InnerWeb
Skip to main content

FAQ: QR vs encrypted card, questions from the board about the choice

The board rarely asks about the technology, more often about risk, cost and dependence on the supplier. Below are answers to the questions that come up when choosing between a QR code and an encrypted card, given from the position of a software supplier that does not produce readers and has no interest in selling hardware.

4
components of the gate verdict
Source: feature card
0
readers in the InnerWeb offer
Source: company card

Does InnerWeb replace our access control system

No. InnerWeb does not produce readers or access control cards and does not replace the existing system. It receives card swipe events from the plant's access control system and links them with qualifications, permits, attendance and working time recording. For the board this is an important point: choosing the medium does not require discarding the investment in readers or changing the access control supplier.

In practice an encrypted card and a QR badge can work side by side. The card stays where it is already deployed, and the QR appears where issuing card media is uneconomical or too slow.

Which groups suit QR and which suit a card

The criterion is the lifetime of the medium and the number of issues. Staff who come in every day for years justify the cost of an encrypted card and its personalisation. A guest for a single visit, a contractor for a few days or a delivery driver are people for whom a card would require issuing, collecting and recording its return.

A QR badge for such people is printed as a label, and the code also arrives in the invitation e-mail. The choice does not have to be uniform across the whole plant, which is why a question about a hybrid layout is usually more accurate than a question about one medium for everyone.

  • Permanent staff: encrypted card from the existing access control system.
  • Guest, driver, service technician: QR badge with a short validity period.
  • Contractor for several weeks: QR or a temporary card, depending on the number of people and the risk.

Is QR less secure than a card

It depends on the threat. An encrypted card, for example one based on MIFARE DESFire and the ISO/IEC 14443 standard, resists cloning of the medium better than older low-frequency cards. A QR code as an image can always be copied, so its security rests on other mechanisms: a random token, revocation, a record of attempts and the gate verdict.

The badge token is generated from 32 random bytes, and revocation issues a new code while leaving the old one in the history as revoked. A revoked badge at the gate gives the same answer "unknown code" as a non-existent code. The board should therefore compare not the medium alone but the whole chain: issue, use, loss, revocation.

Who makes the entry decision: a person or the system

The scan at the gate is a decision of the system, not an action of the guard. From the current verdict and the state "on site" the system determines entry, exit or refusal, without a separate "let in" button. Every attempt, including refusals, is recorded, so the board and the auditor have a trace rather than an oral account.

The verdict consists of four components: no overdue trainings, no missing qualifications for dangerous work, an approved permit for today and an active account. The card swipe in the access control system behaves differently, as it usually confirms the identity of the holder of the medium. Combining both events in one place makes it possible to answer whether a person with a valid card may enter this zone today.

What about training tablets and identity confirmation

Scanning a badge on a training tablet logs nothing by itself. The tablet shows the first name, last name and company of the code owner, and the training starts only after confirmation by a person. As a result, accidentally scanning someone else's badge does not start a course in the name of another person.

This is a deliberately cautious solution: the cost is one touch on the screen, and the gain is no wrong entries in the training documentation. An encrypted card, if it were to be used in a similar place, would require a reader at the tablet, which the plant may not have.

What dependence on the supplier risk do we take

A supplier that sells readers and cards has a natural interest in the plant buying more. InnerWeb is a software producer, not a device producer, so the recommendation of a medium does not depend on margin on hardware. The board may ask the supplier openly what share of reader sales it has and compare the answers.

The plant keeps its access control system, its cards and its readers. It prints QR badges on a label printer, which is often already part of the reception equipment. Leaving the solution does not require replacing infrastructure, because card access control keeps working in an independent system.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Can we keep encrypted cards and add QR only for guests?

Yes. InnerWeb receives card swipe events from the access control system, so the encrypted card stays for staff and the QR badge serves guests and contractors. Both media work side by side.

Does InnerWeb supply cards or readers for the gate?

No. InnerWeb is a software producer and does not produce or replace readers and access control cards. It integrates with the plant's existing access control system.

Is there a separate button to let a person in?

No. The scan is a decision: the system determines entry, exit or refusal from the current verdict and the state "on site". Every attempt, including refusals, is recorded.

What happens to a card or code after revocation?

A revoked code or card does not identify its former holder. At the gate it gives the same answer "unknown code" as a non-existent code.

Let's plan the media layout for your plant

We will go through the groups of people, the existing access control system and the medium loss scenarios together, then show what the gate verdict looks like.

Let's talk