InnerWeb
Skip to main content

When a QR badge is enough and when an encrypted card

A QR badge and an encrypted card do not compete within one plant. They serve different groups and zones. Below are recommendations for the security director: where to base entry on the InnerWeb QR badge, and where to keep the encrypted card from the access control system that runs alongside it.

300
badges a month in the sample calculation
Source: sample calculation
5 min
time to replace a lost QR badge by security
Source: sample calculation

Division of roles within one plant

InnerWeb does not produce readers or access control cards. The system receives card swipe events from the KD access control system and links them with qualifications, work permits, attendance and time recording. In practice an encrypted card and a QR badge can therefore work side by side: the first in zones that require strong authentication of the medium, the second where what matters is a short issuing time and simplicity for people who enter for a single day.

The recommendations concern the division of zones and groups, not the choice of a card supplier. The choice of card technology belongs to the plant and the KD vendor.

Six recommendations

General rule: the shorter the stay and the lower the risk of theft, the closer to a QR badge. The longer the employment and the higher the value of the protected assets, the closer to an encrypted card.

1. Visitors and short visits: QR

For a person who comes in for a few hours, personalising an encrypted card is too costly. A QR badge comes from a single label print, and its token is random: 32 random bytes, 64 hexadecimal characters, 256 bits.

2. General zones and access roads: QR with the verdict

Where the decision depends on training and qualifications rather than on strong authentication of the medium, a scan at the gate is enough. The verdict has four components: no overdue training, no missing qualifications for dangerous work, a work permit in progress for today, and an active account.

3. Zones with a high risk of theft: encrypted card

A store of valuable components, a server room and rooms with documentation require a medium that is harder to copy than a printed code. Here we recommend an encrypted card from the KD system, and InnerWeb adds the swipe event to qualifications and attendance.

4. Permanent staff: card, with QR as a backup

For people who come in every day, a card has the advantage of convenience and resistance to copying a photo. Keep the QR badge as a backup route for when the card is lost and replacement takes time at the pass office.

5. Contractors: depending on the length of the contract

A contractor working for two days gets a QR badge. A group working for a quarter may get a card if the plant wants to include it in its own KD system. The boundary is a cost decision for the plant, not a requirement of the InnerWeb system.

6. Revocation on both routes

A card revoked at the gate no longer identifies its former holder and gives the same answer, "unknown code", as a code that never existed. Keep one process: the same reception desk revokes both the card and the badge, and the history stays in the system.

Assumptions of the sample calculation

Assumptions of the sample calculationChart: 300 badges a month, and replacing a badge takes about 5 minutes.0100200300count or minutesBadges per month: 300 count or minutes300Badges per monthMinutes to replace a QR badge: 5 count or minutes5Minutes to replace a QR badge
Source: Sample calculation; values to be replaced with the plant's data

Sample workload calculation

For orientation, assume a plant that issues 300 QR badges a month to visitors and contractors, with a label printer already at reception. Replacing a lost QR badge takes one print and about 5 minutes of security staff time. Replacing a lost encrypted card requires a medium, personalisation and a visit to the pass office, so the time is longer and should be confirmed by measurement at the plant. The values are assumptions to be replaced with the plant's own data.

How to reach the decision at board level

It is best to draw the plant plan with three colours: QR zones, card zones and mixed zones. For each zone, record the group of people, the frequency of entries and the value of the protected assets. Such a sheet closes the discussion about a single solution for the whole plant and shows how many cards actually need to be personalised.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does InnerWeb supply encrypted cards?

No. InnerWeb does not produce readers or access control cards. It receives swipe events from the plant's KD system and links them with qualifications and attendance.

Can a card and a QR badge work at the same time?

Yes. An encrypted card in high-risk zones, a QR badge for visitors and short visits, and both routes feed a single attendance view.

What about a revoked card?

At the gate it no longer identifies its former holder and gives the answer "unknown code", the same as for a code that never existed.

Let's divide the zones of your plant

We will help you plan where a QR badge is enough and where a card from the KD system is needed. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.

Let's talk