Who these recommendations are for
The recommendations are addressed to the plant director, the security manager and the purchasing department, who prepare the access control specification. They assume that the plant is an employer within the meaning of the Labour Code and that biometrics would apply to employees, not visitors.
A typical conclusion from an impact assessment of employee entry control is that for most areas of the plant a card or QR code is sufficient, and biometrics is considered only for narrow zones of special protection. The recommendations below develop this conclusion.
Recommendations 1 to 4: when to stay with a card or QR
The first four recommendations apply to the great majority of plants and allow rejecting biometrics already at the tender stage, before it starts to generate legal and organisational costs.
1. Start from the purpose, not the technology
Record what the entry control is meant to protect: a warehouse, the production hall or a server room. Only then choose the measure. Article 22(1b) of the Labour Code links biometrics with access control to particularly important information or rooms requiring special protection, so the purpose is the gate to a discussion about a fingerprint.
2. Use an encrypted 13.56 MHz card for standard zones
DESFire proximity cards provide encrypted communication and key management. For gates, changing rooms, canteens and halls without special protection, this is a complete solution and far simpler legally than biometrics.
3. Keep the QR code for visitors and temporary staff
A QR code on a badge or in an invitation suits people who appear for a short time. It does not require collecting a special category of data and can be revoked with one action.
4. Record the alternative already in the specification
If any zones are to be biometric, require the supplier to make the same reader accept a card or PIN. The alternative must not be a workaround invented after deployment.
Number of people with a fingerprint, example
- Biometrics for everyone
- Biometrics only in the special zone
Recommendations 5 to 7: if biometrics comes into play
The next three recommendations apply to narrow zones where the plant has a justification for a fingerprint and wants to document it.
Recommendation 5: demonstrate necessity. The employer must show that biometrics is needed for the access control purpose, not merely convenient or cheap. Recommendation 6: carry out a data protection impact assessment before purchase, because Article 35 GDPR requires it before starting high-risk processing. Recommendation 7: limit the scope to people who actually enter the zone, and plan the deletion of templates after a change of position or departure.
- demonstrated necessity recorded in a document before the readers are purchased
- DPIA completed before processing starts
- scope of biometrics limited to a narrow list of zones and people
- template deletion procedure linked to HR
InnerWeb's place in the decision
InnerWeb is a software producer, not a reader producer. It does not sell or replace access control readers, including biometric ones, but integrates with the KD system that the plant already has or will choose. The system receives access events via webhook and links them with qualifications, permits, attendance and time and attendance (RCP) records.
From InnerWeb's point of view the choice between biometrics and a card is neutral: the event is a person identifier and a timestamp. The plant can therefore change the entry technology without rebuilding permits and trainings.
Example calculation: how many people biometrics would cover
Assume a plant with 600 employees and three entry zones: the main gate, the halls and one zone of special protection entered by 30 people. With a card for everyone and biometrics only for that zone, fingerprints concern 5% of the workforce instead of 100%. These are illustrative assumptions.
A smaller circle means fewer consents or grounds to examine, fewer templates to protect and fewer withdrawals to handle, and therefore lower risk and lower organisational cost.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Can biometrics be introduced everywhere if employees agree?
Consent alone does not settle the matter, because in an employment relationship it raises doubts due to the imbalance between the parties. The employer must also demonstrate necessity for the access control purpose.
Is an encrypted card secure?
DESFire cards with encryption and key management are widely used in access control. The level of security also depends on key configuration and procedures.
What about visitors?
For visitors a QR code or a temporary card is appropriate. Biometrics for visitors is usually not justified.
Sources
Let us prepare the entry specification
We will help describe how events from your KD system feed permits and attendance, whether you choose a card, QR code or biometrics.
Let's talk