Who these recommendations are for
The recommendations are addressed to a purchasing specialist or project manager who has to prepare a request for proposal for people location in a production plant, and who is not a radio engineering expert. The readers are also directors who approve the budget and want to understand the difference between the offers.
A common mistake is to compare offers on a single parameter, most often accuracy given in centimetres or metres. Location technologies differ in how they measure, the infrastructure they require and what exactly the system records, so the same parameter means different things in each of them.
Recommendation 1: start from the decision, not the technology
First write down the decisions the system is to make: an evacuation alarm, a presence check in a zone, a work permit that depends on location, a call for help. Only then add the required accuracy to them. A requirement that a person must be located within a zone is a different specification from a requirement that a person must be located to within 20 cm.
Order of magnitude of location accuracy by technology
Recommendation 2: distinguish continuous position from point events
Passive RFID records a passage through a gate or a read point, not a continuous position, and it requires the tag to be brought close to the reader. It works well as evidence of entry and exit, but it will not answer the question where the person is right now. BLE and UWB provide a continuous position, with the caveat that its accuracy depends on the infrastructure.
If the requirement is that security should know who is on the site, a point event is enough. If it is that, in case of an alarm, one must indicate where to search, a continuous position is needed.
Recommendation 3: compare accuracy using the same measure
UWB under IEEE 802.15.4z measures signal time of flight and, in favourable conditions, achieves accuracy in the range of a dozen or so centimetres. The InnerWeb system on BLE achieves an average accuracy below 1 m across many measurement points, and in a city project 11,000 transmitters delivered accuracy below 1.5 m across 95 facilities with a total area of 120,000 m2.
Include in the request an obligation to state the median and the 95th percentile of the error, because the average alone hides rare large deviations. Also include the measurement conditions: the type of hall, the mounting height and the transmitter density.
Recommendation 4: count the whole infrastructure, not only the devices
UWB requires a dense infrastructure of powered or cabled anchors. This means an installation project, cables, power supply and work during production downtime. BLE with battery transmitters requires hanging the devices and periodic checks of battery condition, without routing cables.
For BLE, the rule is 1 transmitter per 100 to 200 m2 inside a building, and transmitters about every 100 m along plant roads. For a 5,000 m2 hall this means between 25 and 50 units, which allows a quick estimate of the cost of devices and installation work in both variants.
Recommendation 5: check whether the system complements rather than replaces
InnerWeb is an independent system that complements the client's existing systems: access control, working time recording, HR and ERP. It does not manufacture or replace access control readers. Write into the request that the new system must cooperate with the existing one and not replace it, because otherwise the supplier may add the cost of replacing readers that nobody planned for.
Recommendation 6: require a pilot in a real hall
Catalogue accuracy does not reflect a hall with racking, booths and metal structures. Require a pilot in one hall or part of it, with a control route and error measurement, before signing a contract for the whole plant. Write the pass criterion for moving to deployment into the request as a number, not as a general statement about satisfactory operation.
Recommendation 7: do not count on a specific battery life
The battery life of a device is not a product constant and depends on the configuration and conditions. Battery-powered BLE transmitters can work for years when they transmit rarely, but the specific number of years depends on the transmission frequency. In the request, ask for a description of the assumptions under which the supplier states the battery life, not just the number.
Checklist
Video
Frequently asked questions
Is RFID enough to locate people in a plant?
It is enough to record entry and exit, because it registers a passage through a gate or a read point. It will not show where a person is at a given moment, so alarms that need a position require BLE or UWB.
Is it better to buy UWB for extra accuracy in reserve?
Spare accuracy has a cost: UWB requires a dense infrastructure of powered or cabled anchors. Buy as much accuracy as the most demanding operational decision on the list requires.
What should go into the accuracy request?
State the required accuracy in metres for each zone, the measurement method, the required median and 95th percentile of the error, and the hall conditions. Add the obligation to pilot with a control route.
Does InnerWeb sell card readers?
No. InnerWeb is a manufacturer of software and beacons, and it does not manufacture or replace access control readers. It integrates with the client's existing system.
Sources
Prepare a request with a pilot
We will help you formulate the requirement for people location and plan a pilot in one hall. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.
Let's talk