InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Who approves high-risk work: the plant or the external company

A permit for especially hazardous work is approved or rejected only by the user on the plant side. The contractor prepares the request, carries out the work and, for hot work, keeps the watch after it ends. This split is recorded in the system, so the external company knows before entering the shutdown what is its own responsibility and what it cannot do itself.

63%
of permits belonged to the four largest contracting firms
Source: analysis of 106 permits over 9 weeks at a continuously running plant
82%
of permits were issued between 6:00 a.m. and 10:00 a.m.
Source: analysis of 106 permits over 9 weeks

The division of roles in one sentence

The plant decides, the contractor acts. A permit for especially hazardous work is approved or rejected only by the user on the plant side, and the fire watch during hot work is carried out by an employee of the external company. Neither role moves to the other side, even when the shutdown deadline is tight.

For the external company this sets a clear boundary: the request can be prepared and submitted, but the work does not start without a decision from the plant. For the plant it means certainty that no permit is treated as valid based only on the contractor's declaration.

What the contractor can do on its own

The contractor has real tasks in the system. It prepares the request, indicates the work location, the team and the type of work, and after approval carries out the tasks recorded in the permit. For hot work it also carries out the watch after welding ends, because it is present at the work site.

An analysis of 106 permits collected over 9 weeks at an insulation materials plant running continuously shows that the four largest contracting firms held 63% of the permits. This means a few contractors have constant contact with the procedure, so their good preparation of requests reduces the load on the approvers.

Pointing to a specific place at the machine

The contractor should choose a specific point at the machine, for example a filter, a section, a feed point or a chamber. In the analysis, 44 of 106 permits pointed to a general location, meaning the building, Other or Whole line. A precise point shortens the plant's decision and improves the data about the work location.

The watch after hot work

Closing is blocked until at least 3 hours of monitoring have passed, and hot work passes the 1 h and 4 h checkpoints. The contractor must therefore plan the watch crew before it starts welding.

Days on which permits were issued in the analysis of 106 permits

Days on which permits were issued in the analysis of 106 permitsBar chart: 62 permits on Tuesday and Wednesday, 44 on other working days, 0 at the weekend020406080permitsTuesday and Wednesday: 62 permits62Tuesday and WednesdayOther working days: 44 permits44Other working daysWeekend: 0 permits0Weekend
Source: Analysis of 9 weeks of permits at a continuously running plant; other working days = 106 minus 62

What the contractor cannot do on its own

The contractor cannot approve its own permit, close hot work before the monitoring time has passed, or pass the decision to a colleague from the same company. These actions belong to the plant-side user or are blocked by a system rule.

This arrangement protects both sides. The plant is certain that the decision was taken on its side, and the contractor has proof that it followed the procedure when the sequence of events has to be reconstructed after the shutdown.

How to split the work during the peak

Permits do not arrive evenly. In the analysis, 82% of permits were issued between 6:00 a.m. and 10:00 a.m., and 62 of 106 on Tuesday and Wednesday. None were issued at the weekend. Approvers on the plant side therefore have a narrow window in which they must make many decisions.

The contractor can help by submitting requests a working day in advance, if the process allows it. The plant can set up an on-duty approver for the peak window. The cost of such a duty is calculated separately for the plant running continuously.

What about tasks that were not closed

The status of especially hazardous work is independent of the permit status. Unclosed tasks do not block the permit from moving between phases, and open tasks move on to the main works. The contractor therefore does not need to stop the whole shutdown because of one open item, but it must close that item within the main works.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Can an external company approve a permit when the plant has no approver available?

No. Only the plant-side user approves or rejects the permit. When there are not enough approvers in the peak window, the solution is an on-duty approver on the plant side, not the contractor taking over the decision.

Who keeps the watch after welding if the crew finished early?

The fire watch is carried out by the external company's employee. The monitoring time runs from the end of the hot work, and closing is blocked until at least 3 hours have passed.

Can open tasks block the permit from moving to the next phase?

No. Unclosed tasks do not block the move between phases, and open tasks pass to the main works, where they must be closed.

How does the plant know where the contractor is working?

From the location given in the request. The more precise the point at the machine, the easier it is to assign risks and assess the permit, which is why the share of general locations should be reduced quarter by quarter.

Set out the roles for the shutdown

We will show how to split the plant's decisions and the contractor's duties in a digital permit. Book a demo for safety and external companies.

Let's talk