The strongest transmitter method and its assumption
The method assumes that the strongest signal comes from the nearest transmitter. In open space this is usually the case, but in a hall full of metal the assumption stops holding. A machine or a rack between the device and the nearby transmitter weakens its signal, and a reflection from a wall can strengthen the signal of a more distant transmitter.
The result is position jumps: a person standing in one place is assigned once to the transmitter on the left side of the machine and once to the one on the right. For an SOS alarm, this is an error that becomes visible only in the control room.
Why the BLE signal strength varies
Bluetooth Low Energy operates in the 2.4 GHz band, which is attenuated by the human body and reflected by metal. The same position can produce different readings depending on how the worker holds their arms, whether they stand with their back to the transmitter and whether a trolley has just passed nearby. A single reading is therefore a sample with a wide spread.
This is a physical property of this technology, not a defect of a specific transmitter, so it cannot be removed with better hardware. It can, however, be compensated for in the algorithm.
For the practitioner, this means giving up the question of which transmitter is the best, in favour of the question of how many transmitters the device hears at each work location.
Illustrative example: zone accuracy in 100 readings
- Strongest transmitter
- Averaging many transmitters
How averaging many signals works
In the InnerWeb system, the worker's position results from the signals of many transmitters averaged on the map, not from a single strongest transmitter. The device periodically sends the list of transmitters it hears, the signal strength, the battery state and its status (heartbeat). From this list, the algorithm builds a position on the map in which each transmitter contributes its share, and single disturbed readings lose their weight.
The effect is similar to measuring a length with several rulers: the error of one ruler does not decide the result. In practice this gives an average accuracy below 1 m from many measurement points.
The role of transmitter density
Averaging works only when the device hears several transmitters at the same time. This is why inside a building the design assumes 1 transmitter per 100–200 m², and plant roads are covered with transmitters about every 100 m. Too sparse a grid means that in part of the hall only one transmitter is audible, and we are back to the strongest-signal method with all its drawbacks.
After installation, check at several points how many transmitters the device hears. If the number drops to one in critical zones, add a transmitter instead of changing the algorithm.
A numerical example: who makes mistakes more often
The chart below illustrates an example scenario: 100 readings at one point in a hall with a metal rack, where the strongest-transmitter method indicated the correct zone in 70 cases, and averaging many transmitters in 94. These are illustrative values, meant to show the mechanism, not the measurement result of a specific plant. You will measure your own result with a test on control points.
What follows for the deployment
Require the supplier to describe the algorithm, not only the accuracy figure. Ask how many transmitters take part in determining the position, how a single strong signal is treated and what happens when only one transmitter is audible. After deployment, monitor the number of transmitters heard in the zones and fill in the grid where it drops.
How to recognise the symptoms in the data
A symptom of a method based on a single transmitter is a position that jumps between two points even though the worker is standing still. On the map, this appears as alternating indications of two neighbouring zones. The second symptom is differences between devices at the same place and time. The third is positions indicating a point on the other side of a wall. When you see such phenomena, first check the number of transmitters heard and the positions recorded on the map, and only then replace devices. From the heartbeat data you can read the list of transmitters heard and the signal strength, which makes it possible to distinguish a lack of density from an error in recording the position.
At acceptance of the deployment, record in the protocol the number of transmitters heard at each control point together with the accuracy result: when the hall is extended, you will then know where the grid was sparsest and where to start densifying.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does averaging delay the position indication?
Slightly, because the algorithm uses the last few readings. With the cyclic transmission of the transmitter list, the position remains current for an SOS alarm.
Will a better transmitter solve the problem?
No, because the variability results from the propagation physics in the 2.4 GHz band. Density and the algorithm improve it.
Is one transmitter enough in a small room?
To establish that someone is in a given room, often yes, but accuracy within the room requires several transmitters.
How do I check how many transmitters the device hears?
The device sends data on the transmitters heard and the signal strength in the cyclic heartbeat, so they can be reviewed after a test at the control points.
Let's talk about location in your plant
We will show how a system based on many BLE transmitters behaves in a hall similar to yours. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.
Let's talk