InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Cost of lost guest cards vs a QR code on the phone

A guest card that does not come back from a visit costs twice: once as plastic, and once as the time of reception and security staff. Below we show an example calculation for a plant with 40 guests and contractors a day, and indicate which assumptions should be replaced with your own figures.

300
guest cards lost per year in the example
Source: example calculation
PLN 6,900
difference per year in the example calculation
Source: example calculation

What the cost of a lost card consists of

The buyer usually sees one line item: the price of the card. In practice the cost has three components. The first is the medium itself, which has to be bought again. The second is the time of the person who searches for the card, deactivates it in the KD system and issues a replacement. The third is the risk that an unreturned card still opens the gate until someone blocks it.

Treat this page as a skeleton for the calculation. The prices and rates below are example assumptions and do not describe any specific plant. Substitute your own data from purchasing and from the reception log.

Calculation assumptions

We assumed a plant with a daily turnover of 40 guests and contractors, in which 3% of identifiers are not returned or are lost. With 250 working days a year this gives 10,000 visits and 300 lost cards a year, or on average 1.2 cards a day.

The remaining assumptions, namely the price of the card, the time to handle a loss and the hourly rate, are entered as example values to be replaced. The 3% value is an assumption to be substituted, not the result of market research.

Annual cost of losing guest identifiers

Annual cost of losing guest identifiersBefore and after chart: PLN 4,500 for media and PLN 3,000 for handling time with cards, against PLN 300 with the QR code010002000300040005000PLNPlastic cards (Media): 4500 PLN4500 PLNQR code on the phone (Media): 300 PLN300 PLNMediaPlastic cards (Handling time): 3000 PLN3000 PLNQR code on the phone (Handling time): 300 PLN300 PLNHandling time
  • Plastic cards
  • QR code on the phone
Source: Example calculation based on the assumptions in the section Calculation assumptions

Result: plastic card

The loss of the medium is 300 cards at PLN 15 each, which is PLN 4,500 a year. Handling one loss takes 10 minutes: finding the person, blocking the card and issuing a new one. For 300 losses this is 3,000 minutes, or 50 hours, and at PLN 60 an hour that is PLN 3,000. Together PLN 7,500 a year, excluding the cost of buying the initial stock of cards.

Result: QR code on the phone

The message with the QR access code goes to the guest before arrival, and the code is displayed on the phone. There is no medium that can be left in a jacket pocket. A guest without a phone receives a printed label with the code, whose default size is 86 x 54 mm.

Assume that 90% of guests use a phone and 10% use a label. That is 1,000 labels a year at PLN 0.30 each, or PLN 300. Of these labels 3% are not returned, which is 30 pieces, and handling their loss takes 300 minutes, or 5 hours, which is PLN 300. Together PLN 600 a year.

Comparison and limits of the calculation

The difference in the example calculation is PLN 6,900 a year, or about 92% of the cost of losses. The result is sensitive to two assumptions: the share of guests with a phone and the price of the card. When the plant uses cheap contactless cards, the saving on media shrinks, but the saving of time and the closing of the gap left by an unreturned card remain.

What the calculation does not cover: implementation, integration with the existing KD system and reception training. The QR code works alongside the KD vendor's cards, without replacing readers, so the cost of hardware at the gates does not grow. Indicative ranges come from implementations in 2025 and 2026; individual quotation applies.

  • Measure in the reception log the number of cards not returned in the last 12 months.
  • Check in purchasing the actual price of a card and the cost of printing a label.
  • Ask reception how many minutes it takes to handle one loss.
  • Establish in the pilot what share of guests has a phone with a working camera.

The risk that does not show in the spreadsheet

An unreturned guest card is not only a cost of plastic. Until someone blocks it in the KD system, it can open a passage. A plant that does not know how many cards are outside the site does not know how many open accesses exist either. A QR code sent before arrival has an advantage here: it applies to a specific visit, and revoking it issues a new code and disables the old one.

For the purchasing department this is a non-financial argument worth recording next to the calculation. An auditor usually asks for the register of lost identifiers and for the response time, not for the price of plastic.

How to approach the purchase: three steps

First, measure the current state on your own data: the number of cards issued, the number not returned, and the handling time. Second, decide which group the pilot will cover: it is easiest to start with guests and contractors invited by e-mail or SMS. Third, set an alternative for people without a phone, namely a label printed at reception.

A guest registered at reception is created with only a first name, last name and phone number, and receives a printed QR code label in one action, so this alternative does not lengthen the handling time. Invitations can also be sent to people without an e-mail address, using their phone number or registration number.

Example calculation

Example calculation: lost guest cards

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Guests and contractors per day40 people
Working days per year250 days
Share of cards not returned3 %
Card price (to be replaced)15 PLN
Handling time per loss10 min
Reception hourly rate60 PLN/h
Guests with a phone90 %
Label cost0.30 PLN

Result: Cards: PLN 7,500 a year. QR code: PLN 600 a year. Difference: PLN 6,900 a year.

Note: Example calculation based on assumptions to be replaced. It does not describe any specific plant.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does a QR code completely eliminate the cost of losses?

No. The cost of labels for guests without a phone and the time to handle their losses remain. The example calculation shows how large this remaining cost is.

Does dropping cards require replacing readers?

No. We deploy the QR code alongside the KD vendor's cards, so the readers at the gates stay. Employee cards can keep working as before.

What about a guest who loses the phone or runs its battery down?

Reception prints a label with the code, and revoking issues a new code and disables the old one. Details are in the guide on a lost phone.

Let us calculate it with your figures

Together we will put the data from your reception and purchasing into the calculation, and show the guest's QR code on the phone at an example plant.

Let's talk