InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Training QR code: risk of someone else's number

The link and QR code of an additional training are assigned to the training, not to a person, and by entering a register number you can enter as someone else. This is a consciously accepted risk of entry without an account. Before the code is sent, the information security team should establish for which trainings this risk is acceptable and for which it is not.

1 of 3
identifiers are enough at the additional training gate
0
accounts required to enter the training gate

What the risk is

An active additional training can be shared by link and QR code. The link is assigned to the training, not to a person, because the training is distributed widely before participants are known. At the gate a person identifies themselves by register number, a company email address or a phone number, without creating an account.

The consequence is obvious: anyone who knows another employee's register number can pass the training in their name. This risk also applies to the QR code of an additional training. The vendor consciously accepted it, because the alternative would be requiring an account, which would cut off employees without email and phone.

What to settle before sending

The first decision: is the register number common knowledge at the plant? If it appears on an ID badge or a payslip envelope, practically anyone can use it. The second: how much weight the training carries. An additional training does not block entry, so a fraudulently obtained result does not increase physical risk, but it does change the data in the record.

The third decision: who knows the QR code. A code posted on the board in the canteen is known to the whole workforce; a code sent only to one crew is known only to that crew. The fourth: whether the training should be linked to the attendance list in the room, where the trainer confirms physical attendance.

Level of identity control by training variant

Level of identity control by training variantHorizontal bar chart comparing three variants: QR code and number, QR code with the Is it you question, and room session with signature.0123scale 1-3 (qualitative rating)QR code and numberQR code and number: 1 scale 1-3 (qualitative rating)1QR code with Is it you?QR code with Is it you?: 2 scale 1-3 (qualitative rating)2Room session with signatureRoom session with signature: 3 scale 1-3 (qualitative rating)3
Source: Qualitative rating by the author based on

Mitigating measures

After entering through the link with a number, the system asks: Is it you? Only after confirmation does it start the next required training for that person. This question does not stop deliberate impersonation, but it protects against mistakes on a shared device.

We recommend three organizational measures. First, for trainings of higher weight use room sessions with a signature on screen. Second, limit the reach of the QR code to the target group. Third, do not use a number that is printed on an ID badge as the only confirmation of identity.

For the audit, record the decision: which trainings may be passed from the code, what risk the plant accepts and who is responsible for it. Such a decision is evidence that the risk was considered.

Implementation pitfalls

A common mistake is treating an additional training like a mandatory one and forcing passes through the QR code. Then the incentive to pass for a colleague grows. The second mistake is giving employees no information that passing for someone else breaks the plant's rules.

The third mistake is leaving out employees without email and phone: for them the QR code and register number are sometimes the only channel. Withdrawing the code would worsen their access, so it is better to secure the process than to close it.

Information security checklist

Before sending the code, settle the classification of the training, the reach of the code, where it is posted and the date of the decision review. After a month, check the attendance and pass lists for unusual patterns, for example many passes from one device in a short time.

The decision record does not have to be extensive: one page is enough, with the date, the training name, the reach and the risk acceptance. With it the plant can show that it consciously chose availability and did not overlook the threat.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Can the risk be eliminated completely?

Not with identification by number alone. It can be limited organizationally and by choosing trainings for which it is acceptable.

Does this apply to mandatory trainings?

The described risk applies to the additional training code, which does not block entry.

Is the Is it you? question enough?

It protects against mistakes on a shared device, but it will not stop deliberate use of someone else's number.

Who should approve the decision?

The information security team together with the OHS manager.

Safe sharing of trainings

We will jointly assess which trainings can be shared by QR code. Book a talk.

Let's talk