InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Broadcast interval and transmitter cell replacement cost in a steelworks over 5 years

The purchasing department is hearing a proposal to shorten the broadcast interval to 250 ms and asks what the plant gains and what it loses. A shorter interval does not extend the life of the cells, it shortens it: the current draw rises from 16 to 31 µA, and the period until replacement falls from 4 to 5 years to about 3. Below is a calculation of the effects for 200 transmitters over 5 years, with explicit assumptions.

16 µA
average draw at 500 ms
Source: product card
31 µA
average draw at 250 ms
Source: product card
about 3 years
until cell replacement at 250 ms
Source: product card

What the broadcast interval really changes

The broadcast interval is the gap between successive messages from a transmitter. The shorter it is, the more often the device sends a signal, so the phone or watch has more samples to average the position from, but the transmitter uses more energy. In current consumption measurements, a 500 ms interval gave an average draw of 16 µA and 4 to 5 years until the cells need replacing. A 250 ms interval gave 31 µA and about 3 years, and a 150 ms interval gave 50 µA and about 2 years.

It is worth clarifying the terms, because purchasing questions often mix them up. The interval of the transmitter affects the battery life of the transmitter. The battery life of the watch is a separate parameter: in location mode it is 13 to 17 days in the factory configuration and more than 30 days after listening optimisation, and in the mode with motion detection it is 3 to 7 days. Both values must be assessed separately.

Calculation of cell replacements for 200 transmitters

We assume 200 transmitters and a 5-year horizon. At a 500 ms interval, the cells are replaced once in this period (after 4 to 5 years), which means 200 transmitter replacements. At 250 ms, the replacement falls after about 3 years, so there is still one within 5 years, which means 200 replacements, but the first one comes 1 to 2 years earlier and the second would fall after about 6 years, just beyond the horizon. At 150 ms, replacements fall after about 2 and 4 years, which means 400 transmitter replacements.

The conclusion for purchasing is surprisingly simple: over a 5-year horizon, a 250 ms interval does not double the number of replacements compared with 500 ms, but it moves the first one 1 to 2 years earlier and increases the risk that the second falls in the early years of the next contract. Only the 150 ms interval doubles the number of replacements in this horizon.

  • 500 ms: 1 replacement in 5 years, 200 transmitter replacements,
  • 250 ms: 1 replacement in 5 years (after about 3 years), 200 transmitter replacements,
  • 150 ms: 2 replacements in 5 years (after about 2 and 4 years), 400 transmitter replacements.

Transmitter replacements over 5 years for 200 transmitters

Transmitter replacements over 5 years for 200 transmittersBar chart: 200 replacements at 500 ms, 200 at 250 ms, 400 at 150 ms within 5 years0100200300400replacements500 ms: 200 replacements200500 ms250 ms: 200 replacements200250 ms150 ms: 400 replacements400150 ms
Source: Sample calculation based on cell life of 4 to 5, about 3 and about 2 years

Who bears the replacement cost and how to write it into the contract

Replacing transmitter cells is a service task. One maintenance offer included it in the subscription at about every 4 years. If the vendor takes on replacement within the subscription, shortening the interval changes the cost of service, not the cost to the plant, and this is the point to negotiate: whether the subscription rate depends on the interval or is fixed.

For the plant director, the cost of reaching the transmitter often matters more than the price of the cells. In a steelworks, transmitters above cranes, on platforms and near hot zones need service windows and work-at-height authorisations. The cost of one replacement is therefore in practice the cost of access, not of the cell, which is why the number of replacements over the horizon matters more than the price of the battery.

When a shorter interval makes sense

A 250 ms interval is worth considering where the process requires fast location response, for example in zones where a worker moves near internal transport and the position should be refreshed more often. In areas where people work in one place or movement is slow, a 500 ms interval is sufficient and saves the cells.

A practical solution is to differentiate the interval by zone: shorter where risk and movement dynamics are high, longer in warehouses, offices and on low-traffic roads. This reduces the number of replacements without losing responsiveness where it is needed. The decision should be recorded in the placement design and verified during the post-installation measurement.

Arguments for the conversation with purchasing

The purchasing department will accept a shorter interval if it sees three numbers: by how much the current draw rises (from 16 to 31 µA, almost twice as much), how much earlier the replacement falls (from 4 to 5 years to about 3), and who bears it. Without these, the proposal will be rejected as a cost without a benefit.

It is also fair to acknowledge that the battery life data come from measurements and depend on temperature and cell type. At low temperatures the cell capacity drops, so for cold mounting points the replacement schedule should be assumed more cautiously and confirmed with the service team.

Example calculation

Number of cell replacements over 5 years for 200 transmitters

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Number of transmitters200 pcs
Cell life at 500 ms4 to 5 years
Cell life at 250 ms3 years
Cell life at 150 ms2 years
Horizon5 years

Result: 500 ms: 200 transmitter replacements. 250 ms: 200 (first after about 3 years). 150 ms: 400 (after about 2 and 4 years).

Note: Sample calculation. Battery life depends on temperature and cell type; the cost of replacement depends on access to the transmitter and the scope of the subscription.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does a shorter interval extend cell life?

No, it shortens it. The current draw rises from 16 µA at 500 ms to 31 µA at 250 ms, and the time to replacement falls from 4 to 5 years to about 3.

Does the interval affect the watch battery life?

The watch battery life is a separate parameter: 13 to 17 days in location mode in the factory configuration, and more than 30 days after listening optimisation.

Is cell replacement included in the subscription?

In one offer, yes, at about every 4 years. The scope must be confirmed in the request for quotation.

Can different intervals be used in one hall?

Yes. Differentiating by zone is practical: shorter where movement is dynamic, longer in quiet areas.

Let's match the interval to the zones of your plant

InnerWeb will show how to differentiate the broadcast interval in a hall and will calculate the replacement schedule for the indicated mounting points.

Let's talk