Two power variants
The rechargeable variant needs charging every few days. For five thousand units this means daily rotation at gates and departments, and the practice from factories and schools is a 40-position station with rotation per department. The primary cell variant removes the cost of charging stations (approximately PLN 237,500 in the example of five thousand watches) and the daily charging logistics, but requires cell replacement.
Beacons on industrial batteries work for several years, and in the maintenance service battery replacement falls about every 4 years. For a watch the cycle is shorter, and it is the watch that drives the bill. Below is a comparison of costs that can be calculated before ordering.
Structure of charging costs
The cost of charging has three parts: stations, labour in the rotation and energy. Stations are a one-off cost: in the example of five thousand watches with 40-position stations, 125 stations are needed, and the total cost of approximately PLN 237,500 means PLN 1,900 per station. Labour is the time spent issuing and placing devices. Energy is negligible at this scale.
The lifetime of the stations adds to their cost. Assuming five years of use, the annual cost of the stations is PLN 47,500. This is an example assumption: change it if the supplier gives a different lifetime.
Yearly charging cost for 5,000 watches (example)
Structure of the cell cost
The cost of a primary cell is the price of the unit, the labour of replacement and the disposal of spent cells. Replacement is spread over time, needs no station and does not load the gates. The drawback is a less predictable unit cost, which depends on the frequency of replacement. In the example fleet of trackers for drivers, the subscription includes battery replacement at approximately PLN 30 plus a licence at approximately PLN 50, together approximately PLN 80 per tracker per month. This shows the order of magnitude of the replacement cost in the service.
The PLN 30 must not be transferred directly to the watch, because it concerns the tracker. However, it allows an assessment of whether the break-even point from the calculation below is realistic.
Break-even point
The cell variant wins if the annual cost of cells and their replacement per watch is lower than the annual cost of charging per watch. With the assumptions of the calculation the break-even point is approximately PLN 51 per watch per year, that is approximately PLN 4.3 per month. If the cell supplier offers replacement below this amount, the cell is cheaper. If above, charging is more economical.
Remember the factors outside the budget: a cell reduces the number of devices discharged during a shift, while charging gives visibility of the battery state in the system on an ongoing basis.
How to use the calculation in your plant
Substitute your own values into four parameters: number of watches, price of a station, time to service one charge and the hourly cost of labour. Calculate the annual cost per watch and compare it with the offer for cell replacement. If the difference is small, the choice is decided by qualitative factors: the number of gates, access to power and certainty that the device has energy for the whole shift. Also collect data from the first month of use, because the actual service time is often different from the assumed one. A corrected calculation based on your own data is more reliable than any catalogue table.
What else affects the decision
First, the shift pattern and the number of gates, because charging rotation needs space and people at each point. Second, the zone restrictions: where cell replacement is difficult, charging is easier. Third, ecology and disposal: primary cells are waste that must be collected in line with regulations.
The last factor is flexibility: a rechargeable battery can be charged at a variable pace, while a cell is replaced on a schedule. The choice can also be mixed: cells for watches in hard-to-reach places, rechargeable batteries for the rest.
Yearly charging cost for 5,000 watches and the break-even for a cell
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Number of watches | 5000 pcs |
| Positions per station | 40 pcs |
| Cost of all stations | 237500 PLN |
| Station lifetime (assumption) | 5 years |
| Charging every (assumption) | 3 days |
| Service time per charge (assumption) | 0.5 min |
| Working days per year (assumption) | 250 days |
| Hourly cost of labour (assumption) | 60 PLN |
Result: Stations: PLN 47,500 per year. Rotation labour: 5000 / 3 = approx. 1,667 watches per day, 0.5 min each, that is approx. 13.9 h per day, 3,472 h per year, approx. PLN 208,333. Total approx. PLN 255,833 per year, that is approx. PLN 51 per watch per year (approx. PLN 4.3 per month).
Note: Example calculation. Replace the figures marked as assumption with your own numbers; the cell is cheaper if its yearly cost including replacement is below approx. PLN 51 per watch.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Is a cell always cheaper than charging?
No. It depends on the replacement price. In the example calculation the break-even is approx. PLN 51 per watch per year.
Why don't we count energy?
At this scale the energy cost is negligible compared with the stations and the rotation labour.
Can both variants be combined?
Yes. Cells can go to watches in hard-to-reach places, and rechargeable batteries to the rest.
Where does the PLN 237,500 come from?
It is the station cost in the example of 5,000 watches with rotation on 40-position stations.
Let's talk about devices at your plant
We will show how to match devices to roles and how the system connects them on one map. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.
Let's talk