InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Risks assigned to the hall location: recommendations

The health and safety manager at a machinery plant decides whether a given risk belongs to the hall, the area, the line or a specific place. That decision determines whether the permit printout stays short and readable, or turns into a list of repetitions that nobody reads. Below are seven recommendations with the reasoning behind each.

4
location hierarchy levels for risks
Source: karta
5
risk sections on the printout
Source: karta

Who these recommendations are for

The audience is the health and safety manager or specialist who builds the risk catalogue for a machinery plant with an assembly hall, a welding bay and a paint shop. It also concerns the system administrator who enters the data together with health and safety.

InnerWeb allows risks, together with the required protective measures, to be assigned to a location at every level of the hierarchy: hall, area, line, place. They can also be assigned to a type of hazardous work. Since there are four location levels plus the work type, you need to know where to place a specific risk so that it is not duplicated across several levels.

How the system combines risks on the printout

The permit printout combines the risks in five sections without repetition: risks between permits, location hierarchy, additional locations, type of hazardous work and user risks. The system makes sure the same risk does not appear twice.

This does not, however, replace design. If we enter the same hazard at the hall level and separately at every line, the printout will still be correct, but the catalogue becomes hard to maintain: changing a protective measure requires editing in many places.

Risk level thresholds in the editor

Risk level thresholds in the editorBar chart of the risk level thresholds: 20, 70, 200 and 400 points0100200300400ptsThreshold 1: 20 pts20 ptsThreshold 1Threshold 2: 70 pts70 ptsThreshold 2Threshold 3: 200 pts200 ptsThreshold 3Threshold 4: 400 pts400 ptsThreshold 4
Source: Feature documentation: particularly hazardous work and risks

Seven recommendations

The recommendations are ordered from the widest level to the narrowest. Each one is justified by the behaviour of the system, not by theory.

1. Keep a risk shared by the whole hall at the hall level

Internal vehicle traffic or overhead crane operation affects every place in the hall. Entered once at the hall level, it appears on every permit for that hall. Reason: one edit changes all the printouts.

2. Assign a risk specific to an area to that area

Solvent vapours in the paint shop or weld spatter in the welding bay do not concern assembly stations. Assigning them to the area means the welder in the welding bay sees their risks, and the assembler does not get a list that does not concern them.

3. Reserve the line and place levels for exceptions

Use the line and place levels for risks that really differ from their surroundings, for example a hot surface at one station. When most items sit low in the hierarchy, the catalogue swells and nobody remembers where the items came from.

4. Assign risks of the type of work to the type of hazardous work

Hazards linked to the activity itself, for example hot work, do not depend on the place. Assigned to the type of work, they accompany the permit always, regardless of the location. This way you do not copy them into every area.

5. Treat additional locations as a supplement, not a substitute

When a job touches more than one place, the system adds the risks of the additional locations. These form a separate section of the printout, so adding the same risks to the main location only multiplies the items.

6. Limit the between-permit risks to what is truly shared

The first section of the printout covers the risks between permits. Put there only what applies to every job in the plant, because every item will appear on every document.

7. Leave room for user risks

The person issuing the permit can add their own risks in the last section of the printout. A catalogue cannot foresee every situation, so this section lets you describe an exception without changing the plant's data.

Risk assessment: the threshold decides the measures

In the risk editor the risk level is calculated as the product of probability, exposure and severity against the thresholds 20, 70, 200 and 400. For each risk at the location level it is worth recording the assessment, because the threshold shows how strong a protective measure is needed.

After protective measures are applied, exposure and severity usually stay the same, and only the probability drops. By default the editor copies these values from the initial assessment, so the assessment after measures requires changing one value, not three.

Common mistakes in the risk hierarchy

The most common mistake is copying the whole catalogue to every line. The printout will still be generated, but changing one protective measure then requires a dozen edits, and one of them will be missed.

The second mistake is entering the risk of an activity at the location level. Then a welding permit in another place does not receive the fire warnings, because those sit in the area rather than in the type of work.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Can the same risk appear twice on the printout?

No. The printout combines the risks in five sections without repetition. It is still worth assigning a risk at one right level, so that the catalogue is easy to maintain.

Where should a risk linked to the activity itself be entered?

In the type of hazardous work. It then accompanies the permit regardless of the location.

Can a health and safety specialist add a risk on their own?

Yes. The risk editor lets the administrator and the health and safety role add a hazard once, after which it is permanently available to everyone issuing permits.

Let us design the risk catalogue for your hall

We will help you place risks at the right levels of the hierarchy, so that the permit printout is short and complete. We invite you to talk.

Let's talk