InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Recommendations: which employee card for a plant

Management and procurement usually ask one question: which card to buy so that it does not have to be replaced in three years. Below are seven recommendations for a production plant, based on public documentation of card technologies, with criteria for security, reader compatibility and the structure of cost.

AES-128
encryption in DESFire EV2 and EV3 cards
Source: NXP
7
recommendations for management and procurement
Source: own elaboration

Who these recommendations are for

We address these recommendations to the plant director, the procurement department, and the heads of IT and security who choose the card technology for a new system or when replacing an old one. We assume a production plant with several hundred to several thousand people, where the card serves gates, lockers and working time registration, and where contractor employees enter alongside the plant's own staff.

InnerWeb does not sell cards or readers. We write from the perspective of a software integrator that receives events from the access control system and must be certain that the identifier is reliable.

Recommendation 1: do not choose a technology with broken encryption

MIFARE Classic relies on the Crypto1 cipher, which has been publicly broken, so it is not suitable for new deployments that require security. The reasoning is simple: the cost of copying such a card is low, while the consequences of misuse, for example entry into a hall, are high.

The same applies to cards that transmit only the number without authentication. If the current system relies on such cards, the recommendation for management should include an exit plan, not just add new cards alongside them.

Sample structure of the total cost of a card system (assumption)

Sample structure of the total cost of a card system (assumption)Horizontal bars: readers and SAM 45 percent, cards 20, personalisation 20, staff time 15.01020304050%Readers and SAM modulesReaders and SAM modules: 45 %45CardsCards: 20 %20Personalisation and stationPersonalisation and station: 20 %20HR and security staff timeHR and security staff time: 15 %15
Source: Sample calculation: structure assumed for the request for quotation, to be replaced with the plant's data

Recommendation 2: choose a card with AES-128 compliant with ISO/IEC 14443

MIFARE DESFire EV2 and EV3 use AES-128 encryption and operate in line with ISO/IEC 14443. Compliance with the standard matters for purchasing: it reduces dependence on a single reader supplier and allows offers from different access control integrators to be compared.

Before deciding, check in writing with the access control system supplier whether the readers support DESFire in the required version, and whether the operating mode is reading the identifier or full authentication with a key.

Recommendation 3: diversify the keys

Key diversification means that the card key is derived from a master key and the unique UID of the card, so the leak of one card key does not open the others. This is one of the cheapest security strengthenings, because it does not change the card price and only requires a decision in the design.

If a supplier proposes one shared key for all cards, the request for quotation should require a justification. A shared key means that obtaining it once opens the whole plant.

Recommendation 4: establish where the master key is stored

The SAM module in the reader stores master keys in a protected chip and performs card authentication, so that the keys never leave the reader. The request for quotation must state whether the solution requires a SAM module, because it affects the reader price and the ordering process.

A variant without a SAM module is possible, but then the key must be protected organisationally: a separate key administrator role and a backup kept separately.

Recommendation 5: calculate the total cost, not the card price

The unit price of the card is usually the smallest component. The total cost includes: readers or their modification, SAM modules where they are required, personalisation, the issuing station, the time of HR and security staff, and the cost of replacing lost cards. Indicative ranges from deployments in 2025 to 2026 depend on scale and require an individual quotation.

When comparing offers, it is worth setting them side by side using the same list of items. An offer with a cheaper card but a need to replace readers may be more expensive than an offer with a more expensive card and compatible readers.

Recommendations 6 and 7: integration and compatibility with existing systems

When choosing a card, ask how the tap events will reach other systems. InnerWeb receives card tap events from the access control system through a webhook and links them with qualifications, permits, attendance and working time registration. As a result, the choice of card technology does not close the path to these functions.

Recommendation seven: plan the visitor card and the external company card from the start. A visitor card should have limited validity, limited zones and mandatory return, and the register should indicate the inviting person.

The most common mistakes when choosing a card

The first mistake is choosing a card solely on the unit price, without checking whether the existing readers will support it. The second is failing to write into the contract who is responsible for the master key and where its backup copy is kept. The third is omitting visitor cards and external company cards, which in a three-shift plant make up a significant part of the traffic at the gates.

The fourth mistake is assuming that card encryption solves the whole problem. A card with AES-128 protects against copying, but it does not protect against duplicate accounts, a card lent to a colleague, or a lost card that was not blocked. That is why the recommendation for management should also cover the process: the card register, blocking after a loss is reported, and a quarterly check.

It is also worth agreeing with the access control supplier how long the chosen technology will be supported and what are the terms of card supply after the project ends. A card that cannot be reordered after two years forces another replacement that is as costly as the first one.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is the DESFire EV3 card necessary?

Not always. EV2 and EV3 both use AES-128, so both meet the encryption criterion. The choice depends on reader compatibility.

Is a SAM module mandatory?

No, but it allows master keys to be kept in the reader. Without it, the key must be protected organisationally.

What is the most expensive part of a card system?

Usually the readers and the staff time, not the card itself. The cost structure is worth calculating for your own plant.

Sources

Let us compare card offers on one list

We will help prepare the request for quotation and set out the total cost without taking on the role of the reader supplier.

Let's talk