InnerWeb
Skip to main content

How to check the type of cards used on site

Before management decides on a card replacement, the security manager must know which cards are actually in circulation, and in one plant two or three generations often coexist. The card type is established in five steps: documentation, markings, a test read, establishing how the access control system reads the card, and recording the result in a register. The whole inventory usually takes one working day.

5 steps
from documentation to the register of card technology
Source: guide
3 technologies
most common in circulation: 125 kHz, MIFARE Classic, DESFire

Why the card type must be established before any decision

The risk of copying a card depends on the technology, not on the appearance. Cards of the same shape and colour can belong to different technologies: one is a 125 kHz card, which transmits a fixed number without authentication or encryption, another is MIFARE Classic with the Crypto1 cipher and a 48-bit key, and a third is DESFire with 128-bit AES.

Without knowing which card is which, the decision to replace is based on guesswork. The auditor will ask about this first, and the inventory result becomes the basis of the conversation with the IT and purchasing departments.

Step 1: collect documentation from the card vendor and the access control system

The fastest source is the purchase documentation: invoices, specifications and product sheets of the cards the plant bought over the years. They show the card model, and the model indicates the technology. The access control vendor usually knows the configuration of the readers and can confirm which technologies the readers support.

It is worth asking three things: which card models were bought and in which years, whether the number read by the system comes from the UID or from an encrypted sector, and whether the readers have support for several technologies enabled at the same time.

Encryption key length in three card technologies (bits)

Encryption key length in three card technologies (bits)Key length: 125 kHz 0 bits, MIFARE Classic 48 bits, DESFire EV3 128 bits.050100150bits125 kHz (none): 0 bits0 bits125 kHz (none)MIFARE Classic: 48 bits48 bitsMIFARE ClassicDESFire EV3: 128 bits128 bitsDESFire EV3
Source: https:/sos.cs.ru.nl/applications/rfid/2008-esorics.pdf; https:/www.nxp.com/products/rfid-nfc/mifare-hf/mifare-desfire

Step 2: check the markings on the card and the batches from the warehouse

Many cards carry factory markings, for example a technology symbol or the chip model. The label on the bulk packaging usually gives the full product name. Cards from one batch share the same technology, so it is enough to check one card from each batch.

Remember the emergency, replacement and visitor cards: they sometimes come from a different series than employee cards, and the older technology is most often found there.

Step 3: a test read on a device that distinguishes the frequency

The frequency is established by reading. The 13.56 MHz band supports, among others, the ISO/IEC 14443 standard, which covers proximity cards with a range of a few centimetres. A phone with NFC works in the 13.56 MHz band, so cards which the phone does not detect at all most likely belong to the 125 kHz band. This is a hint, not proof, but a good basis for quick selection.

A more precise read is made by a test reader or an application that shows the chip family, for example distinguishing MIFARE Classic from DESFire. The test is done by the IT department or the access control vendor, on the plant's own cards, in the presence of the person responsible for the card register. Cards are not copied, and their content is not saved beyond the technology register.

How to read the result

No reading by an NFC phone suggests 125 kHz. A reading with the MIFARE Classic family means the Crypto1 cipher, and a reading with the DESFire family means mutual authentication and AES. Record the result for each batch in the register.

Step 4: establish how the access control system reads the card

The card type is one thing, the way the system reads it is another. A system that reads only the UID number remains vulnerable to copying the number, even when the card has protected sectors. Therefore, after establishing the technology, check whether the reader and the controller use card authentication or only the number.

The answer comes from the configuration of the readers and the access control vendor's documentation. If it is not available in the plant, it should be obtained in writing, because the auditor will need it.

Step 5: record the result in the register and pass it on

The inventory result takes the form of a table: employee group, card batch, technology, reading method, number of cards in circulation, doors to which the cards give access. The table becomes evidence for the auditor and the basis for the replacement costing. In a plant of 500 employees a few rows are usually enough, because the cards were bought in several batches.

InnerWeb does not manufacture or replace readers and access control cards, and it integrates with the existing access control system. The card technology register is therefore a document on the access control side, but it is worth that the department responsible for training and permits also has it, since a card replacement affects the gate entry plan.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is a phone enough to establish the card type?

It gives a preliminary hint: a phone with NFC works in the 13.56 MHz band, so no reading suggests 125 kHz. To establish the chip family, a test reader or an application that recognises chips is needed.

Is it allowed to copy cards during the test?

No. The test reads only the technology and the chip family. Copying employees' cards is not needed for the inventory and goes against the principle of data minimisation.

How long does the inventory take in a plant of 500 employees?

Usually one working day, because the cards come from several purchase batches. The longest part is obtaining confirmation of the reader configuration from the access control vendor.

Sources

Do you have the card inventory results?

We will show how the permit and training system accepts swipes from the access control system regardless of the card technology. Book a conversation or a demo.

Let's talk