Who these recommendations are for
We address these recommendations to the plant director, the head of security and the purchasing department of a company that uses 125 kHz cards of the EM or Prox type. These cards send a fixed number without authentication and without encryption, and the number can be written onto a blank card in a few seconds. A risk review usually ends with the conclusion that the cards cannot be protected with additional measures.
Seven recommendations
The recommendations follow an order, because each one builds on the findings of the previous one.
1. Inventory your card and reader types
Start by establishing how many cards are in circulation and which gates support 125 kHz only. Without this number the budget will be guesswork. Multi-technology readers often support both bands, so not all of them need replacing.
2. Do not choose MIFARE Classic
The 13.56 MHz band does not automatically mean security. MIFARE Classic uses the Crypto1 cipher with a 48-bit key, and the cipher was broken and described publicly in 2008. The manufacturer recommended moving away from it in new systems.
3. Choose a card with AES authentication
MIFARE DESFire EV3 works in the ISO/IEC 14443 type A standard and has a hardware AES 128-bit cipher with three-pass mutual authentication. For new projects, AES is recommended rather than older algorithms.
4. Plan in stages, not one date
Replacing all cards on one day stops entries. Divide the workforce into groups and work weekly, keeping readers that support both bands during the transition period.
5. Separate keys from the start
DESFire allows one master key per card and up to 14 keys per application. Plan who keeps them before you order the first batch of cards.
6. Keep authorization logic in an independent system
InnerWeb does not manufacture or replace access control readers and cards. It is an independent system that complements the client's existing systems (KD, time tracking, HR, ERP), so a change of card technology on the KD side does not require changes to the authorization logic.
7. Measure the effect after the replacement
After the replacement, compare the number of incidents with two people on one card and the number of reports of lost cards with the period before. The result goes into the report for leadership as evidence that the investment reduced the risk.
Sample schedule: cards replaced cumulatively
Sample replacement schedule
Sample calculation: a plant has 1,200 employees and replaces cards in four equal groups of 300 people, one group per week. Readers support both bands throughout, so entries are not stopped. After the fourth week all cards work at 13.56 MHz, and the old 125 kHz numbers are blocked in the system.
What not to do
Do not rely on the argument that copying requires expert knowledge. A copy of a 125 kHz card can be made in a few seconds with a short contact. Also do not order readers in one technology only if you plan a staged migration, because you would block the transition period for yourself.
How to justify the budget to leadership
Arguments for leadership are best based on three facts. First, a 125 kHz card number can be copied in seconds, because the card does not authenticate itself to the reader. Second, a DESFire EV3 card has a hardware AES 128-bit cipher and proximity checks against relay attacks. Third, replacing the cards does not change the authorization logic in InnerWeb, so it does not require retraining staff in the authorization system.
For the purchasing department, we recommend an inquiry with specific parameters, described in a separate recommendation on choosing a DESFire card. Costs depend on the number of cards, gates and readers, so the quotation is prepared by the KD integrator after the inventory. The quotation covers cards and readers on the KD side, not InnerWeb software.
Card replacement schedule in groups
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Number of employees with a card | 1,200 people |
| Replacement group | 300 cards per week |
| Readers during the transition | both bands 125 kHz and 13.56 MHz |
Result: 4 weeks to full replacement without stopping entries.
Note: Sample calculation based on the assumptions above; the actual schedule depends on the number of gates and shifts.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does every gate need a new reader?
Not always. Multi-technology readers support both bands, so the inventory will show which access points need replacing.
Does InnerWeb supply DESFire cards?
No. Cards and readers are supplied by the KD system vendor. InnerWeb integrates with the existing KD system and does not change the authorization logic when the technology is replaced.
Does simply moving to 13.56 MHz close the cloning risk?
No, if MIFARE Classic was chosen. Its cipher has been broken, so protection comes only from a card with AES authentication.
Sources
Plan the card replacement without stopping entries
We will help set the order of work so that authorizations, training and attendance keep working throughout the transition. Ask us for a call.
Let's talk