InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Machine downtime versus service permit issue time: a calculation

A minute of machine downtime costs the plant its hourly margin divided by sixty, and a service permit usually circulates for signatures longer than anyone expects. Below is a sample calculation for the plant director: how many minutes a paper circulation takes, how many the electronic flow takes, and how the annual amount follows from this.

-30 min
downtime per permit (assumption)
Source: kalkulacja przykładowa
432,000 PLN
annual saving in the example
Source: kalkulacja przykładowa

What the downtime linked to the permit consists of

Machine downtime during a service has two parts. The first is the service itself, meaning the working time of the mechanic, which paper or a system will not shorten. The second is the time around the service: waiting for the permit to be prepared, signatures of several people, carrying the document to the hall and closing it after the work. This second part is what the calculation on this page concerns.

In a paper circulation the permit usually passes through the coordinator, the production manager and a person from OHS, and each handover means looking for a person or waiting for them to return from another hall. The electronic circulation shortens this handover to the moment when the authorised person opens the task, and records the time of each step.

Assumptions of the sample calculation

The calculation is a sample and does not describe any specific plant. The assumed values should be replaced with your own. We assume a plant with a dozen or so machines, where services by external companies take place several times a day.

We assume 30 service permits a month in which the machine stands still for the duration of the permit circulation. The paper circulation takes on average 45 minutes from the request to admission of the work, and the electronic circulation 15 minutes. We put the cost of a minute of machine downtime at 40 PLN, which corresponds to an hourly production value of about 2,400 PLN. The plant director inserts his own figure from controlling here.

Why 15 minutes and not zero

With the electronic circulation someone still has to approve the permit. We therefore assume 15 minutes: time to check the tasks, the risks and the technician's profile by the authorised person. The course of the permit follows a template linked to the location and the tasks, so the preparation tasks are ready rather than drafted anew for each service.

Time from request to admission of the work

Time from request to admission of the workComparison of permit circulation time: 45 minutes on paper and 15 minutes in the electronic circulation.01020304050minPaper circulation: Circulation time: 45 min45 minPaper circulationElectronic circulation: Circulation time: 15 min15 minElectronic circulation
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the section Assumptions of the sample calculation

Result: minutes and money

The difference on one permit is 45 minus 15, that is 30 minutes of downtime. With 30 permits a month this gives 900 minutes, that is 15 hours less downtime a month. At a cost of 40 PLN per minute the saving is 36,000 PLN a month, and 432,000 PLN a year.

The result is sensitive to two assumptions: the number of permits in which the machine actually stands still for the circulation time, and the cost of a minute. If the machine has a buffer in the form of semi-finished stock, the actual cost of a minute will be lower and the calculation should be corrected. Conversely, in a plant with continuous machines, where every minute affects the whole line, it will be higher.

What this calculation does not include

We do not count here the time of the service itself, nor the cost of the people taking part in the circulation. The latter is discussed separately in the calculation of printing and circulation costs for permits. We also do not include the effect on quality, accident rate and risk, because these cannot honestly be converted into money in a single example.

The electronic permit does not shorten the service itself. It shortens the time around it and records from when to when it lasted. The permit time and the working time of each employee are counted separately, and the employee's time is counted from joining or from the start detected by location. This is also useful for settlements with the service company.

How to check your own figures in one day

To insert the data of your own plant into this calculation, a few hours with controlling and the maintenance manager are enough. Three things need to be established: how many service permits were issued in the last quarter, how long on average it took from the request to admission of the work (a sample of ten permits with the signature times is enough), and what a minute of downtime costs for the most important machines.

It usually turns out that the spread of circulation time is larger than the average: some permits pass in ten minutes, and some stand for an hour because the signing person is in another hall. These long cases generate most of the cost, so it is worth counting them separately.

Example calculation

Saving of machine downtime from the electronic circulation

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Service permits in which the machine stands still30 permits/month
Paper circulation time45 min
Electronic circulation time15 min
Cost of a minute of machine downtime40 PLN/min

Result: 30 min x 30 permits = 900 min a month; 900 min x 40 PLN = 36,000 PLN a month, that is 432,000 PLN a year.

Note: Sample calculation based on the assumptions above, not referring to any specific plant. Own values should be inserted from controlling.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Are 15 minutes of electronic circulation realistic?

This is a sample assumption. The time depends on how quickly the authorised person opens the task and approves the permit. The plant can measure it on a sample of permits after launch.

Will the system shorten the service itself?

No. It shortens the time around the service: preparation, approval and closing, and it records the permit time and the working time of employees separately.

How is the cost of a minute of downtime calculated?

From controlling: the hourly production value of the machine, reduced by what can be made up from the buffer. For machines with a buffer of semi-finished stock the cost will be lower than in the example.

Let us calculate downtime on your figures

We will go through your own permit numbers and cost per minute with controlling. The quotation and the scope of implementation are individual.

Let's talk