The situation: three gates, two technologies
We describe a plant concept with three gates, where readers of the older 125 kHz technology are installed. Some people enter and leave through every gate, while external contractors mainly use one of them. This is a planning scenario, not a description of a completed deployment.
The head of security faces a practical problem: if new cards work only on new readers and old readers handle only old cards, replacing one gate cuts off part of the workforce. If all gates are replaced in one night, every fault stops the whole plant.
What a dual-frequency card is
Dual-frequency cards combine a 125 kHz circuit and a 13.56 MHz circuit in one body, so during the transition period they work on both old and new readers. The 125 kHz circuit transmits a fixed number without authentication, so copying it is cheap. The 13.56 MHz circuit, in the MIFARE DESFire EV2 or EV3 standard (ISO/IEC 14443), uses AES encryption and mutual authentication between the card and the reader.
This leads to a conclusion about the level of protection: a transition card is not safer than an old card at a gate that still reads only the 125 kHz circuit. The security gain appears only when the gate is switched to a reader that supports the new circuit and the old format is switched off at that gate.
New and old readers after each gate
- New
- Old
Order of gate replacement
The order below is a planning assumption for three gates. We adjust it to the traffic on each shift.
- Everyone receives dual-frequency cards before any gate is switched.
- The gate with the lowest traffic gets new readers first and acts as the pilot.
- After an observation period we switch the second gate, and external contractors are handled on it at a separate date.
- The third, busiest gate changes its readers last.
- Only after all gates are switched do we disable reading of the 125 kHz circuit.
The role of InnerWeb: punches from both technologies in one time recording system
InnerWeb is a software producer and does not replace access control readers. It integrates with the client's existing access control system. For time recording it does not matter which frequency the card was read at, as long as the access control system passes the punch with the reader identifier and the person.
The punch reaches InnerWeb as an HTTPS POST message from the access control server. It contains the time from the controller, the reader identifier, the person and the card number in the form object_code-number. The event identifier protects working days from distortion caused by the offline queue or by resending.
Two cards for one person
If someone carries both an old and a new card during the transition period, it is essential to assign both numbers to one personnel number. Then a punch with either card counts as a punch by the same person.
Unknown card
A punch from an unknown card goes to the "card to be assigned" queue, instead of creating an account from an unknown punch. This is safer during mass card distribution.
Sample calculation: how the share of old readers falls
Assuming 20 readers at gates and doors (sample calculation), the split across three gates and internal doors may look as follows: after the first gate 5 new and 15 old readers, after the second 11 new and 9 old, after the third 20 new. The numbers are a planning assumption, not data from a deployment.
Such a calculation lets you estimate how many hours of installation crew work each stage requires, and when the security team can roll back to the previous state.
Pitfalls to know in advance
The first pitfall is the order: replacing readers before cards are distributed. The second is external contractors who receive cards later than the workforce and arrive at a blocked gate. The third is the lack of a card export from the access control system to personnel numbers, which creates a wave of cards to be assigned after the replacement. It is worth agreeing this with the access control vendor before integration.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Is a dual-frequency card secure?
The MIFARE DESFire circuit at 13.56 MHz is encrypted, but the 125 kHz circuit still transmits a fixed number. The full security gain comes only when reading of the 125 kHz circuit is switched off.
Does time recording need changes for the new cards?
No, as long as punches continue to arrive from the access control system with the person and the reader identifier. New card numbers are assigned to people by a CSV import.
Does InnerWeb supply cards and readers?
No. Cards and readers are supplied by the access control vendor or another hardware supplier. InnerWeb integrates with the access control system.
Sources
Plan the reader replacement gate by gate
We will show how punches from both technologies feed one time recording register. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.
Let's talk