InnerWeb
Skip to main content

BLE location in a steel-structure hall: questions and answers

Steel, overhead cranes and metal sheets reflect radio signals, so management's concern about interference is justified. The honest answer is neither “there is no problem” nor “the system will not work”. Location quality depends on the positioning method, the density of transmitters and a signal survey carried out in the specific hall. Below are the questions that heavy-industry plants ask most often, with answers to pass on to decision makers.

225 m2
design assumption: 1 point per hall
Source: product card
100 to 200 m2
transmitter density inside buildings
Source: product card

Do reflections from steel affect the BLE signal at all?

Yes, they do, and it is worth saying so to management at the start of the discussion. A 2.4 GHz radio signal bounces off sheet metal, beams, cranes and containers, and the strength of the signal received at one spot in a hall can change even after a small move by the worker. A single signal strength reading from one transmitter is therefore a weak indicator of distance.

For that reason, a system that relies on the single strongest transmitter would be unreliable in a steel hall. The InnerWeb solution does not use that method. The worker's position is built from the signals of several transmitters, which are averaged on the map, instead of picking the strongest one. Errors caused by individual reflections are spread out this way, rather than passed unfiltered into the result.

How does the system determine position when the signal is disturbed?

The phone or watch receives signals from several transmitters at once, together with the strength of each, and sends them every few seconds over the mobile network or Wi-Fi. The server matches these readings against the map of transmitter positions and calculates the position as the result of averaging, not as a reading from a single point.

The practical consequence for the design follows: the more transmitters audible in a given place, the more stable the result. A hall where a worker hears only one transmitter is poorly covered, even if it theoretically “has range”. The control question during the site survey is therefore not “does the signal arrive?”, but “how many transmitters can be heard at this place at the same time?”

What about places without GPS?

Location works without GPS. This matters in halls, under overpasses and in roofed structures, where the satellite signal does not reach or is distorted. The system does not need a view of the sky, but it does need powered transmitters placed according to the design.

Floor area per transmitter

Floor area per transmitterHorizontal bar chart: 100, 200 and 225 square metres per transmitter050100150200250m2Interiors, lower rangeInteriors, lower range: 100 m2100Interiors, upper rangeInteriors, upper range: 200 m2200Hall, design assumptionHall, design assumption: 225 m2225
Source: Placement rules and design assumption from InnerWeb materials; they require validation on site

How many transmitters are needed so that metal does not spoil the results?

The general rules in InnerWeb materials are about 100 m between transmitters along plant roads and 1 transmitter per 100 to 200 m2 inside buildings. In halls, the density follows from the BLE range in the presence of metal structures, and two points on opposite edges of a hall do not replace a grid.

For budget planning, the design assumption is 1 point per 225 m2, which means a grid of about 15 m, with a minimum of four points per hall. These rules must be validated on site. In a hall with dense steel structures, the grid is tightened wherever measurement shows drops in range.

  • plant roads: transmitters about every 100 m,
  • building interiors: 1 transmitter per 100 to 200 m2,
  • design assumption for a hall: 1 point per 225 m2, minimum 4 points,
  • platforms: 1 point per 15 m of walkway, counted separately from the hall.

How do we know it will work in this specific hall?

BLE range in steel and reinforced concrete structures is verified by measurement on site, before the final placement of transmitters. This is the only honest answer to the question about reflections, because every hall has different geometry, different loads and a different crane arrangement. The measurement result goes into the placement design and is the basis for tightening the grid in difficult places.

After installation, a second measurement is carried out, this time of coverage, and attached to the acceptance protocol. This gives management evidence rather than a declaration: the plant has a result read in its own hall, which can be repeated after a rebuild.

How do you present the topic to management that fears interference?

It is best to separate three questions. First: does metal affect the signal? The answer is yes, which is why the method relies on many transmitters. Second: how many points are needed? The answer is a range taken from design rules and confirmed by measurement. Third: what error is acceptable for the process, for example for a dispatcher directing rescue teams? That question is answered by comparing the requirements with the measurement result, not by a general statement about accuracy.

It is also worth stressing that InnerWeb is an independent system that complements the plant's existing systems. It does not replace infrastructure. Beacons can be mounted on walls, poles and structures with existing power supply, without rebuilding the hall.

What should you look for in an offer when a vendor promises “accuracy to the metre”?

Accuracy without stated conditions means nothing. A reliable offer states the transmitter density, the measurement environment and how the result is confirmed after installation. In one simulation for a grid of transmitters every 100 m, the average position deviation was 15 m and the maximum was 39 m. The figures in practice depend on density and surroundings, not on the manufacturer alone.

The purchasing team should require three elements: a description of the positioning method, a measurement plan before installation, and a post-installation measurement plan with an acceptance criterion. If any one of them is missing, the risk of metal reflections has been passed on to the plant.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is one transmitter at each end of the hall enough?

No. Two points on opposite edges of a hall do not replace a grid. Position requires signals from several transmitters in every area where people work.

Does the system need GPS inside the hall?

No. Location works without GPS, which matters in halls and under overpasses where the satellite signal does not reach.

When is the range checked?

Before the final placement of transmitters, in the hall itself, and again after installation. The result is attached to the acceptance protocol.

Are the density rules a guarantee of the result?

No. They are a design assumption that requires validation on site. The final grid is set by measurement in the specific hall.

Let's plan a range measurement in your hall

Book a talk with InnerWeb. We will go through the positioning method, the measurement plan before installation and the acceptance criteria for a hall with steel structures.

Let's talk