InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Cost of a cloned card incident: calculation

Management does not need a lecture on ciphers, only the arithmetic: what one incident of entry on someone else's cloned card costs, and what moving to encrypted cards costs. In the sample calculation one incident costs 97,000 PLN, which is more than twice the cost of replacing the cards and readers in a plant of 500 employees. Below are the assumptions and how the plant can substitute its own figures.

97,000 PLN
cost of one incident in the sample calculation
Source: sample calculation
44,528 PLN
cost of replacing cards and readers in the sample calculation
Source: sample calculation
approx. 5.7 years
payback period calculated from the expected annual loss
Source: sample calculation

How management compares two numbers

The decision to replace cards comes down to comparing two quantities: the one-off cost of moving to encrypted cards and the cost of a single incident that the technology is meant to prevent. A third quantity is the hardest: the probability of an incident within a year. Management rarely knows it precisely, so it is worth running the calculation in two variants: as the cost of one incident and as the expected annual loss.

The 125 kHz cards transmit a fixed number without authentication or encryption, and the number can be written to a blank medium in a few seconds. With such a technology the consequence of an incident does not depend on the ingenuity of the person, only on what the copied card gives access to.

What makes up the cost of one incident

In the sample calculation the cost of an incident has four components. The first is the direct loss, for example goods or materials removed from a zone entered by an unauthorised person: 40,000 PLN. The second is downtime after the event: six hours at 5,000 PLN per hour, which is 30,000 PLN. The third is the investigation and audit after the incident: 15,000 PLN. The fourth is the emergency replacement and reissue of cards: 12,000 PLN.

The total is 97,000 PLN. All the values are example assumptions, which the plant replaces with its own figures from accounting, controlling and insurance.

  • Direct losses: 40,000 PLN (example assumption).
  • Downtime after the event: 6 hours x 5,000 PLN = 30,000 PLN.
  • Investigation and audit: 15,000 PLN.
  • Emergency replacement and reissue of cards: 12,000 PLN.

One incident versus the cost of replacing cards and readers (PLN)

One incident versus the cost of replacing cards and readers (PLN)Comparison: one incident 97,000 PLN, replacement of cards and readers 44,528 PLN.020,00040,00060,00080,000100,000PLNCost of one incident: Incident: 97,000 PLN97,000 PLNCost of one incidentCost of replacement: Replacement: 44,528 PLN44,528 PLNCost of replacement
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the calculation section

Comparison with the cost of moving to encrypted cards

The replacement of cards and readers in a plant of 500 employees and 24 doors costs 44,528 PLN in the sample calculation. The detailed structure of this cost is shown on the separate page about replacement costs. One incident costing 97,000 PLN is therefore more than twice as expensive as the entire replacement.

This comparison is an argument, but not proof. The replacement pays back through one incident only if that incident actually happens. That is why the second variant of the calculation, the expected annual loss, is more honest towards management.

Variant two: expected annual loss

The expected annual loss is the cost of an incident multiplied by the probability within a year. At an assumed probability of 8 percent it comes to 7,760 PLN per year. In this variant the replacement of 44,528 PLN pays back after about 5.7 years, which seems long, but this is a payback period counted from direct losses only.

In practice the replacement also has other justifications: the auditor's requirements, the security policy of the group, the expectations of the plant's clients and compliance with the principle of adapting protection measures to the risk. For doors leading to zones of high importance, the replacement is a decision independent of the payback period.

Components of the cost of one incident (PLN)

Components of the cost of one incident (PLN)Components of the incident cost: losses 40,000 PLN, downtime 30,000 PLN, investigation 15,000 PLN, emergency replacement 12,000 PLN.010,00020,00030,00040,000PLNDirect lossesDirect losses: 40,000 PLN40,000DowntimeDowntime: 30,000 PLN30,000Investigation and auditInvestigation and audit: 15,000 PLN15,000Emergency card replacementEmergency card replacement: 12,000 PLN12,000
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the calculation section

What the calculation does not show

The calculation does not value damage to reputation or the loss of client trust. It also does not cover the consequences of an event in a zone where a single entry by an unauthorised person has a dimension of human safety. For such doors the economic arithmetic is only one of the criteria.

It is also worth remembering that a false trail in the swipe log hampers the investigation. The system will record the entry as the entry of the card owner, with his or her training and permissions, so after an event it is necessary to establish who was actually on the site.

How to calculate your own case in three steps

Step one: from accounting, collect the values of the assets behind the doors of greatest importance and the hourly cost of downtime in that zone. Step two: ask the insurer or controlling what the last similar event in the plant or the industry cost. Step three: enter the values into the calculation and compute both variants, one incident and the expected annual loss.

InnerWeb does not manufacture or replace readers and access control cards. It integrates with the plant's access control system and links card swipes with qualifications and permits, so replacing the card technology does not require a change in permission logic.

Example calculation

Sample calculation: incident versus card replacement

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Direct losses40,000 PLN
Downtime6 hours
Cost of one hour of downtime5,000 PLN
Investigation and audit15,000 PLN
Emergency replacement and reissue of cards12,000 PLN
Probability of an incident in a year8 %
Cost of replacing cards and readers (500 employees, 24 readers)44,528 PLN

Result: One incident: 40,000 + 30,000 + 15,000 + 12,000 = 97,000 PLN. Expected annual loss: 97,000 x 8% = 7,760 PLN. Payback period of the replacement: 44,528 / 7,760 = about 5.7 years.

Note: Sample calculation on assumptions, not the data of any plant. The plant substitutes its own values from accounting, controlling and insurance.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does one incident really cost as much as the replacement?

In the sample calculation, yes, even twice as much. In a real plant the result depends on the value of the assets and the cost of downtime, so the calculation must be done with the plant's own figures.

How do we estimate the probability of an incident?

It is estimated from the plant's history of events, the insurer's assessments and the importance of the doors. It is worth calculating several values, for example 2, 5 and 8 percent, and seeing how the payback period changes.

Does the calculation include reputational losses?

No. Reputational damage is hard to value, so in this calculation it stays outside the arithmetic. Management can add it as a separate comment.

Sources

Let's count the risk on your figures

We will help build the calculation for management and show what does not change on the permit and training side when the cards are replaced. Book a conversation or a demo.

Let's talk