Starting point: legacy system and three shifts
The scenario concerns a production plant with three shifts, where its own employees and contractors enter through several gates and turnstiles. Some cards are old identifiers, and some are MIFARE Classic. The IT department wants to move to a card with stronger encryption, but security requires that no gate is left without a working reader during the night shift.
This is a concept for a plant of this type, not a description of a specific implementation. The numerical values in the calculation box are sample assumptions that each plant will replace with its own.
Why replace: Crypto1 and AES-128
MIFARE Classic relies on the Crypto1 cipher, which has been publicly broken, so it is not suitable for new deployments that require security. MIFARE DESFire EV2 and EV3 use AES-128 encryption and operate in line with ISO/IEC 14443, which means that many modern readers can handle them after proper configuration.
Cards at 125 kHz usually transmit only the identification number to the reader, without mutual authentication, so copying them is cheaper than in the case of encrypted cards. The argument for replacement is therefore both technical and organisational: the card should be proof of identity, not a number to be read.
Card replacement: hours per group of 200 people by number of stations
Stage 1: inventory and decisions before the first card is lost
Before ordering cards, the readers must be counted, the card types in circulation identified, and it must be established with the access control system supplier whether the existing readers support DESFire. InnerWeb does not manufacture or replace readers: it integrates with the client's existing access control system, so this part of the discussion takes place between the plant and the access control supplier.
The second decision is the key model. A card key derived from a master key and the card UID (diversification) means that the leak of one card key does not open the others. It is worth settling this before ordering, because changing the model after the cards have been issued means personalising all the cards again.
- number of gates, turnstiles and readers on each shift
- card types in circulation: 125 kHz, MIFARE Classic, other
- DESFire support in the existing readers
- key model and the person responsible for the master key
Stage 2: dual-technology readers and parallel operation
The safest pattern for a three-shift plant is a parallel period: the reader reads both the old and the new card, and the access control system assigns both to the same person. The employee receives the new card when issued on their shift, and the old card remains valid until the cut-off day.
The replacement does not stop production, because no gate goes into a state where it recognises only the new card type. The daily replacement plan can be divided into groups by shift: issuing on the morning shift for morning workers, on the afternoon shift for afternoon workers and on the night shift for night workers, so that nobody has to come in outside working hours.
For external companies a separate schedule and a list of inviting persons work well. The card is then issued through the same process that applies to visitor cards, with limited validity.
Stage 3: cutting off old cards and checking duplicates
The cut-off takes place once a threshold of replaced cards is reached, for example 98 percent of employees on each shift. The remaining people are identified on a list, and their supervisors are called the day before, not only at the gate.
At this point the problem known from imports returns: accounts with a card and accounts without one. If the old card was assigned to one account and the new one was added to another, the gate will report missing training. That is why, after the replacement, it is worth running the check of duplicate account pairs described in a separate case.
Old cards are returned to the register with the status returned, rather than being destroyed without a trace. Physical destruction is carried out only after the register has been checked.
Sample calculation: how long the replacement takes
Sample assumptions: 600 employees, 3 shifts of 200 people each, an issuing station serves 24 people per hour, and the replacement takes place in the first hour of each shift using 2 stations. This gives 48 people per hour, that is about 4 hours for a group of 200 people, but spread over 5 working days with 1 hour of replacement per shift, it does not disrupt production.
The result depends on the number of stations and on whether the issue is combined with a new photo and signature. The calculation is a sample and serves to establish the order of magnitude before the conversation with the access control supplier.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does replacing cards require gate downtime?
No, provided the readers support both technologies during the parallel period. The old card remains valid until the cut-off day.
Does InnerWeb replace readers?
No. InnerWeb is a software producer and integrates with the client's existing access control system.
Why is MIFARE Classic not suitable for new deployments?
It relies on the Crypto1 cipher, which has been publicly broken.
When should old cards be cut off?
After reaching the agreed threshold of replaced cards on each shift, with a list of the remaining people and earlier contact with their supervisors.
Sources
Plan the card replacement without downtime
We will go through the inventory and the parallel period schedule with your IT and security teams.
Let's talk