InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Quarterly review checklist for cooperation with the security agency

Once a quarter the plant's safety manager and a representative of the security agency should sit down over the same data. The security panel and the log provide it without extra reporting: denials, duplicates, automatic check-outs, open alarms and the list of accounts with their permissions. Below is a checklist with comments on what each item shows and what to do about it.

3 months
period of data for the review
Source: recommendation from this checklist

Why a quarterly review

Cooperation with a security agency is usually judged by events: an incident, a complaint or a change of staffing. A quarterly review reverses the order. The plant and the agency look at the data before something happens and agree on corrections that cost less than a reaction after the fact.

The review is not meant to be a settling of accounts. Its purpose is to establish what in the organisation of the gate and the configuration of the panel needs changing, and to confirm that the division of responsibility written into the agreement still describes reality.

Data to prepare before the meeting

The safety manager prepares a summary from the log for the last three months. A denial writes an entry, so denials can be counted and grouped. Duplicates are ignored with a message, so their number shows how often guards scan twice. Automatic check-outs show how many people left without a scan.

  • Denials by reason and by external company.
  • Denials repeated by the same people.
  • Duplicate scans by workstation and shift.
  • Automatic check-outs after exceeding 12 hours.
  • SOS and no-movement alarms, with the time they were closed.
  • List of accounts with the security role and the date of last use.

Sample data layout for the quarterly review

Sample data layout for the quarterly reviewBar chart: sample numbers of denials, duplicates, automatic check-outs and alarms in a quarter.050100150eventsDenials: 54 events54 eventsDenialsDuplicates: 130 events130 eventsDuplicatesAutomatic check-outs: 7 events7 eventsAutomatic check-outsAlarms: 3 events3 eventsAlarms
Source: Illustrative data for the layout of the summary, not a measurement at a plant

How to read denials, duplicates and check-outs

A denial is a signal about shortfalls on the side of external companies, not an assessment of the guard. If most denials concern one reason, for example a missing training, the talk should be about the training, not about the gate staffing. The notification of a denial includes information about the person, the place and the missing element, and about what to do, so the data for analysis already exist.

A high number of duplicates points to a habit of scanning twice or to trouble with the scanner. A duplicate is ignored without effect on the log, but its frequency tells whether the workstation is set up well.

Automatic check-outs after 12 hours show forgotten exits. A few per quarter is a normal phenomenon, a dozen a week calls for a talk about the organisation of the exit.

Open alarms and account permissions

The alarm review concerns two things. First: whether every SOS alarm was closed by the supervisor assigned to the SOS template. An SOS alarm lasts until a person closes it, so an alarm open for weeks is a signal that the template has no supervisor or the person does not know the procedure. Second: whether no-movement alarms were treated seriously, even though they close by themselves once movement returns.

The account review concerns the deactivation of accounts of guards who have left and the consistency of roles. Security sees external companies and their employees, and who has a permit today, but not the full view of permits, and cannot suspend, resume or close them. If a security account has wider rights than its role implies, this has to be explained.

Findings and owners of corrections

The review ends with a short list of findings: what we change, who owns the correction and by when. It is also worth recording what was checked and found in order, because at the next review that list is the reference point.

We recommend that conclusions from the review return to the agreement with the agency only when they change the division of responsibility. Minor organisational corrections are enough to record in the review minutes.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Who should take part in the quarterly review?

The safety or security manager on the plant side and a representative of the agency who knows the staffing. If needed, the system administrator for accounts.

Is the number of denials a measure of guard quality?

No. A denial results from a missing training, qualification, permit or account on the side of the person, not from a guard error. The measure is the distribution of denials and how often they repeat.

How do we know an SOS alarm was closed?

An SOS alarm lasts until a person closes it, and the supervisor assigned to the SOS template can close it. An open alarm permit on the list means an alarm that is not closed.

Does the review require changing the agreement with the agency?

Only when the division of responsibility changes. Minor organisational corrections are enough to record in the review minutes.

Let us prepare the first review summary

We will show how to pull denials, duplicates, check-outs and alarms from the log into a form you can put on the table with the agency straight away.

Let's talk