What the cost of onboarding a guard is made of
The cost of onboarding a new guard is the sum of hours of several people, not only the hours of the guard. The bill includes: the guard's time for training and the test at the gate, the mentor's time, that is an experienced colleague or the shift leader, and the time of the plant's account administrator.
At a traditional gate with paper lists, the learning includes procedures, recognising companies and checking permissions. In the security panel this part is shorter, because a scan of a QR badge or RFID card gives a verdict based on four elements: trainings, qualifications, a permit or visit for today, and an active account or invitation. The guard does not need to know the requirements of every company, because the panel shows what is missing.
Assumptions of the sample calculation
The example concerns an agency serving a gate in three shifts, with one guard trained to use the panel on each shift. The other values are assumptions to be replaced with the agency's or the plant's own data.
- 3 shifts per day, 1 guard per shift.
- 6 new guards per year as staff rotates (sample assumption).
- Panel training: 2 guard hours, gate test: 0.5 guard hours, mentor: 1 hour (sample assumptions).
- Onboarding without the panel, on paper lists: 6 guard hours and 2 mentor hours (comparison assumption).
- Guard rate: 60 PLN per hour, mentor rate: 90 PLN per hour (sample assumptions).
Cost of onboarding one guard
- Paper lists
- Security panel
Results: cost per guard and annual cost
In the panel variant the cost of onboarding one guard is 2.5 hours at 60 PLN and 1 mentor hour at 90 PLN, that is 150 PLN plus 90 PLN, 240 PLN in total. In the paper variant it is 6 hours at 60 PLN and 2 mentor hours at 90 PLN, that is 360 PLN plus 180 PLN, 540 PLN in total.
With six new guards a year this gives 1,440 PLN in the panel variant and 3,240 PLN in the paper variant. The difference is 1,800 PLN a year at one gate. The amount is small in the scale of a security budget, but it is not the main argument.
Costs the calculation does not see
The largest cost of rotation is the first weeks of work, when a new guard makes mistakes that show up only later: they admit a person without training or stop someone with a valid permit. In the panel the first kind of error is harder to make, because the verdict comes from the scan, not from the guard's judgement. A denial writes an entry to the log, and at a denial the panel shows a red banner and plays a voice recording.
The second hidden cost is the shift leader's time spent explaining disputes. The log of entries, exits and denials shortens such conversations, because instead of opinions there are recorded events.
- Mentor time during the first shifts of a new guard.
- Plant administrator time to create and deactivate accounts.
- Denials caused by a handling error, not by a missing requirement.
- Disputes about responsibility after an incident at the gate.
Who pays for training: the plant or the agency
The most common practice in contracts is to charge the agency with the cost of onboarding its own staff, and the plant with the cost of preparing the workstation and the account. It is worth writing this clearly into the agreement with the agency: who runs the panel training, who creates the accounts and within what time from reporting a new guard.
A security service is usually compared by the hourly rate of staffing. It is worth adding a second column: the cost of onboarding a new person and the time after which the guard works independently. An agency with low rotation and a short onboarding can be cheaper than an agency with a lower rate.
InnerWeb does not sell readers or access control cards, so the calculation has no hardware items on our side. The scanner and the workstation stay with the plant or the agency.
Onboarding rotating guards: panel against paper lists
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| New guards per year | 6 people |
| Panel training and test | 2.5 guard hours |
| Mentor with the panel | 1 hours |
| Paper onboarding | 6 + 2 guard and mentor hours |
| Guard and mentor rate | 60 and 90 PLN per hour |
Result: 240 PLN per guard with the panel against 540 PLN without it; per year 1,440 PLN against 3,240 PLN, a difference of 1,800 PLN.
Note: Sample calculation on the assumptions above; the agency's own rates and onboarding time will change the result. It is not an offer or a guarantee of savings.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does every guard need a separate account?
We recommend it, because the log of entries, exits and denials then has an author. A shared account makes it harder to explain events after a shift.
How long does panel training take in the sample calculation?
We assumed 2 hours of training and half an hour of test at the gate. This is an assumption to be replaced with the agency's own time.
Does a guard need to learn the requirements of every external company?
No. The verdict at the gate comes from trainings, qualifications, a permit or visit, and an account or invitation, and for a denial the panel shows what is missing.
Does InnerWeb supply gate equipment?
No. Scanners and workstations stay with the plant or the agency. InnerWeb supplies the security panel software.
Let us calculate it at your rates
We will put your agency's real rotation and rates into the calculation and show how long onboarding a guard takes in the security panel.
Let's talk