Permit distribution: why the peak costs money
An analysis of 106 permits collected over 9 weeks at an insulation materials plant running continuously shows decisions bunched together in time. 82% of permits were issued between 6:00 and 10:00 a.m., and 62 of 106 on Tuesday and Wednesday. None were issued at the weekend.
Bunching means the approver staffing has to match the peak, not the average. If approvals were spread evenly across the week, one approver would be enough. If they stay as they are, the four-hour window may run short of hands, and contractors wait at the gate for a decision.
Structure of the duty cost
The cost of duty consists of the approver hours in the peak window, the hours of a second person on the days of greatest load, and the cost of contractors waiting. The first two components can be counted exactly, while the third requires an assumption about the external company's rate.
Basic staffing hours
The window from 6:00 to 10:00 is 4 hours a day. Over five working days this gives 20 hours of basic staffing in the week, if the plant staffs the window on every working day.
Double staffing hours
Sample calculation: a duty of approvers in the 6:00 to 10:00 window is 4 hours a day, and 2 peak days a week give 8 hours of double staffing. This is an assumption for your own costing, not the result of an implementation.
Permits by time of issue
Sample weekly calculation
With the assumptions in the table below, basic staffing is 20 hours a week, and double staffing on peak days adds 8 hours. Together that is 28 hours of approver staffing in the week, of which 8 hours concern Tuesday and Wednesday only.
The value in currency depends on the hourly rate of the approver in your plant. That is why we give hours, and leave the conversion into money to the finance department. A plant with a different distribution of permits should replace the 4 hours with its own window.
How to lower the cost without losing control
The simplest way is to level the peak by submitting requests earlier. If a contractor submits a request a day in advance, the decision does not have to be made between 6:00 and 10:00 a.m. The second way is to reduce general locations: a precise point at the machine shortens the decision time, because the approver does not need to ask where the work is.
In the analysis, 44 of 106 permits pointed to a general location. If the share of these permits falls, every decision in the peak will be shorter, and the same staffing will handle more permits. The indicator of general locations is described in a separate guide.
Approver staffing hours per week
Where the permits to approve are concentrated
In the same analysis, 43 permits covered hot work, 40 covered work at height, and 76 of 106 permits concerned two halls. In the warehouse hall 24 of 39 permits concerned work at height, and in the production hall 24 of 37 were hot work. The duty can therefore be set up for specific halls and types of work, not for the whole plant.
The four largest contracting firms held 63% of the permits. It is worth agreeing a fixed window for submitting requests with them, because that is the cheapest way to level the peak.
Sample calculation: approver staffing per week
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Peak window | 6:00 to 10:00 4 hours a day |
| Working days with duty | 5 days a week |
| Peak days with double staffing | 2 days a week |
Result: 5 times 4 hours is 20 hours of basic staffing, 2 times 4 hours is 8 hours of double staffing, 28 hours a week in total.
Note: Sample calculation: the assumptions serve your own costing and are not the result of an implementation. The hourly rate is set by the plant.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Is duty needed at the weekend?
The analysis shows no permits issued at the weekend, so weekend duty did not follow from the data. A plant with a different shutdown schedule should check its own distribution.
How do I know that the peak is Tuesday and Wednesday?
From the analysis of 106 permits over 9 weeks: 62 fell on those two days. The plant will read its own distribution from the list of permits over several weeks.
Can a second approver be replaced by a system rule?
Only the user on the plant side approves or rejects a permit, so the second approver can be replaced only by another plant user, not by a rule for the contractor.
How do I convert hours into cost?
Multiply the 28 hours a week by the approver's hourly rate and by the number of weeks of the shutdown or the year. The rate is internal data of the plant.
Calculate the staffing for your peak
From a list of permits over several weeks we will show when the peak falls in your plant and how many staffing hours you need. Book a conversation.
Let's talk