Why criteria are needed, not a feeling
Buying in stages makes sense only when the move between stages is a decision based on results. Without criteria, the plant director releases funds out of a sense that everything is going well, or holds them back out of caution. Both decisions are costly: the first exposes the budget, and the second delays the effect.
It is worth agreeing the criteria before signing the contract and recording them in the same document as the payment schedule. Then the control point is a discussion of facts, not of opinions.
Four criteria for moving from stage one to stage two
The first criterion is the acceptance of stage I: a working training module and an instance with the map. The second is an accepted test permit, that is stage II in the three-stage variant, carried out on a real site. The third is stable coverage: the BLE transmitter network gives positions without gaps in the key zones, and the location works without GPS, using signals from several transmitters averaged on the map. The fourth is usage: the share of active users against the planned number.
The fourth criterion has a financial meaning. A licence is counted per active user, meaning an account with at least one login in a month, so a low share of active users means either too many licences or no rollout in the organisation. There is no point in extending a system that is not used at the first site.
- acceptance of stage I: the training module and the instance with the map work
- an accepted test permit on a real site
- transmitter coverage without gaps in the key zones
- active users close to the plan from the request
Structure of the 2,400 PLN net monthly subscription
Signals that a stage has to be repeated
A stage is worth repeating when the criteria are met only partly and the problem is organisational rather than technical. Typical signals are: the training module works, but only a small share of people have completed the training; the test permit passed, but only after the supplier's intervention; the map is there, but in two zones the position wavers because transmitters were placed too sparsely.
In such situations repeating the stage is cheaper than expanding. When there are no coverage gaps, the solution usually comes down to adding transmitters, and a network of 100 units on a subscription costs 700 PLN net per month without buying hardware and covers typically about 20,000 m2.
Cost of running the network after expansion
When deciding on stage two, the director should know the fixed cost after the expansion. Running a working network of 200 transmitters costs 7 PLN net per unit per month, that is 1,400 PLN, with battery replacement about every 4 years included in the service. Together with the server and licences at 800 PLN and two watches at 200 PLN, the subscription comes to 2,400 PLN net per month.
The structure of the 2,400 PLN is therefore: 1,400 PLN the transmitter network, 800 PLN the server and licences, 200 PLN the watches. It is worth showing this to the board together with the request for stage two, so that the operating cost is not a surprise.
First year of the inactivity pilot: implementation and subscription
Example: the inactivity detection pilot as stage one
If stage one is a pilot of inactivity detection, its first year costs 28,000 PLN net (9,400 PLN of implementation plus 12 times 1,550 PLN of subscription), of which implementation is about 34% and the subscription about 66%. The control point after that year should answer three questions: did alarms reach the right people, were the watches charged and worn, and did the map cover the zones of lone work.
Only a complete set of answers justifies a request for stage two, for example extension to further zones. Add 23% VAT to the net amounts, and the price ranges are indicative and require an individual quotation.
How to record the decision in the control point protocol
The protocol is one page: the criteria, the results, the decision (move on, repeat, stop) and the date. It is signed by the system owner and the plant director, and the controller receives a copy for settlements. Remember that the contract is for an indefinite period with monthly notice, so stopping the project after stage one is a real option, not an exception.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Who decides on moving to stage two?
The plant director, on the request of the system owner, after the agreed criteria are met and on the basis of the control point protocol.
Can the project be stopped after stage one?
Yes. The contract is for an indefinite period with monthly notice, and payments are tied to stage acceptances.
What does maintaining the transmitter network include?
For a network of 200 transmitters it is 7 PLN net per unit per month, with battery replacement about every 4 years included in the service.
What area does a 100-transmitter network cover?
Typically about 20,000 m2, and a 100-transmitter network on subscription costs 700 PLN net per month without buying hardware.
Let's agree the stage criteria together
We will help you write down the criteria for moving on and the control points in the schedule. Book a call.
Let's talk