InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Dual-format card or readers replaced over a weekend: calculation

A dual-frequency card costs more than a single-format card, but it lets the site get through the transition period without stopping the gates. Replacing all readers over one weekend is cheaper in cash, but it demands discipline. Below is a sample calculation for the board of a site with 1 000 employees and the point at which the choice reverses.

10 000 PLN
surcharge for dual-format cards for 1 000 employees
Source: sample calculation
5 200 PLN
additional cost of replacing 20 readers over a weekend
Source: sample calculation

Two scenarios to compare

Scenario A assumes dual-frequency cards, which combine a 125 kHz layout and a 13.56 MHz layout in one body. During the transition period they work both on the old 125 kHz readers and on the new readers that support encrypted cards, so the readers can be replaced gradually, gate by gate, without announcing a switchover day.

Scenario B assumes replacing all 20 readers over one weekend. Beforehand, all employees receive new single-format cards, and on Monday morning the whole site is already on the new format. It is cheaper in media, but the entire change has to succeed within a single window.

Sample assumptions

We assume a site with 1 000 employees and 20 readers. The price of a single-format encrypted card is 12 PLN net, and of a dual-format card 22 PLN net, so the surcharge is 10 PLN per piece. Weekend crew work: 2 people for 16 hours at 120 PLN per hour. Monday reserve: 5 percent spare cards and two extra people at the gatehouse for 8 hours at 45 PLN per hour.

These are sample assumptions for the calculation, not InnerWeb prices: the site buys cards and readers from its access control supplier. Issuing cards to all employees is needed in both scenarios, so this work does not differentiate the result and is left out.

Additional cost: two scenarios

Additional cost: two scenariosComparison of additional cost: dual-format cards 10 000 PLN, weekend replacement 5 200 PLN0200040006000800010,000PLN netDual-format cards: 10,000 PLN net10,000Dual-format cardsWeekend replacement: 5200 PLN net5200Weekend replacement
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions on this page

Result: additional cost of each scenario

In scenario A the additional cost is the card surcharge: 1 000 times 10 PLN, that is 10 000 PLN. In addition, the transition period runs longer, because the old format stays active until the last wave is switched off.

In scenario B the additional cost is the weekend crew (2 people times 16 hours times 120 PLN, that is 3 840 PLN), the card reserve (50 times 12 PLN, that is 600 PLN) and the reinforced gatehouse on Monday (2 people times 8 hours times 45 PLN, that is 720 PLN). Together about 5 200 PLN.

With these assumptions scenario B is cheaper by about 4 800 PLN. This does not settle the choice, because the price does not include the risk: if part of the cards does not work on Monday, the site pays with delays and manual corrections of working time.

Break-even point

The surcharge for a dual-format card equals the cost of the weekend at a value of about 5.2 PLN per card, that is 5 200 PLN divided by 1 000 cards. If the supplier offers a surcharge below about 5 PLN, scenario A is cheaper or comparable. If it is higher, the difference has to be weighed against the cost of the risk of the switchover.

The second element of the decision is security. 125 kHz cards transmit a fixed number without authentication, so copying them is cheap. In scenario A the 125 kHz part of the dual-format card remains vulnerable until the site switches off the old format on the readers. The transition period should therefore have an end date, not just a plan.

Recommendation for the board

For a single-shift plant with one service window, a weekend replacement is usually sensible. For a multi-shift site that also works at weekends, a dual-format card buys peace of mind: there is no single switchover day, and an individual gate can be rolled back.

Whatever the choice, nothing changes on the software side: punches still reach InnerWeb from the access control system, and the number of the new card is assigned to a person through a CSV import. A punch from an unknown card goes to the queue of cards waiting to be assigned, so the first days after the change do not generate duplicate accounts.

Example calculation

Sample calculation: 1 000 employees, 20 readers

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Employees with a card1000 people
Readers to be replaced20 pcs
Single-format encrypted card12 PLN net/pc
Dual-format card22 PLN net/pc
Weekend crew2 people x 16 h x 120 PLN/hour
Card reserve on Monday5 % of cards
Gatehouse on Monday2 people x 8 h x 45 PLN/hour

Result: Scenario A (dual-format cards): 10 000 PLN. Scenario B (weekend): 3 840 + 600 + 720, together about 5 200 PLN. Break-even point: surcharge of about 5.2 PLN per card.

Note: Sample calculation. Indicative ranges from 2025–2026 deployments; individual quote.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is a dual-format card as secure as an encrypted card?

No, as long as the readers accept the 125 kHz part. That part transmits a fixed number without authentication, so security is achieved only after the old format is switched off.

Does InnerWeb have to be changed for a dual-format card?

No. The system receives punches from the access control system, and the card number is assigned to a person through a CSV import. The difference concerns only the medium and the reader.

How long does the transition period last in scenario A?

As long as the first four stages of the plan take: inventory, a trial on one gate, the wave for employees and external companies. Only the fifth stage switches off the old format.

Sources

Let's choose the transition scenario for your gates

We will prepare a calculation on your figures and agree with the access control supplier which scenario makes sense for your shift schedule.

Let's talk