Who this decision is for
These recommendations are addressed to the board and the plant director, who approve the entry rules, and to the data protection officer, who assesses the risk. The decision concerns three groups: own staff, temporary workers and external contractors. For each group the choice of carrier may differ.
A QR code in the InnerWeb system does not require an app: it opens in the browser, and any phone with a screen is enough to show it. This way the choice does not depend on the operating system or the app version, only on the plant's policy.
Recommendations 1-3: whom the private phone covers
First recommendation: for contractors and guests, default to a private phone. The plant will not issue them a work phone and should not force them to have one. They receive the code in a message and show the screen of their device at the gate.
Second: for temporary workers also a private phone, but with a backup channel. When a person has no e-mail address but has a phone number, the code arrives by SMS with a link. When there is no channel at all, nothing is sent and the reception handles the person.
Third: the private phone is used only to show the code, with nothing installed by the plant. If the plant requires no app and no device management profile, the main argument of the DPO against private hardware disappears.
Recommended carrier by group (number of rules in the policy, example calculation)
- Private phone
- Work phone
Recommendations 4-5: when a work phone
Fourth recommendation: designate a work phone where the plant already issues a device for work, for example to foremen and shift managers. Since they hold the phone all shift, the code in it adds no new hardware and gives control over screen lock and updates.
Fifth: do not force a work phone for everyone. Buying several hundred devices just to show a QR code costs more than two years of labels and does not solve the problem of guests. The choice should follow the person's role, not one rule for the whole plant.
Recommendations 6-7: minimisation and security
Sixth: rely on a code carrying only a token. The QR code contains an address with a random token 64 hexadecimal characters long, generated by a random number generator, not from a number, identifier or date. The phone stores no personal data, and the first name, last name and company are displayed by the server at the moment of confirmation.
Seventh: require identity confirmation in sensitive places. A scan on the training tablet shows the first name, last name and company of the code owner, and training starts after the button 'Is this you?'. This one click protects against use of someone else's phone or a screenshot.
- Contractors and guests: private phone.
- Temporary workers: private phone plus SMS as a backup channel.
- Management with a work phone: the code in that phone.
- The code carries only the token; the server displays the data.
- Identity confirmation at the training.
How to agree this with the DPO before the pilot
Before the pilot it is worth writing on one page: what data the system processes (first name, last name, company, entry events), where it comes from, how long it is kept and who sees it. A private phone adds no new data here, because the plant has no access to its content, location or contacts.
The second document is a short notice for the contractor, sent together with the code, saying that the plant scans only the code and not the phone. For the selection criteria the board should record how the gate behaves when the phone does not work: see the emergency scenario in the other pages of this set.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does a private phone require the employee's consent?
The plant does not process the content of the phone, so for many plants information and voluntariness are sufficient. The assessment is always confirmed by the plant's DPO.
Do we have to buy work phones?
No. The QR code opens in the browser of any phone, and buying phones for management is an optional decision.
Does a code in the phone replace the cards?
It does not have to. It can work next to the supplier's KD cards, without replacing readers.
Sources
Let us set the carrier policy before the pilot
We will help the board and the DPO write the rules for guests, contractors and staff. Let's schedule a short call.
Let's talk