Three factors and one number
A risk assessment in the InnerWeb editor is the product of probability, exposure and severity, compared with the thresholds 20, 70, 200 and 400. The result is shown twice: before the protective measures are applied and after them. In this way the OHS specialist not only states that the risk exists, but shows how much it has fallen after specific actions.
Similar numerical methods based on the product of three factors are known from OHS literature, and the scales of the individual factors are set by the plant. It is important to use one scale for all machines within the plant, because only then are the results comparable and can priorities be built from them.
What the factors mean in service work
Probability describes how often the given event may occur during this work. Exposure describes how long and how often the service technician stays in the hazard zone, for example inside the machine's enclosure. Severity describes how serious the consequences may be. Machine service has its own specifics: short but intensive exposure in the area of moving parts or residual energy.
Worked example step by step
The example below is illustrative, and the values of the factors are assumptions, not the result of an assessment of a real machine. Let us assume a service of a machine in which contact with a moving element is possible when residual energy is released. We take probability 3, exposure 6 and severity 15. The product is 3 x 6 x 15, which equals 270. The result falls between the thresholds 200 and 400, so according to this scale it requires priority actions.
Next we select protective measures: isolation and securing of energy, a lock against unintended start-up, a guard for the moving element for the duration of the service, and instruction before entry. After they are applied we assess again. Probability drops to 1, exposure to 3, and severity stays unchanged, because protective measures do not reduce the severity of a possible injury. The product is 1 x 3 x 15, which equals 45, that is below the threshold 70.
Why severity usually does not change
Technical and organisational measures usually lower the probability or the exposure. Severity falls only with measures that limit the energy of the event, such as guards or reducing the force. If after the re-assessment severity drops, but the assessment does not describe a specific measure limiting the energy, it is worth asking where that change comes from.
Risk assessment result before and after protective measures
How the thresholds 20, 70, 200 and 400 help set priorities
The thresholds divide the scale into ranges, and the plant assigns each of them a required response: acceptance, observation, actions within a set time, priority actions, or stopping the work. The names of the ranges and the responses belong to the plant's procedure. The system compares the result with the thresholds and shows where the result lies, and the decision to admit the work remains with the authorised person.
In practice the following rule works well: work with a risk above the set threshold after protective measures does not receive approval until the assessment is corrected or a further measure is added. We record this rule in the instructions, because the system does not replace the decision of the OHS specialist.
Risk catalogue and location
The risk catalogue is hierarchical and assigned to locations (hall, area, line, place) and to the type of dangerous work. As a result, a risk assessed once for a machine's working position appears with every permit covering that location and is not entered again. The person ordering the work may add a risk on an ad hoc basis when the service requires something the catalogue does not yet have.
A risk can be added from the 3D map editor without leaving the editor, and new risks are created by the administrator or OHS. This separation of roles is deliberate: the service technician does not extend the risk catalogue during the work, and an ad hoc addition by the ordering person remains visible in the permit.
How risks reach the printout
The printout of the permit contains the risks in five sections with deduplication: common risks, location hierarchy, additional locations, type of dangerous work and user risks. Deduplication means the same risk does not repeat four times on one sheet.
Evidence for an audit
For an auditor three things matter: that the assessment existed before the work, that it was calculated on one scale, and that after the protective measures the result decreased. The system stores the value before and after, the link with the location and the permit, and the printout in the established format. This supports meeting the requirement to document the risk assessment, but does not replace the plant's methodology or the responsibility of the people who carry out the assessment.
Example of a machine service risk assessment
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Probability before / after | 3 / 1 pts |
| Exposure before / after | 6 / 3 pts |
| Severity before / after | 15 / 15 pts |
Result: Before: 3 x 6 x 15 = 270 (between thresholds 200 and 400). After: 1 x 3 x 15 = 45 (below threshold 70).
Note: Sample calculation with values assumed for illustration; the scales of the factors and the responses to the thresholds are set by the plant.
Checklist
Video
Frequently asked questions
Are the thresholds 20, 70, 200 and 400 fixed?
The system compares the result with these thresholds, and the meaning of the ranges and the required responses are set by the plant's procedure. One scale across the plant is the condition for comparability.
Who adds a new risk to the catalogue?
New risks are created by the administrator or OHS. The ordering person may add a risk on an ad hoc basis to a permit.
Does the assessment replace the OHS decision?
No. The assessment supports the decision and provides evidence for an audit, but the admission of the work remains with the authorised person.
We will show risk assessment in the editor
In a demo we will go from the risk catalogue at the location to the assessment before and after protective measures for the service of your machine.
Let's talk