InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Link cost for a distant gateway: LTE or a LoRa repeater

A distant gateway has to pass its data to the system somehow: through its own LTE module, or through a repeater gateway that relays the frames onward. For purchasing the difference lies not in the hardware price but in subscriptions, power and the number of points to maintain over several years.

TTL 2-3
hop counter of the repeater gateway
Source: karta
about 100 PLN
simple gateway as the reference point for the repeater
Source: karta
1250 PLN
LTE per point over 36 months, example calculation
Source: kalkulacja przykładowa

The problem: a gateway without Wi-Fi

Not every LoRa gateway at a plant has Wi-Fi, and the data from all gateways must reach the one that has internet access. A typical case is a gateway on a distant yard, at a side gate or on a warehouse roof, where the plant network does not reach.

There are three ways to reach the internet: Ethernet or PoE where cabling exists, an LTE module where the gateway has power and GSM coverage, and a repeater gateway that passes the frames to a gateway with internet access. This page compares the last two.

Two options and their limits

The LTE option: the distant gateway gets an LTE module and its own SIM card. Data goes directly to the system, without the involvement of other gateways. The condition is power and GSM coverage at the mounting place.

The repeater option: the repeater gateway relays InnerWeb protocol frames to a gateway with internet access, with a hop counter (TTL) of 2-3 and frame deduplication. It requires no new hardware on the system side. The limit is the radio range to the next gateway and the number of hops.

Why not a mesh as the collective link

A mesh network as the collective link requires a second radio at the gateway, an MQTT broker, a consumer on the system side and a separate frequency plan, because the default mesh slot overlaps the 869.4-869.65 MHz channel. Two different radio protocols on one SX1262 chip cannot be listened to at the same time, so a dual-radio gateway means two boards or two modules. This is the more expensive and more complex option, considered only when the repeater is not enough.

Cumulative cost of one point: LTE and repeater

Cumulative cost of one point: LTE and repeaterLine chart: LTE cost grows from 350 PLN to 1250 PLN over 36 months, the repeater cost stays flat at 200 PLN025050075010001250PLNStart12 months24 months36 monthsLTE (Start): 350 PLN350LTE (12 months): 650 PLN650LTE (24 months): 950 PLN950LTE (36 months): 1250 PLN1250Repeater (Start): 200 PLN200Repeater (12 months): 200 PLN200Repeater (24 months): 200 PLN200Repeater (36 months): 200 PLN200
  • LTE
  • Repeater
Source: Example calculation on assumptions: LTE module 250 PLN, subscription 25 PLN/month, repeater 100 PLN, mounting and power 100 PLN

Cost structure from the purchasing point of view

The LTE cost has two components: a one-off module and a recurring subscription. The cost of a repeater is another gateway and its power, but no subscription. A simple gateway costs roughly 100 PLN, which is the reference point for the repeater. These are indicative ranges from 2025-2026 deployments; pricing is individual.

In the summary below, the LTE module price and subscription are assumptions for the example calculation. They should be replaced with current prices from the operator's and the module supplier's offers.

  • LTE: module once, SIM card, subscription every month, power, GSM coverage.
  • Repeater: gateway about 100 PLN, power, enclosure, a place within radio range of the gateway with internet access.
  • Common: mounting, coverage test, site documentation.

Example calculation over 36 months

Let us assume one distant gateway and a 36-month horizon. Assumptions: an LTE module at 250 PLN one-off, a subscription at 25 PLN per month, a repeater as a simple gateway at 100 PLN, and additional mounting and power of 100 PLN for each option. Results: LTE comes to 250 + 36 x 25 + 100 = 1250 PLN, the repeater to 100 + 100 = 200 PLN.

The difference grows with the number of points: for three distant gateways it is about 3750 PLN against 600 PLN. The repeater wins on cost, provided there is an intermediate point with power within radio range. Where there is none, LTE is the only route and the subscription cost must be written into the budget.

How to decide in purchasing

Three questions help the decision. Is there power at the gateway location? Is there radio range from that location to a gateway with internet access or to an intermediate repeater? Will someone at the plant take responsibility for the SIM card and its renewals? If the answers are yes, yes, no, the repeater is the more sensible choice.

For small sites the rule is simple: the watch stays on the InnerWeb protocol, and the backhaul is built only at the first site without full Wi-Fi coverage, by default as a repeater variant.

Example calculation

One distant point over 36 months

Assumptions
ParameterValue
LTE module (example assumption)250 PLN one-off
LTE subscription (example assumption)25 PLN/month
Repeater as a simple gateway100 PLN
Mounting and power of the point100 PLN per option
Horizon36 months

Result: LTE: 250 + 36 x 25 + 100 = 1250 PLN. Repeater: 100 + 100 = 200 PLN. Difference about 1050 PLN per point.

Note: Example calculation. The LTE module and subscription prices are assumptions and should be replaced with offers. Indicative ranges from 2025-2026 deployments; pricing is individual.

Video

Frequently asked questions

When is LTE the only option?

When there is no point with power and internet, or an intermediate repeater, within radio range of the distant gateway. Then the gateway needs power and GSM coverage.

How many hops can a repeater have?

The hop counter (TTL) is 2-3, and frame deduplication prevents the same frame from being reported to the system more than once.

Does the repeater require changes on the system side?

No. The repeater variant requires no new hardware on the system side, because InnerWeb protocol frames reach the same gateway with internet access.

Let us count the link for your gateways

Based on the placement of your points we will suggest where a repeater is enough and where LTE is needed. Let us arrange a short call.

Let's talk