InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Visitor book versus QR register for small suppliers: full cost account

A paper visitor book costs nothing beyond a pen, so it seems the cheapest option for couriers and small suppliers. The account changes when you count what has to be copied from the book: the evacuation list and the data for the working time records. Below is a sample calculation with explicit assumptions and a description of the situations in which the book remains a sensible choice.

13 seconds
refresh interval of the evacuation list from the gate
Source: evacuation list feature card
6
groups on the evacuation list
Source: evacuation list feature card
85 hours
annual difference in the sample calculation
Source: sample calculation

What a visitor book really costs

The cost of a book is not the paper but the time of the people who use it. The receptionist writes the data at entry and exit, security searches for names after an incident, and someone responsible for records copies the contents into other summaries. Each of these activities is short, but it repeats every day.

The second cost is risk. In a book it is not visible in real time who is on site. An exit entry is sometimes skipped, and the list of people present at the moment of an evacuation has to be reconstructed from the memory of security and the notes on the pages. This is not a cash cost, but in an incident it is the most expensive one.

What a QR register provides in the same scope

The evacuation list is built from QR scans at the gate, refreshes every 13 seconds and divides people into six groups, including guests, couriers and suppliers. The printout is one page per group. Nobody needs to add anyone to the lists by hand, because the source is the entry and exit scan.

Gate events also feed the working time records, so one entry and exit scan serves both the evacuation list and the RCP. The copying from the book to a spreadsheet disappears. InnerWeb does not produce access control readers and does not replace the client's existing system; it supplements it, so the calculation concerns the software layer, not the replacement of gates.

How a QR register differs from an ordinary list in a spreadsheet

A spreadsheet requires the same manual entry as a book, only in a different tool. A QR register moves the entry to a scan, and the person performs one action: registration with a badge printout. The last list of people on site is then the current state, not the state from an hour ago.

Annual working hours: visitor book and QR register

Annual working hours: visitor book and QR registerBefore and after chart: visitor book about 190 hours a year, QR register about 105 hours.050100150200hoursVisitor book: Entries: 167 hours167 hoursVisitor book: Copying: 21 hours21 hoursVisitor book: Evacuation list: 2 hours2 hoursVisitor bookQR register: Entries: 83 hours83 hoursQR register: Copying: 0 hours0 hoursQR register: Evacuation list: 0 hours0 hoursQR register: Labels and review: 21 hours21 hoursQR register
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the Calculation section

Calculation: book versus QR register

The assumptions come from the calculation on the previous page: 20 entries a day, 250 working days, 2 minutes per book entry, 1 minute for registration in the system. Two activities that the book adds are included: copying the daily entries into a summary for security and records (5 minutes a day) and manually preparing the list of people on site for evacuation drills (30 minutes, four drills a year).

On the system side, the label check (2 minutes a day) and the weekly review (15 minutes) are included. The result: the book about 190 hours a year, the QR register about 105 hours. The difference is about 85 hours, which at a rate of 70 PLN per hour is about 5,900 PLN a year. The amount does not include printer and implementation costs.

Why the difference is larger than for registration alone

Because for registration alone the calculation compares two entries, while here it compares two processes. In the book the process ends only after the data has been copied, while in the system it ends at the scan.

When a book is enough

With a few entries a week, without a requirement for an evacuation list per group and without working time records fed from the gate, a book is sensible. Such a plant has no pressure for speed, and the cost of implementing the system would exceed the benefit.

The boundary shifts when an audit requirement appears, evacuation drills with a list of those present, or a shared register with the RCP. Then the book stops being free, because part of the work moves to other departments. It is worth counting this before a decision, not after the first inspection.

How to move from the book to a QR register

The safest approach is to run both records in parallel for one month. The book stays as a copy, and reception compares the number of entries in both places. Discrepancies usually concern people who left without a scan, and that is a good moment to clarify the gate procedure.

After a month the book is taken out of circulation for small suppliers and kept for use in the event of a power or network failure. In the plant's documents it is worth recording that the book is an emergency procedure, not a parallel register.

Example calculation

Sample calculation: book versus QR

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Small supplier entries20 a day
Working days250 days a year
Book entry / system entry2 / 1 min per entry
Copying entries from the book5 min a day
Manual list of people on site30 min x 4 drills
Labels and review in the system21 hours a year
Reception rate70 PLN per hour

Result: Book: about 190 hours a year. QR register: about 105 hours. Difference: about 85 hours, about 5,900 PLN a year, excluding printer and implementation costs.

Note: Sample calculation based on the author's assumptions, not a measurement at a specific plant. Individual quote.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does a QR register replace an access control system?

No. InnerWeb supplements the plant's existing systems and does not produce access control readers.

Where does the evacuation list come from?

From QR scans at the gate. It refreshes every 13 seconds and divides people into six groups; the printout is one page per group.

Can the book be kept as a backup copy?

Yes. It is worth describing it in the procedure as the solution for a power or network failure.

Let's count this on your numbers

We will substitute your entry times and the number of entries into the calculation and show whether the registration in the system pays off in time, or whether records and security justify it mainly.

Let's talk