InnerWeb
Skip to main content

General location rate in permits: how to count it and reduce it

In the analysis of 106 permits, 44 pointed to a general location, meaning the building, Other or Whole line, instead of a machine. That is 41.5% of permits where the risks are hard to assign to a place. This guide shows how to count the rate, how to set an improvement target quarter by quarter and what to show the auditor.

44 of 106
permits with a general location in the analysis
Source: analysis of 106 permits over 9 weeks at a continuously running plant
63%
of permits belonged to the four largest contracting firms
Source: analysis of 106 permits

What a general location is and why it hurts

A general location is the indication of a work place at the level of the building, the Other position or the Whole line, instead of a specific point at the machine. The permit is then formally valid, but it does not say where exactly the crew is standing.

This has practical effects. Risks assigned to the location of a kiln or a filter will not link to a permit that points to a whole line. After an incident it is harder to establish who was nearby, and during an audit it is harder to show that the permit concerned a place with defined hazards.

The rate formula step by step

The rate is the number of permits with a general location divided by the number of all permits in the period, multiplied by 100. For the example from the analysis: 44 divided by 106 is about 41.5%. Choose a fixed period, ideally a quarter, so that the results can be compared.

What to count as general

Treat as general any location at the building level, the Other position and the Whole line. Points at the machine, such as a filter, a section, a feed point or a chamber, count as specific.

Additional split by hall

In the analysis, 76 of 106 permits concerned two halls. Count the rate separately for each of them. The hall with the highest share of general locations is the first candidate for a conversation with the contracting firms.

Location in permits: general versus specific

Location in permits: general versus specificDonut chart: 44 permits with a general location and 62 with a specific pointGeneral (building, Other, Whole line): 44 permits (41.5%)Specific point: 62 permits (58.5%)106permitsGeneral (building, Other, Wholeline)44 permits (41.5%)Specific point62 permits (58.5%)
Source: Analysis of 106 permits over 9 weeks; specific point = 106 minus 44

How to set an improvement target quarter by quarter

The share of permits with a general location is a data quality indicator to be lowered quarter by quarter. The contractor should choose a specific point at the machine. Set the target as a realistic goal, not a one-off jump, because too sharp a requirement will increase the number of rejections and load the approvers at the peak.

A sample path: a base quarter with a result of about 41.5%, and in the following quarters a reduction by a fixed number of percentage points, agreed with the safety department and the contracting firms. The concrete values of the target are the plant's decision, because they depend on how precisely the points at the machines are described.

How to get contractors to choose a point

The four largest contracting firms held 63% of the permits in the analysis. A conversation with a few firms is therefore enough for the indicator to fall noticeably. Show them the result of their own permits and indicate which points at the machines are available in the editor.

A well-organized location structure also helps: if the line has named points, the contractor picks them from a list instead of describing the place in words. Manual tidying of the structure and a script with gates are described in a separate cost calculation.

Proof for the audit

For the auditor the trend is the value, not a one-off result. Save the indicator at the end of every quarter, together with the number of permits and the split by hall. Such a record shows that the plant measures the quality of data about the work place and reacts to the result, but it is not a guarantee of compliance with any regulation.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is a general location an error?

No, it is permissible, but it has less value: it does not let the permit be linked to the risks of a specific machine. The indicator is there so that the share of such permits falls.

What result counts as good?

The plant sets the target itself, based on the base result. The analysis started at about 41.5%, and the goal is to reduce it quarter by quarter.

Does the indicator burden the contractors?

It requires them to choose a point at the machine, which takes a moment when the structure is well organized. The burden falls when the points are named and available in a list.

Does the indicator apply to all types of work?

Yes, it can be counted for all permits, and additionally separately for hot work and work at height, which in the analysis accounted for 43 and 40 permits.

Count the rate on your permits

We will go through your list of permits from the last quarter and set the improvement target. Book a conversation with the safety department.

Let's talk