What takes up guard time during manual checks
With manual checks the guard must verify three things independently: whether the person has valid trainings, whether they have qualifications for hazardous work, and whether they have a permit or an appointment for that day. Each check is a different list, a different document, or a call to the OHS department.
The cost does not come only from minutes per person. It comes from repetition: the guard performs the same checks at every entry, even when everything is in order. Time grows linearly with the number of entries, and the queue at the gate lengthens during shift changes and delivery hours.
How the gate verdict replaces manual checks
The gate verdict consists of four elements: valid trainings, qualifications for hazardous work, an active work permit and an active account. A scan of the QR badge or RFID card checks all of them and records the entry in the log. The system does not open the gate or the barrier itself: the verdict goes to the guard, and the opening is controlled by the plant's existing access control system.
On the permit side the work is done in advance. When a permit is created, the system automatically checks whether the assigned workers have the required valid qualifications and warns about expiring ones. The guard therefore does not repeat this check at the gate, because the result is included in the verdict.
When a person does not meet a condition, the system gives the first reason in a fixed order: account inactive, no health declaration, no trainings, no qualifications, permit expired, no permit or appointment. Instead of searching for the cause in documents, the guard reads it from the screen.
Daily guard time at 80 entries
Structure of the costs of manual checks and the verdict
Guard time is one of three items worth counting before the decision on the gate verdict:
- guard minutes spent checking trainings, qualifications and permits at every entry,
- time people spend waiting in the queue at the gate,
- time of the OHS department spent answering security questions about the validity of documents,
- cost of implementing and licensing the system, which depends on scope and is priced individually.
Illustrative calculation: 80 external entries a day
We assume a plant where 80 people from external companies, including suppliers and contractors, enter through the gate each day, over 250 working days a year. This is an illustrative assumption.
With manual checks: 1.5 minutes to check trainings, 1 minute for qualifications and 1 minute for the permit, a total of 3.5 minutes per person. This gives 280 minutes a day, or about 4.7 hours.
With the gate verdict we assume 0.3 minute per person: the scan and reading of the result. This gives 24 minutes a day. The difference is 256 minutes a day, or about 4.3 hours.
Over a year the saving is about 1,067 hours of guard work (256 minutes times 250 days, divided by 60). At an assumed rate of PLN 55 per hour this is about PLN 58,700 a year, excluding the licence and implementation cost.
What changes the result and what to watch for
The largest influence has the number of entries and the time of manual checks. At 30 entries a day the saving falls proportionally, to about 400 hours a year under the same assumptions. When a plant has several gates, the result adds up across all of them.
The saving does not mean a smaller guard staff. In many plants the guard stays, but instead of checking papers they deal with people whose verdict is a denial, check vehicles and observe the site. They gain quality of control, not only minutes.
A note on the limits of the system: the verdict depends on the data entered into the system. If trainings have not been entered, the verdict will be a denial, so the rollout requires completing the data before the requirement is switched on at the gate.
Guard minutes with manual checks and the gate verdict
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| External entries a day | 80 people |
| Manual: trainings | 1.5 min/person |
| Manual: qualifications | 1 min/person |
| Manual: permit or appointment | 1 min/person |
| Gate verdict: scan and reading | 0.3 min/person |
| Working days a year | 250 days |
| Cost of an hour of guard work | 55 PLN/h |
Result: 280 min a day manually against 24 min with the gate verdict: a difference of 256 min a day, about 1,067 h and about PLN 58,700 a year, excluding the licence cost.
Note: Illustrative calculation based on the author's own assumptions; the actual result depends on the number of entries, gate organisation and rates. The implementation and licence cost is priced individually.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does the gate verdict allow a reduction of guard staff?
That is the plant's decision. The calculation shows the recovered time, which security can spend on other tasks, for example handling denials and checking vehicles.
What if the training data is incomplete?
The verdict will be a denial because of missing trainings. Therefore the data must be completed and checked on a trial group of people before the requirement is switched on at the gate.
Does the system integrate with the existing access control system?
InnerWeb does not manufacture readers and does not replace existing ones. It complements the client's access control and receives card scan events, while the opening of the gate is controlled by the client's system.
Let's count the time at your gate
Give us the number of entries and control times at your gate, and InnerWeb will prepare a calculation with your assumptions.
Let's talk