InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Guide: how to assess the necessity of biometrics for a plant zone (Article 22(1b) of the Labour Code)

The necessity of biometrics does not follow from the reader being convenient. The head of security, together with the data protection officer, should demonstrate in writing that for a specific zone no milder solution is sufficient. Below are six steps leading to such a document.

6
steps of the biometrics necessity assessment
Source: guide
Art. 22(1b)
of the Labour Code: basis for the employer's exception

What the provision says and what it does not say

Article 22(1b) of the Polish Labour Code regulates the processing of an employee's biometric data by the employer and links it to access control to particularly important information or to premises requiring special protection. The employer must demonstrate that the solution is necessary for the access control purpose, and not merely convenient or cheaper.

The provision does not define a list of premises. The assessment is therefore individual for the plant and the zone, and the assessment document is the evidence on which the supervisory authority will rely during an inspection.

Steps 1 and 2: the description of the resource and the damage scenario

Step 1: describe the resource you are protecting: a room, information or equipment. State its value for the plant and the effect of its disclosure or loss, without client names and without data on specific individuals.

Step 2: describe the damage scenario. What happens if an unauthorised person enters? Disclosure of technological information, damage to an installation, disruption of a process? The condition in Article 22(1b) refers to particularly important information whose disclosure may expose the employer to harm, so the scenario should justify it.

Stages of the biometrics necessity assessment

Stages of the biometrics necessity assessmentHorizontal bar chart of the six stages of the biometrics necessity assessment.0246stageResource descriptionResource description: 1 stage1Damage scenarioDamage scenario: 2 stage2Alternatives testAlternatives test: 3 stage3DPIADPIA: 4 stage4Protective measuresProtective measures: 5 stage5Audit evidenceAudit evidence: 6 stage6
Source: Proposed structure of the necessity assessment

Step 3: test of milder alternatives

Step 3: check whether access control by another method neutralises the scenario. Consider a 13.56 MHz contactless card with DESFire-type encryption, a second factor (PIN), a QR code and verification by security. For most areas of the plant a card or a QR code is sufficient.

Record why a given alternative does not suffice. Example of a justification: a card can be handed to another person, and the consequence is access to a room where a particularly protected process is under way. If you cannot write this down, biometrics for the zone is not necessary.

Steps 4 and 5: the DPIA and risk-reducing measures

Step 4: carry out the data protection impact assessment. Article 35 GDPR requires it before processing that is likely to result in a high risk to the rights of individuals, including large-scale processing of special categories of data. In the DPIA take into account that a biometric template cannot be changed after a leak.

Step 5: plan the measures: a narrow range of zones, a template stored so as to limit the risk of reconstruction (Article 25), encryption and access control (Article 32), and a retention and deletion policy after the employee leaves. The data minimisation principle in Article 5(1)(c) GDPR gives the direction: only as much data as necessary.

Step 6: audit evidence and the alternative for the employee

Step 6: gather the evidence: the description of the resource, the damage scenario, the test of alternatives, the DPIA, information for employees under Article 13 GDPR, and a description of the parallel path for those who do not want biometrics. Employee consent raises doubts because of the imbalance between the parties, so the alternative path is part of the assessment, not an addition to it.

InnerWeb does not produce readers; it integrates with the existing access control system, from which it receives check-in events via a webhook. The platform is an independent supplementary system and works without GPS. For an employee outside the biometric zone, a scan of the QR badge or of an RFID card on the security panel gives a verdict based on valid training, qualifications and permits.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Who should sign the necessity assessment?

The head of security together with the data protection officer, and the decision is approved by the management board or the plant director.

Does the assessment need to be repeated?

Yes, when the scope of zones, the reader technology changes or after a data incident. An annual review is good practice.

Does necessity also apply to visitors?

Article 22(1b) concerns employees. Visitors and external companies are covered by the GDPR and need a separate basis, and it is usually easier to base them on a QR code than on biometrics.

Sources

Preparing a necessity assessment?

We will show how data from your existing access control system supports the audit evidence without processing templates. Book a conversation.

Let's talk