InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Hybrid: QR for guests, encrypted card for staff, calculation with ranges

The purchasing department does not ask whether QR is better than a card, but how much a layout costs in which each group gets a medium suited to how often they visit. Below is a method for counting a hybrid with explicit assumptions and ranges, for 300 QR badges issued monthly to guests and contractors.

720 PLN
monthly cost of guest handling in the hybrid
Source: sample calculation
3,270 PLN
monthly cost with temporary cards
Source: sample calculation
1,650-3,450 PLN
range of the monthly difference
Source: sample calculation

What the hybrid layout consists of

In a hybrid layout the staff keep encrypted cards from the existing access control system, while guests and contractors receive QR badges printed on a label. InnerWeb does not produce readers or access control cards. It receives card swipe events from the KD system and links them with qualifications, permits, attendance and working time recording, so both media can work side by side in one solution.

For purchasing this means that the existing card infrastructure does not have to be replaced. The costs that change concern only the handling of guests: issuing, returning and losing temporary media.

What changes in costs and what stays

The staff costs are the same in both variants: the cards already exist and the KD system handles them. The comparison therefore comes down to guests and contractors. In the card variant guests receive temporary cards, which must be issued, collected and recorded. In the hybrid variant they receive QR badges printed on a label, and the code also arrives in the invitation e-mail.

Printing labels requires a printer, which is often already part of the reception equipment, and label paper. For caution the calculation assumes a cost for the label with printer ribbon, not zero.

  • Stays: staff cards, readers, the KD system and its maintenance.
  • Changes: the guest medium, issuing and return time, losses.
  • Added: label and printing time on the reception side.

Monthly handling cost for 300 guests: three scenarios

Monthly handling cost for 300 guests: three scenariosBar chart: monthly cost of temporary cards 2,670, 3,270 and 3,870 PLN, and of QR badges 1,020, 720 and 420 PLN.01000200030004000PLNTemporary card (Cautious): 2670 PLN2670 PLNQR badge (Cautious): 1020 PLN1020 PLNCautiousTemporary card (Base): 3270 PLN3270 PLNQR badge (Base): 720 PLN720 PLNBaseTemporary card (Favourable to QR): 3870 PLN3870 PLNQR badge (Favourable to QR): 420 PLN420 PLNFavourable to QR
  • Temporary card
  • QR badge
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the section Assumptions and base result

Assumptions and base result

We assume 300 guests and contractors per month, which matches the sample assumption of the badge calculation. The guard's working time costs 1 PLN per minute. Temporary card: 10 minutes of handling for issue and return, and 5 percent losses at a card price of 18 PLN, that is 0.90 PLN per visit, in total 10.90 PLN per guest. QR badge: 2 minutes of handling and 0.40 PLN for the label, in total 2.40 PLN per guest.

With 300 guests per month the card variant costs 3,270 PLN and the hybrid 720 PLN. The difference is 2,550 PLN per month, that is 30,600 PLN per year. All values are samples and are meant to be replaced with the plant's data.

Ranges: pessimistic and optimistic scenario

Purchasing rarely gets a single number, because the parameters vary. In a cautious scenario we assume that handling a card takes 8 minutes and a QR badge 3 minutes. This gives 8.90 PLN against 3.40 PLN per guest, that is 2,670 PLN against 1,020 PLN per month and a difference of 1,650 PLN.

In a scenario favourable to QR, handling a card takes 12 minutes and a QR badge 1 minute. The cost per guest is 12.90 PLN against 1.40 PLN, that is 3,870 PLN against 420 PLN per month and a difference of 3,450 PLN. The range of the difference is therefore from 1,650 to 3,450 PLN per month, and the base result of 2,550 PLN lies in the middle.

What changes the result most

The handling time of a guest at issue and return of the card has the strongest effect, because it is multiplied by all guests. The loss of cards has a smaller share, as long as it does not rise above a few percent. The price of the label can in practice be ignored, because it is an order of magnitude lower than the cost of working time.

Cost per guest, base scenario

Cost per guest, base scenarioCost per guest: temporary card 10.90 PLN, QR badge 2.40 PLN.02.557.51012.5PLNTemporary cardTemporary card: 10.9 PLN10.9QR badgeQR badge: 2.4 PLN2.4
Source: Sample calculation: handling 10 and 2 minutes at 1 PLN, label 0.40 PLN, card losses 0.90 PLN

Conditions to check before buying

The hybrid is not free organisationally: it requires a label printer at reception, a scanner at the gate or a tablet, and a decision on who prints the badges. Label printing sits behind login in the guard or administrator role, because the print page contains badge tokens in the print addresses.

Bulk guest invitations have a limit of 144 addresses per request and 5 requests per 13 minutes per user. The limit stops a script on a hijacked session and does not get in the way on a day of mass invitations. When planning a day with many guests, it is worth checking whether this limit is sufficient for the size of the group.

  • Label printer at reception or with the guard.
  • Scanner or tablet at the gate and at the guest training point.
  • Guard role for printing labels.
  • Integration of events from the staff KD system.

How to prepare the purchase request

The purchase request should contain three elements: assumptions from measurements at the plant, ranges with three scenarios, and a list of costs that do not change. Such a document makes it possible to compare offers without hidden assumptions. InnerWeb is a software producer, not a device producer, so the quotation concerns the licence and implementation, and the plant buys the hardware from any supplier.

The amounts in this article are samples and do not constitute an offer. Implementation prices are quoted individually and concern the licence and integration, not the devices.

Example calculation

Cost of handling guests and contractors: temporary card vs QR badge

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Guests and contractors300 persons/month
Labour cost1 PLN/min
Card handling (issue and return)10 min
Losses of temporary cards5 %
Card price18 PLN
QR badge handling2 min
Label with printer ribbon0.40 PLN

Result: Temporary card: 10.90 PLN per guest, 3,270 PLN per month. QR badge: 2.40 PLN per guest, 720 PLN per month. Difference: 2,550 PLN per month, 30,600 PLN per year. Range of the difference: 1,650 to 3,450 PLN per month.

Note: Sample calculation. Values to be replaced with the plant's data, times to be completed by measurement. Indicative ranges; implementation is quoted individually.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does the hybrid require replacing readers?

No. Staff cards and readers remain in the KD system. InnerWeb receives card swipe events from that system and does not produce readers.

Where do the values for the calculation come from?

From the reception register and a measurement of handling time. The figures in the article are samples: 300 guests per month, 1 PLN per minute, 5 percent losses.

Are 144 addresses in a bulk invitation enough for a day of a large visit?

A bulk invitation accepts up to 144 addresses per request and 5 requests per 13 minutes per user. For larger groups the invitations are sent in several requests, within these limits.

Let's prepare the hybrid calculation on your data

Together we will replace the assumptions with data from reception and prepare three scenarios for the purchase request.

Let's talk