InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Lost QR badge vs lost encrypted card: replacement cost calculation

The head of the pass office knows that lost media are a daily occurrence, but rarely has the cost of replacement calculated. Below is a sample calculation for a plant issuing 300 QR badges per month to guests and contractors, with assumptions that can be replaced with the plant's own measurements.

81 PLN
monthly cost of QR badge replacements
Source: sample calculation
645 PLN
monthly cost of encrypted card replacements
Source: sample calculation
6,768 PLN
annual difference under the assumptions
Source: sample calculation

What the cost of replacing a medium consists of

The cost of a lost medium does not end with the price of the plastic. It consists of the material, the time of the person who issues the replacement, the time of the person who collects it, and the risk during the period when the lost medium is still active. The first three can be counted, the fourth requires a decision on how quickly the medium is revoked.

For a QR badge the replacement is one label print and about 5 minutes of guard time, and the label printer and paper are usually already part of the reception equipment. For an encrypted card the replacement requires a medium, personalisation and a visit to the pass office. The times in both cases should be completed with a measurement at the plant, because they differ depending on how the work is organised.

  • Material: label or card medium together with personalisation.
  • Issuing time: guard or pass office.
  • Time of the person who loses the medium: walking to the office, waiting.
  • Risk window: time from loss to revocation.

Assumptions of the sample calculation

The calculation rests on assumptions that are clearly marked as sample values. The plant issues 300 QR badges per month to guests and contractors. We assume that 5 percent of them are lost or destroyed, that is 15 replacements per month. Each value is shown in the calculation table, and the head of the pass office may replace it with their own.

The guard's hourly cost is taken as 60 PLN, that is 1 PLN per minute. The label together with the printer ribbon costs 0.40 PLN. An encrypted card with personalisation costs 18 PLN, and its replacement takes 25 minutes of pass office work. All amounts are sample values and are meant to show the method, not a price list.

Monthly replacement cost at 15 losses

Monthly replacement cost at 15 lossesComparison of monthly replacement cost: encrypted card 645 PLN, QR badge 81 PLN.0200400600800PLNEncrypted card: Monthly cost: 645 PLN645 PLNEncrypted cardQR badge: Monthly cost: 81 PLN81 PLNQR badge
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the section Assumptions of the sample calculation

Result: monthly and annual cost

With 15 replacements per month a QR badge costs 15 times (5 PLN of labour plus 0.40 PLN for the label), that is 81 PLN per month. An encrypted card costs 15 times (18 PLN for the medium plus 25 PLN of labour), that is 645 PLN per month. The difference is 564 PLN per month, that is 6,768 PLN per year.

The working time looks similar: 75 minutes per month for QR against 375 minutes for the card. The difference of 300 minutes is five hours per month that the guard and the pass office can spend on other tasks.

What this calculation does not cover

It does not cover the time of the person who loses the medium, nor the costs of the access control system, which operates for the staff in any case. It also does not cover returns: guest QR badges do not need to be recovered, because the token can be revoked, while cards are often recovered. The plant adds these values in its own version.

Ranges: how the result changes with other assumptions

The result is most sensitive to two values: the percentage of losses and the time of card replacement. At a loss rate of 2 percent, that is 6 replacements per month, the cost of QR is 32.40 PLN and of the card 258 PLN. At 10 percent, that is 30 replacements, the figures are 162 PLN and 1,290 PLN respectively. The proportion between the media stays similar, and only the scale changes.

For the head of the pass office the most important point is that the QR advantage in case of loss comes from quick replacement and the lack of personalisation, not from a lower price of the label itself. If replacing a card at the plant is faster than 25 minutes, the advantage shrinks. That is why it is worth measuring the replacement time on a dozen or so cases.

Working time for replacements per month

Working time for replacements per monthBars: QR badge 75 minutes per month, encrypted card 375 minutes per month.0100200300400minQR badge: 75 min75 minQR badgeEncrypted card: 375 min375 minEncrypted card
Source: Sample calculation: 15 replacements of 5 minutes and of 25 minutes

How to separate cost from risk

The replacement cost is one side of the decision. The other side is the risk that a lost medium is used. In InnerWeb, revoking a badge issues a new token, and the old one stays in the history as revoked. The rule "at most one active badge per person" is enforced by a transaction with a row lock, so after the replacement the previous code does not work next to the new one.

An encrypted card is harder to clone, but revoking a card in the KD system depends on the plant's procedure and the KD supplier. InnerWeb does not produce cards or readers and does not replace the KD system, so for the staff the card remains in the existing system. The calculation concerns guests and contractors, for whom the QR badge is a realistic alternative.

Example calculation

Cost of replacing lost media: QR badge and encrypted card

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Issued QR badges300 pcs/month
Loss and destruction rate5 %
Replacements per month15 pcs
QR badge replacement time5 min
Encrypted card replacement time25 min
Labour cost1 PLN/min
Label with printer ribbon0.40 PLN
Encrypted card with personalisation18 PLN

Result: QR badge: 81 PLN per month. Encrypted card: 645 PLN per month. Difference: 564 PLN per month, 6,768 PLN per year.

Note: Sample calculation. Values to be replaced with the plant's data, times to be completed by measurement. This is not a price list or an offer.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does the calculation also cover staff?

No. Staff remain on encrypted cards in the existing KD system. The calculation compares replacing media for guests and contractors.

Where do the values of 5 percent and 25 minutes come from?

They are sample assumptions that show the method. The replacement time of a badge (about 5 minutes) and of a card must be measured at the plant, and the loss rate counted from the plant's own data.

Does a QR badge require buying readers?

It is not part of the InnerWeb offer: the company does not sell readers. The code is read by a scanner at the gate or by a tablet, and a label printer is usually part of the reception equipment.

Let's count it on your plant's data

We will replace the assumptions with your measurements and show how much time the pass office and the guard spend on medium replacements.

Let's talk