InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Recommendations: LoRa, Wi-Fi or LTE in a plant

The technical director compares the cost of cable, Wi-Fi and an LTE module for gateways on a plant site. The question is slightly misframed, because LoRa links the watches to the gateway, while cable, Wi-Fi and LTE link the gateway to the system. Below are seven recommendations on choosing the path for each gateway separately.

about 100 PLN
simple gateway with a single radio (indicative range)
Source: spec card
TTL 2 to 3
hop counter of the repeater
Source: spec card

Two different links that must not be confused

In a location system with a LoRa watch there are two segments. The first is the radio link from the watch to the gateway: LoRa in the 869.525 MHz band, designed to work without Wi-Fi and without GSM on the watch. The second is the link from the gateway to the system: here you choose between Ethernet or PoE, Wi-Fi, an LTE module, or forwarding through another gateway.

Not every LoRa gateway in a plant has Wi-Fi, so the data from all gateways must reach the one that has access to the internet. The choice of path is made per gateway, not per plant.

Seven recommendations

The recommendations are ordered by the questions a technical director asks when reviewing connectivity offers.

1. In a hall with cabling, choose Ethernet or PoE

Where a cable already exists, this is the cheapest and most predictable path. PoE also provides power, so the gateway does not need a separate electrical installation.

2. When the gateway is far away but has power and GSM coverage, choose LTE

An LTE module on the gateway avoids laying cable over distances of hundreds of metres. It requires a SIM card, a subscription, and a check of coverage at the mounting point, not across the whole plant.

3. Treat Wi-Fi as the option where it already works

Existing Wi-Fi in an office building can serve a gateway at no extra cost. Building Wi-Fi on a yard just for one gateway rarely pays off.

4. For gateways with no link at all, use a repeater

A repeater gateway forwards InnerWeb protocol frames to a gateway with internet access, with a hop counter (TTL) of 2 to 3 and frame deduplication. It requires no new hardware on the system side.

5. Do not plan mesh as the first choice

A mesh network as the aggregation link requires a second radio at the gateway, an MQTT broker and a consumer on the system side, as well as a separate frequency plan. It is a variant for larger layouts, not for the first pilot.

6. Treat gateway power as a condition, not an extra

A gateway without a stable power supply is not a gateway. The hidden cost can be bringing power to a mast or to the end building. Calculate it together with the link.

7. Compare the total cost, not the price of the module

Cable means labour and wall penetrations, LTE means a monthly subscription, Wi-Fi means signal quality control, and a repeater is one additional gateway. A three-year comparison gives a different picture than a comparison of purchase prices.

Indicative gateway hardware cost by variant

Indicative gateway hardware cost by variantBar chart: a simple gateway costs about 100 PLN, a LoRaWAN gateway between 700 and 900 PLN02004006008001000PLNSimple gateway (one radio)Simple gateway (one radio): 100 PLN100LoRaWAN gateway, lower boundLoRaWAN gateway, lower bound: 700 PLN700LoRaWAN gateway, upper boundLoRaWAN gateway, upper bound: 900 PLN900
Source: Indicative ranges from 2025 to 2026 deployments; price quoted individually

Decision table for one gateway

For each gateway, answer three questions in order and stop at the first yes.

  • Is there a cable or an easy cable route at the mounting point: Ethernet or PoE.
  • Is there power and GSM coverage but no cable: an LTE module on the gateway.
  • Is there working Wi-Fi without additional investment: Wi-Fi.
  • None of the above: a repeater gateway to a gateway with internet access.

Why LoRa does not replace the gateway link

LoRa handles long range and low energy use well, but it carries small frames. It is not a link for transferring application data. That is why a gateway always needs some path to the system, and a repeater only shortens the path to the nearest gateway with internet access.

What the choice costs: ranges for the conversation

The indicative cost of a simple gateway with a single radio is about 100 PLN, and LoRaWAN gateways with a concentrator cost about 700 to 900 PLN. These are indicative ranges from 2025 to 2026 deployments; the price is quoted individually. On top of that comes the link: the cable, the LTE subscription, or a second gateway unit used as a repeater.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does LoRa replace Wi-Fi in a plant?

Not entirely. LoRa links the watch to the gateway, and the gateway still needs a link to the system: cable, Wi-Fi, LTE, or forwarding through a repeater.

When is LTE better than cable?

When the gateway is far away, has power and GSM coverage, and laying cable would be expensive or impossible.

Does a repeater require changes in the system?

No. The repeater variant forwards InnerWeb protocol frames to a gateway with internet access and needs no new hardware on the system side.

Let's match a link to each gateway

We will walk through your site plan with you and show where a cable is enough, where LTE fits, and where a repeater is needed. We invite you to a conversation.

Let's talk