InnerWeb
Skip to main content

FAQ: Labour Code and biometrics. Employer questions before ordering readers

A plant director considering biometric readers at the entrance usually asks the same questions: whether it is allowed, on what basis, what about the DPIA and what about employees who refuse. The answers below are based on Article 22(1b) of the Polish Labour Code and the GDPR, and show when biometrics can be justified and when a card is the better choice.

Art. 35
GDPR: impact assessment before implementation
13 s
refresh time of the evacuation list from QR badge scans
Source: card standard

Does the Labour Code allow biometrics at the plant entrance

Article 22(1b) of the Polish Labour Code regulates the processing of an employee's biometric data by the employer and links it to access control to particularly important information or to premises requiring special protection. The provision therefore concerns specific resources, not every gate.

For a director this means a simple rule: before you order readers, identify which zones meet the criterion of special protection. The main gate with hundreds of entries a day usually does not meet it; a server room holding technology data, or a room with substances under special supervision, may.

What necessity means and how to demonstrate it

An employer that wants to use biometrics for its employees must demonstrate that the solution is necessary for the access control purpose, and not merely convenient or cheaper. This demonstration is a document, not a declaration: a description of the threat, an assessment, an explanation of why an encrypted card or a QR code does not neutralise it, and an indication of the zone.

The control question is: what happens if an employee lends their card to someone? If the consequence is only access to a warehouse hall, there is no necessity. If there is access to information whose disclosure would harm the plant, the argument gains weight.

We describe the detailed procedure in the guide on assessing necessity; here it is enough to remember the principle: the wider the group of people and the lower the risk of the zone, the weaker the legal basis.

Order of decisions before buying readers

Order of decisions before buying readersBar chart with the numbered decision steps: zone, necessity, DPIA, alternative, purchase.012345stepZone identification: 1 step1 stepZoneidentificationNecessity: 2 step2 stepNecessityDPIA: 3 step3 stepDPIAAlternative: 4 step4 stepAlternativePurchase: 5 step5 stepPurchase
Source: Proposed order of the decision process

Is employee consent enough

Consent is one of the exceptions in Article 9(2) GDPR and must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous (Article 4(11) GDPR). In an employment relationship, however, one must take into account that an employee may fear the consequences of refusing.

Employee consent as a basis for processing biometric data raises doubts because of the imbalance between the parties, so it requires particular caution and a genuine alternative. The director should assume that some of the workforce will refuse or withdraw consent, and plan a parallel path with a card or a QR code from the first day.

Do we need a data protection impact assessment (DPIA)

Article 35 GDPR requires a data protection impact assessment before processing that is likely to result in a high risk to the rights of individuals, including large-scale processing of special categories of data. Biometrics of the workforce at a production plant is a typical candidate for a DPIA.

The practical consequence: you carry out the DPIA before ordering readers, not after installation. The result affects the purchasing decision, because the typical conclusion for employee entry control is: for most areas a card or a QR code is sufficient, and biometrics is considered only for narrow zones of particular protection.

Where should the template be stored and how to protect it

A biometric template is a mathematical representation of features, not a picture of a fingerprint, but it is still personal data. Unlike a password or a card, it cannot be changed after a leak, because a body feature is permanent. This is one of the main reasons for the high risk in the impact assessment.

The GDPR requires data protection by design (Article 25) and measures adequate to the risk, including encryption and access control (Article 32). For IT this means a choice between a template on the reader, on the access control server and on the employee's card, together with a clear retention and deletion policy.

The data minimisation principle in Article 5(1)(c) GDPR points the direction: data should be limited to what is necessary for the purpose.

What about the system we already have, and InnerWeb

InnerWeb is a software manufacturer. It does not produce or supply access control readers, including biometric ones, but integrates with the client's existing access control system. It receives check-in events from the access control system via a webhook and links them with qualifications, permits, attendance and time records.

An event may consist of a person identifier and a timestamp, so the platform does not need a biometric template. A decision on biometrics in one zone does not force the plant to pass templates on to other systems. A REST API with JWT authentication and webhooks ease integration, while connectors to specific systems require implementation work.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Can I introduce biometrics for the whole workforce?

This is difficult to justify, because you must demonstrate necessity for access control to particularly protected resources. For a wide workforce and ordinary areas, an encrypted card or a QR code works better.

Must a biometric reader be part of the access control system?

The reader operates within the access control system, and InnerWeb receives check-in events from it. The platform does not take over the role of the reader and does not require a template.

Is informing employees mandatory?

Yes. Article 13 GDPR requires that the purpose, the legal basis, the retention period and the rights of the person be given when data is collected, including biometric data.

What should I do when an employee withdraws consent?

Switch the employee to a card or a QR code and delete the template from the reader, the server and backups, keeping evidence of the deletion.

Sources

Planning access control at your plant?

Let us talk about how to connect events from your existing access control system with qualifications, permits and attendance, without processing biometric templates.

Let's talk