Skip to main content

FAQ: BLE vs UWB accuracy in a plant

A safety manager does not ask which technology is used. The question is whether a rescuer will reach the injured person. Below are answers to the most common questions about BLE and UWB accuracy: how many metres are enough for an SOS alarm, when centimetres matter and what an accuracy claim in a supplier's offer really means.

< 1 m
average BLE accuracy from many measurement points
Source: InnerWeb facts
< 1.5 m
accuracy in 95 facilities, 120,000 m², 11,000 transmitters
Source: InnerWeb city project
100–200 m²
floor area per transmitter inside a building
Source: InnerWeb facts

Is an accuracy of about one metre enough for an SOS alarm?

In most plants it is, because an SOS alarm should show where the rescuer starts searching, not a point on the floor accurate to the centimetre. For InnerWeb, the BLE location algorithm inside buildings reaches an average accuracy below 1 m across many measurement points. A person shown on the hall map with that error is still in the same corridor, next to the same machine or in the same cabin.

The limit is the layout of the rooms. If a thin wall separates two zones with different risk levels, an error of one metre alone may point to the wrong side of that wall. For this reason, when you buy a system, do not ask for a single number. Ask how it behaves next to walls, racks and machines in your own hall.

What does an accuracy claim below one metre in an offer mean?

Such a claim usually describes the average error from measurements taken under specific conditions. It is not a guarantee for every point in the hall. An average hides rare large deviations, so ask for the median and the 95th percentile of the error, together with a description of the building where they were measured.

A practical example: in a city project, 11,000 transmitters reached an accuracy below 1.5 m in 95 facilities with a combined area of 120,000 m². This value comes from varied buildings, so it reflects typical conditions better than a measurement in one empty hall.

Order of magnitude of accuracy (m)

Order of magnitude of accuracy (m)Horizontal bar chart comparing the order of magnitude of accuracy for UWB, BLE and Wi-Fi.01234mUWB (favourable conditions)UWB (favourable conditions): 0.15 m0.15BLE average, many pointsBLE average, many points: 1 m1BLE city projectBLE city project: 1.5 m1.5Wi-Fi (typically a few m)Wi-Fi (typically a few m): 4 m4
Source: Values from InnerWeb fact sheets; UWB and Wi-Fi are orders of magnitude (a few dozen cm, a few metres), not guarantees

When does UWB have an advantage over BLE?

UWB, as defined by IEEE 802.15.4z, measures the time of flight of the signal and, under favourable conditions, offers an accuracy of a few dozen centimetres. This matters where the position of a detail counts: guiding a robot, positioning a tool or checking the order of workstations.

The price of this accuracy is a dense grid of anchors that must be powered or cabled. In safety applications for people, where the question is which zone and which floor a person is on, a few extra centimetres rarely change the rescuer's decision.

Does higher accuracy mean more transmitters?

Yes. With both technologies, accuracy depends on the density of measurement points. In the InnerWeb system, plant roads are covered with transmitters about every 100 m, and inside a building the design assumes one transmitter per 100–200 m². Denser placement in critical places, such as cabins, passages and zones with machines, improves the result exactly where it is needed, without rebuilding the whole hall.

Why does the position not jump around if the BLE signal varies?

The worker's position is derived from the signals of many transmitters averaged on the map, not from a single strongest transmitter. A single reading may be disturbed by metal, the human body or humidity, but averaging several signals smooths out these deviations. A separate guide explains in more detail why the strongest transmitter alone misleads.

Is accuracy also given for floors?

A position on a floor is not given in metres without a source, because the documentation for the function rules out such claims. In practice, the separation of storeys is based on a map with the transmitters of each level marked, and the accuracy declaration is made for a specific storey after measurements on site.

How do you check accuracy in your own plant?

Choose 10 to 20 control points with known coordinates: entrances, hall corners, cabins, passages between halls. Walk past them with the device carried by a worker, record the position shown on the map and calculate the distance from the real point. From these distances, calculate the average, the median and the 95th percentile. This test takes a few hours and gives figures that are valid for your hall, not for the hall in a brochure.

Do walls and metal worsen the result?

Yes, in both technologies. Metal racks, machines and containers reflect and attenuate radio signals, and the human body also weakens the BLE signal. For this reason, an accuracy assessment made in an empty hall says nothing about a hall with full equipment. Repeat the control measurement after the machines are placed and during working hours, because the movement of people and vehicles changes signal propagation. In deployment practice, the map and the placement of transmitters are corrected after such a test, not left in the version from the design.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is BLE accuracy enough for fire evacuation?

Yes, if the goal is to show who was in which zone. A list of people at the assembly point and the last known zone do not require centimetres, only reliable real-time data.

Can I mix BLE and UWB in one plant?

Yes, if UWB is used for a narrow application, for example a single production line. For people across the whole site, BLE is more practical, because battery transmitters do not require cabling.

Who decides what is sufficient?

The requirement follows from the risk assessment of the plant. Accuracy is matched to the scenario: SOS, inactivity, evacuation, work in a zone.

Does accuracy drop outdoors?

On plant roads, the system uses transmitters placed about every 100 m and works without GPS, so accuracy depends on the distance between transmitters.

Let's talk about location in your plant

We will show how a system based on many BLE transmitters behaves in a hall similar to yours. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.

Let's talk