InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Telephone and SMS alarm costs at a plant: a calculation

The plant director asks one thing: how much does it cost for people to learn about an alarm in time. The answer has two parts: the fixed cost of the alarm panel and the variable cost of messages. Below is a sample calculation based on assumptions: an alarm panel at about 300 PLN a month and SMS at about 0.25 PLN each.

300 PLN
alarm panel per month
Source: sample calculation
0.25 PLN
one SMS
Source: sample calculation
55 min
aggregation window of the training alarm
Source: card
~4,000 PLN
a year with 400 people and 4 tests
Source: sample calculation

Structure of notification costs

The cost of notification has a fixed and a variable element. The fixed element is the alarm panel, which the calculation puts at about 300 PLN a month. The variable element is messages, assuming about 0.25 PLN per SMS.

The proportions are often surprising. With a few alarms a year the panel makes up almost the whole cost, and SMS messages are a rounding error. Only systematic notifications, for example about missing contractor training, make the number of messages matter.

Plant-wide alarm to everyone: what it costs

Assume a plant with 400 people present on site. One alarm sent by SMS to everyone costs 400 times 0.25 PLN, which is 100 PLN. Four tests a year come to 400 PLN, and the panel for a year is 12 times 300 PLN, which is 3,600 PLN. Altogether about 4,000 PLN a year.

This result should be read from two sides. On one side it is a small sum compared with the cost of one hour of the plant being stopped. On the other, an SMS is not confirmation of receipt, so for a critical alarm it is supplemented by a phone call and the list of people present.

Calculation assumptions

400 people on site, 4 alarm tests a year, 1 SMS per person per test, panel at 300 PLN a month, SMS at 0.25 PLN.

What is not in the calculation

It does not include the cost of the staff who run the test or the cost of messages that fail to deliver. Add them if the plant records them.

Missing-training notifications: SMS per person versus one per company

Missing-training notifications: SMS per person versus one per companyBefore and after chart: 137.50 PLN with an SMS per person, 33 PLN with one notification per company.050100150PLN a monthSMS per person: Monthly cost: 137.5 PLN a month137.5SMS per personOne per company: Monthly cost: 33 PLN a month33One per company
Source: Sample calculation: 25 people a day, 6 companies, 22 days, 0.25 PLN per SMS

Training alarm and the 55-minute window

The training alarm aggregates reports within a 55-minute window, instead of sending a separate notification for each person. When several employees of one company enter without valid training, the company coordinator gets one message with a list, not ten separate ones.

Example: 25 people a day without valid training from 6 companies, 22 working days a month. Without aggregation that is 25 times 22 times 0.25 PLN, which is 137.50 PLN. With one notification per company: 6 times 22 times 0.25 PLN, which is 33 PLN. The difference of 104.50 PLN a month is small, but the number of calls to the coordinator falls from 25 to 6 a day.

Where the real saving lies

The real saving is not in the grosze per SMS. It lies in the time of the dispatcher and the company coordinator: every notification that has to be read, recorded and handled costs minutes. Aggregation and routing messages to the right person shorten that time far more than negotiating the SMS rate.

That is why costs are best assessed in three columns: the fixed cost of the panel, the cost of messages and the time of people. The first two fit on one line of the budget. The third often needs agreement with the health and safety manager or the works council, yet it is the one that decides whether the investment pays off.

How to plan the budget

Start with the number of people on site at peak, for example during a maintenance shutdown. Multiply by the planned number of tests and the SMS price. Add twelve months of the panel. Add a 20 percent reserve for repeat messages.

An individual quote depends on the number of channels and the requirements of the telephony operator. The figures in this calculation are sample figures and do not determine the costs of a specific plant.

Example calculation

Sample calculation: yearly cost of SMS alarm

Assumptions
ParameterValue
People on site400 people
Alarm tests4 a year
SMS price0.25 PLN
Alarm panel300 PLN a month

Result: SMS 400 PLN plus panel 3,600 PLN, altogether about 4,000 PLN a year.

Note: Sample calculation based on the assumptions above; it is not a quote.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is the 300 PLN a month panel a fixed price?

It is an assumption in the sample calculation. The actual amount depends on the operator and the number of channels.

Is SMS enough for a critical alarm?

SMS does not confirm receipt, so for a critical alarm it is supplemented by a phone call and the list of people present.

Why is the window 55 minutes?

That is the aggregation window in the training alarm function. Reports from that period are combined into one notification.

Does the calculation include the cost of staff time?

No. Add it at your own hourly rate if you want to compare the full cost.

We will calculate the alarm for your plant

Give us the number of people on site and the planned tests, and we will prepare a calculation with your assumptions.

Let's talk