Two models of night-time alarm response
The first model is a permanent duty: a security officer stays at a workstation all night and monitors alarms in the system. The second model is notifications: the system informs the responsible people by itself and can trigger a phone call to the person on duty, while the gate security is one of the recipients, not the only one.
The choice is not only about cost. It concerns who has the authority to close an alarm and whether that person can be reached at night. The second question often decides faster than the calculation.
How the alarms that must be handled work
An SOS alarm from a watch creates its own alarm permit, starts a rescue chain in the messenger and by calls through the PBX, and lasts until a person closes it. The wearer's movement does not clear the SOS alarm, and a second press while the alarm permit is open does not create a duplicate or a second notification.
A no-movement alarm notifies the responsible people, creates an alarm permit from the ALARM template, marks the place on the map and can trigger a webhook, for example a phone call to the person on duty. When the employee moves again, the permit closes by itself. This is an important difference: no-movement is a self-closing alarm, while SOS requires a human decision.
Who closes an SOS alarm?
The supervisor assigned to the SOS template can close the alarm permit. The template must have a named supervisor or owner, otherwise nobody other than the injured person can close the alarm. In the night duty calculation this item is not obvious: a person must be named who is reachable at night and authorised.
Cost of night duty per alarm
Assumptions of the sample calculation
The calculation compares the cost of a permanent night duty with the cost per alarm. We do not give a price for software or phones, because the quote is individual. We count only the cost of security duty, to show how much the plant pays for readiness to respond.
- Night duty: 1 security officer, 12 hours per night, 30 nights per month.
- Hourly duty rate: 45 PLN (sample assumption).
- Number of SOS and no-movement alarms per month: 4 (sample assumption).
- Duty at the gate exists for other reasons too, so in the second variant we count only the cost that is purely for alarms.
Result: what readiness to respond costs
A permanent night duty is 12 hours times 30 nights times 45 PLN, that is 16,200 PLN per month. With four alarms a month this gives 4,050 PLN per alarm. If there were 12 alarms, the cost would fall to 1,350 PLN per alarm, but the calculation still describes readiness, not the quality of the response.
The conclusion is cautious. If security already staffs the gate, the extra cost of listening for alarms may be close to zero and is worth using. If a duty would exist only to listen for alarms, phone notifications to the responsible people are usually more rational, provided the chain of people is complete and tested.
Conditions without which the alarm will not get through
The cheapest model is the most expensive if the alarm reaches a person who does not answer it. Before choosing a model the plant should check three things: whether the SOS template has a named supervisor or owner, whether the person on duty has a working phone and knows they may take a call from the switchboard, and whether security knows that a no-movement alarm closes by itself once movement returns.
- SOS template with an assigned supervisor or owner.
- ALARM template for no-movement and the list of people to notify.
- Test of the rescue chain once a quarter, with the result recorded.
- Confirmation of who replaces the supervisor at night in case of absence.
Permanent night security duty for alarms
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Duty | 1 person, 12 hours per night |
| Nights per month | 30 nights |
| Hourly rate | 45 PLN |
| SOS and no-movement alarms | 4 per month |
Result: 16,200 PLN per month for the duty, that is 4,050 PLN per alarm at 4 alarms.
Note: Sample calculation on the assumptions above; it contains no price for software or phones, as the quote is individual. The plant's rates and alarm count will change the result.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does a no-movement alarm need to be closed by a person?
No. Once the employee moves again, the alarm permit closes by itself. An SOS alarm, however, lasts until a person closes it.
Who can close an SOS alarm?
The supervisor assigned to the SOS template. The template must have a named supervisor or owner, otherwise nobody except the injured person can close the alarm.
Does a phone notification replace security at the gate?
No. An alarm can trigger a webhook, for example a phone call to the person on duty, but the decision on the duty model is made by the plant based on its own risk assessment.
Will another press of SOS trigger another alarm?
No. A second press while the alarm permit is open does not create a duplicate or a second notification.
Let us test the alarm chain at your plant
We will go through the SOS and ALARM templates, the people to notify and the phone for the person on duty, and then calculate the night duty at your rates.
Let's talk