Where the difference comes from
In external service two notions of time apply. The first is the permit time, meaning the period during which the document is in a given state. The second is the working time of individual employees, which the system counts separately, from joining or from the start detected by location.
The difference is natural: a permit may run for four hours, while one of two technicians arrived an hour late. The problem appears when settlement takes only one of these values as its basis, or the declaration from the protocol.
Settlement practices based on location
The system determines the employee's position from BLE signals from transmitters, without GPS. In a building there is roughly one transmitter per 100-200 m2, and the position comes from averaging the signals of several transmitters. For settlement this means accuracy to the place of work, not to the meter, which is usually enough to establish whether the person was at the machine.
After entering the place of work the system can join the employee to the permit for that location, and after leaving it remove the employee from the list, so the working time follows the location.
Agree the source of truth with the supplier
Record that the basis of settlement is the person's time from the system, and that the protocol is descriptive. A dispute over an hour is settled by the location record.
Show technicians how time is counted
People who know that their time is counted from entry into the place of work do not rush to enter hours and do not correct them after the fact.
Example: permit time versus the time of two technicians
What to do when the times differ
When the permit time and the person's time do not match, do not reconcile them by hand. First check whether the difference comes from the order of entries and exits, or from a break outside the place of work, for example to collect a spare part from the warehouse. Only an unexplained difference requires a conversation with the supplier.
The plant's online map in the 2.5D isometric view shows the places of work and the employees, so the coordinator can reconstruct where the person was in the disputed period, without asking for verbal accounts.
Limits of the method
Location confirms presence at the place of work, but it does not prove that the person was working on the machine at that time. It is a record of presence, and assessing effectiveness requires other data. It is also worth deciding in advance about idle time: whether a break outside the place of work counts toward settlement or not.
Example of settling two technicians
Assume a service of one machine for one shift. The permit is open for 240 minutes. Technician A enters the place of work together with the start of the permit and leaves five minutes before it closes, so his time is 235 minutes. Technician B arrives after 65 minutes, so his time is 175 minutes. Settling from the declaration in the protocol, both would have 240 minutes entered, and the plant would pay for the 65 minutes when one of them was absent.
This is a sample calculation with assumed times, but the mechanism is real: a person's time is counted separately, from joining or from the start detected by location. It is worth showing such an example to the supplier before you settle the service from the system for the first time, because a conversation about specific minutes is easier than one about the principle.
Conclusions for the maintenance manager and purchasing
The maintenance manager gains a record that can be shown to the supplier without a dispute about memory. Purchasing gains a basis for settlement built on data. For both sides the key is the same: an agreed rule in advance that the basis is the person's time from the system, and that differences are explained on the map, not by negotiation.
Finally, run a short review after the first month: how many times the person's time differed from the permit time by more than fifteen minutes, for what reason, and whether the difference was explained by the location record. Such a review shows whether the transmitters cover the places of work, and gives grounds for a conversation with the supplier about how to settle breaks. All numbers in the examples on this page are a sample calculation based on the assumptions given in the text, not data from a specific plant.
Checklist
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does location replace the service protocol?
No. The protocol describes the work performed, and location provides an independent record of the time of presence.
Does this work without GPS?
Yes. The position is determined from BLE signals from transmitters, not from GPS.
Why does a person's time differ from the permit time?
Because the system counts them separately. A person's time starts from their joining or from the start detected by location.
See service time from location
Book a demonstration and check on the map of your hall how the system separates permit time from the person's time.
Let's talk