InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Vehicle entry log: what paper costs versus a QR scan

A paper vehicle entry log costs security time that does not appear on any invoice. At 40 vehicles a day and 3 minutes per entry, it means 2 hours of duty officer work every working day. Below is an illustrative calculation with explicit assumptions, which the plant can replace with its own figures.

2 h
per day of security time spent on manual entries (illustrative calculation)
Source: illustrative calculation
500 h
per year spent copying vehicles into the paper register
Source: illustrative calculation

What makes up the cost of a paper log

The cost of a paper log has four components: the duty officer's time to write an entry, the time to find an entry when a vehicle leaves, the risk of error in handwritten records, and the lack of a list of people on site in case of an incident. The first can be calculated directly from time, the others we describe qualitatively.

The most important point is that paper does not answer the question of who is on site right now. The answer requires paging through sheets and comparing entry and exit times, and with dozens of vehicles a day nobody does this in real time.

Assumptions of the illustrative calculation

We assumed figures for a medium-sized plant. These are assumptions, not a measurement from a deployment, so before deciding the plant should substitute its own numbers from its register.

  • 40 vehicles of guests and suppliers per day.
  • 3 minutes of manual entry in the paper log per vehicle.
  • 250 working days per year.

Hours of entries per day against number of vehicles (3 min per entry)

Hours of entries per day against number of vehicles (3 min per entry)Bar chart of daily entry hours: 0.5 for 10 vehicles, 1 for 20, 2 for 40, 3 for 60.0123hours per day10 vehicles: 0.5 hours per day0.510 vehicles20 vehicles: 1 hours per day120 vehicles40 vehicles: 2 hours per day240 vehicles60 vehicles: 3 hours per day360 vehicles
Source: Illustrative calculation: 3 minutes of manual entry per vehicle

Result: security time spent on entries

The daily time for entries is 40 vehicles times 3 minutes, which is 120 minutes, or 2 hours. Over a year this is 2 hours times 250 days, which is 500 hours of security work spent only on copying vehicles into the register.

To turn this into a cost, the plant multiplies the 500 hours by its own hourly rate for the duty officer, including employer costs. This article does not give an amount in zloty, because rates differ between plants and security companies, and inserting an arbitrary number would be guesswork.

What a QR scan does instead of an entry

Scanning the QR code on a badge or the card number is the control itself: there is no separate admit button, and the scan result decides whether the person enters, exits or is refused. Every scan is saved as a gate entry, including a blocked attempt, so nobody copies data by hand.

The guest's data comes from the planned visit. A planned visit is a one-day equivalent of an authorization and removes only the authorization requirement in the gate verdict, so the duty officer does not have to check separately whether the guest was invited.

Does the scan not take the same time?

It takes a fraction of the time. We do not give the scan time as a number, because we have no measurement from a deployment that could be cited. The plant should measure it at its own gate in the first week: a stopwatch and twenty passages are enough.

What the calculation does not cover

The calculation counts only the time of writing entries. It does not include the time spent looking up an entry when a vehicle leaves, corrections after handwriting errors, or the time needed in an incident when a list of people on site is required. A list of people currently on site is a fact from the system register, not a guess.

A person who has not recorded an exit is automatically closed after staying longer than 12 hours, and the check runs every 3 hours. On paper there is no such mechanism: an entry without an exit time stays open until someone completes it.

InnerWeb does not describe reading vehicle registration plates or controlling a barrier, and it does not produce readers, so the gate hardware costs on the plant side stay unchanged. The calculation covers only the replacement of the manual register with a scan record.

How to check it at your plant in a week

Take the last two weeks of the paper register and calculate the average number of entries per day. Time with a stopwatch how long one vehicle entry takes for three duty officers. Put both numbers into the formula: vehicles per day times minutes, divided by 60, times working days.

Compare the result with other gate costs: the waiting time of drivers in the queue, the number of errors in plate records, and the time spent looking up entries on exit. Only the whole picture shows whether the change pays off at your plant.

Example calculation

Security time spent on manual vehicle entries

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Guest and supplier vehicles40 pcs/day
Time to enter into the paper register3 min/vehicle
Working days250 days/year

Result: 120 minutes a day, that is 2 hours, and 500 hours a year of security time spent on manual entries.

Note: Illustrative calculation based on assumptions for a medium-sized plant, not a measurement from a deployment. The plant calculates the cost in zloty with its own hourly rate for the duty officer.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Are 3 minutes per entry a realistic figure?

It is an assumption of the illustrative calculation, not a measurement from a deployment. Measure the time at your own gate and put the result into the formula.

Does a QR scan replace the barrier?

No. InnerWeb does not make barriers or readers and does not describe controlling a barrier. The scan replaces the manual entry into the register.

What about a person who did not record an exit?

The system closes them automatically after staying longer than 12 hours, and the check runs every 3 hours.

Calculate it for your gate

We will put the figures from your register into the calculation and show the QR scan on a live security panel. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.

Let's talk