InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Choosing a Beacon Version for a Hot or Cold Hall: 6 Recommendations

The chief power engineer of a heavy industry plant selects the version of radio beacon for halls where the temperature swings from frost to the heat of furnaces. We have gathered six recommendations: temperature range, Ex zones, batteries, mounting place, interval and service. We justify them with data from the cards and with explicit assumptions.

-40 to 60 °C
operating temperature range of the radio beacon
Source: card
4 to 5 years
until cell replacement at a 500 ms interval
Source: card

Who these recommendations are for

We address the recommendations to the chief power engineer, the maintenance manager and the integrator, who select the beacon version for halls with extreme conditions. They apply to a heavy industry plant where hot zones, cold zones and potentially explosive zones exist side by side.

The recommendations do not replace the zone classification project or the risk assessment of the plant. They show the order of decisions, in which the choice of version is the second step, not the first.

Recommendation 1: temperature range first, everything else later

The operating temperature range of the radio beacon is from -40 to 60 degrees Celsius. Start by measuring the real temperatures at the mounting point: under the hall roof, next to furnaces, the temperature can clearly exceed the average for the hall.

If the measurement shows values at the limit or above 60 degrees, do not hang the beacon at that place: move it to a cooler point where the signal still covers the people's route. The position is calculated from several beacons, so shifting a point by a few metres usually does not break the coverage.

Time to cell replacement depending on the interval (midpoint of the range)

Time to cell replacement depending on the interval (midpoint of the range)Bar chart: 4.5 years at 500 ms, 3 years at 250 ms, 2 years at 150 ms.012345years500 ms: 4.5 years4.5 years500 ms250 ms: 3 years3 years250 ms150 ms: 2 years2 years150 ms
Source: Query and test card; for 500 ms the value 4.5 is the midpoint of the 4 to 5 year range

Recommendation 2: the design, not the sales team, sets the Ex zones

The radio beacon has an ATEX version approved for zones 2 and 22. For zones 1 and 21, certification is commissioned for the needs of the client's installation, with no promised date. The range of zones for beacons has to be verified against the zone classification project of the plant.

For each hall, obtain a list of zones from an explosion protection specialist and mark them on the drawing. Only on this basis assign the version to the mounting places. We describe this in more detail in the implementation notes on Ex zone classification.

Recommendation 3: plan batteries for years, service for shutdowns

Radio beacons run on industrial batteries for several years. With an advertising interval of 500 ms, the average current draw is 16 µA and the cells last 4 to 5 years; at 250 ms it is 31 µA and about 3 years; at 150 ms it is 50 µA and about 2 years.

In a hot hall choose a longer interval if the accuracy allows it, because replacing cells in such a place is costly and risky. Enter the cell replacement into the shutdown schedule, not into current operations.

Recommendation 4: do not mix versions without marking them on the map

Standard and ATEX beacons may coexist in one hall. Each of them must have an unambiguous identifier in the system and a physical marking, because two physically different beacons with the same identifier are recognised as one entry.

With such an error, correcting the entry only moves the mistake to another place, and a person's route on the map shows jumps. The conclusion: the physical label and the system entry are one thing, and they are kept consistent together.

Recommendation 5: count the total cost, not the price of a unit

In the comparative calculation, the own cost of a standard beacon was estimated at 25 to 35 PLN, and of an ATEX version at about 75 PLN. This is an estimate, not a price list; individual quotation applies. The difference in unit price may be smaller than the cost of one additional service visit.

Therefore ask not only about the price of the beacon, but also about the number of installations, service windows and the cell replacement interval. Choosing the more expensive version for the whole hall rarely makes sense when the Ex zone covers only part of it.

Recommendation 6: check after installation, not only before

Coverage measurements are carried out after installation and attached to the acceptance protocol. In halls with extreme temperatures, repeat the measurement after the first winter or the first summer of operation, to check whether conditions have shifted the assumptions.

  • measure the temperature at the mounting point
  • obtain the list of Ex zones for the hall
  • select the interval according to the required accuracy and the cell replacement window
  • mark beacons physically and in the system with the same identifier
  • schedule service for shutdowns
  • repeat the coverage measurement after the season of extreme temperatures

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is one type of beacon enough for the whole plant?

Usually not. The ATEX version approved for zones 2 and 22 is used where the zone classification requires it, and the standard version is sufficient in the remaining places.

What about places above 60 degrees?

Do not mount a beacon there. Move the point to a cooler place, using the fact that the position is calculated from the signals of several beacons.

Who commissions certification for zones 1 and 21?

Certification is commissioned for the needs of the client's installation, with no promised date. It requires arrangements with the zone designer and the integrator.

Let us match the version to your halls

Talk to the InnerWeb team about choosing beacons for hot halls, cold halls and Ex zones. We will prepare a comparison based on your list of zones.

Let's talk