Why line names must be unique
In one building there are lines with the same names in different zones: Filter, Hopper, Cooling section. For a person who knows the plant the difference is obvious, for an outside contractor it is not. In a permit for hot work, choosing the wrong line means that the watch and the safety measures apply to a different place.
Line names are unique within a building thanks to the zone suffix. Instead of two entries Filter in the list, there are Filter north zone and Filter south zone.
Practice 1: a zone suffix instead of a number
The zone suffix should describe the location, not the order of creation. A number such as Filter 2 only says that there is a first filter somewhere. A zone suffix, for example Filter east zone, lets you find the place without knowing the history of the plant.
The suffix should come from the existing nomenclature of the plant: from the markings on drawings, plates and in the operating instructions. Then the person in the field will find the same words on the plate and in the system.
- The suffix describes the zone, not a sequence number.
- The dictionary of zones comes from the markings in the plant.
- The name is unique within the building.
- Changes to names go through one owner of the dictionary.
Permits by the way the place is indicated (9-week analysis)
Practice 2: exactly one Other location per line
Each line contains exactly one collective location Other, with the highest identifier, placed in the middle of the line. Two Other entries in one line distort the statistics, and an Other at the edge of the line misleads about the position.
The middle of the line is a safe default position: the position error relative to the real place is then the smallest. The highest identifier lets automated tools and gates point to this one location unambiguously, without comparing names.
Practice 3: Other as a quality indicator, not a convenient shortcut
The contractor should choose a specific point at the machine, for example a filter, a section, a hopper or a chamber. Other is for places that are not on the list. The share of permits with a general location is an indicator of data quality, worth reducing from quarter to quarter.
In an analysis of 106 permits from 9 weeks at an insulation materials plant running continuous operation, 44 permits pointed to a general location (building, Other, Whole line) instead of a machine. This is 42% of permits, which make it harder for the accepting person to assess the risk.
Practice 4: control gates and a review after migration
The rules of name uniqueness and of a single Other can be turned into automatic gates: overlapping lines, pins outside the line, Other outside the middle, and duplicates. Each gate has a red test, that is an example deliberately breaking the rule, which must be stopped.
After regenerating the structure, compare by content (name, area, level, geometry), not by identifiers. Only such a check gives certainty that the tidying did not change the meaning of the map.
Share of general locations in the permit analysis
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Permits in the analysis | 106 pcs |
| With a general location | 44 pcs |
Result: 44 of 106 is about 42% of permits.
Note: Data from the analysis of one insulation materials plant; for your own decisions, calculate the indicator on your own data.
Checklist
Video
Frequently asked questions
Why is a number in the line name not enough?
A number does not say where the line is. A zone suffix lets an outside contractor find the place without knowing the history of the plant.
Where should the Other location be set?
In the middle of the line, as its only Other location, with the highest identifier. The middle minimises the position error for places outside the list.
How do you assess the quality of place selection in permits?
By measuring the share of permits with a general location. In the analysis described it was 44 of 106 permits, and the goal is to reduce the indicator quarter by quarter.
How many of your permits have a general location?
We will help you calculate the indicator on your data and propose a zone dictionary and control gates.
Let's talk