InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Cost of line downtime while waiting for a service permit

A formatting line in a board manufacturing plant is standing still, and the service team is waiting for a permit to be signed. Every such hour has a price that is rarely calculated. Below is an example calculation with explicit assumptions: we show the method, and the plant substitutes its own figures.

15 h
of waiting for permits per month before the change
Source: example calculation
5 h
of waiting after the organisational change
Source: example calculation
40,000 zł
monthly difference in the example
Source: example calculation

Why waiting for a permit is a real cost

In a board manufacturing plant the formatting line is often the bottleneck: edge banding machines, drilling and packaging depend on it. When the line stops because of a fault, the service team wants to start immediately. If the work permit waits for the signature of a person who is in another part of the plant, time passes without any work being done.

This cost is invisible, because in accounting it is assigned to the fault rather than to the flow of documents. It is enough, however, to separate the two components of downtime: the time spent waiting for clearance to work and the time of the repair itself. The first can be shortened organisationally.

How waiting time is shortened in the permit system

The permit flow for work ordered from an external company runs on a single permit: the person ordering the work on the plant side and the contractor see the same data. There is no passing of the document by email and no version to agree on.

Only a user on the plant side can approve work classified as particularly hazardous, and this rule is enforced in the code. Speed therefore depends on whether the plant has a designated person available on each shift and whether the permit is prepared from a template rather than from scratch.

  • Permits from templates: risks and protective measures assigned to the place and type of work.
  • Qualifications checked when people are assigned, not when the permit is issued.
  • An approving person designated for each shift.
  • A shared view for the orderer and the contractor on one permit.

Hours of waiting for permits per month

Hours of waiting for permits per monthBefore and after chart: 15 hours of waiting for permits per month before the change, 5 hours after the change.051015hBefore the change: Waiting: 15 h15 hBefore the changeAfter the change: Waiting: 5 h5 hAfter the change
Source: Example calculation based on the assumptions in the Assumptions section

Assumptions of the example calculation

The values below are examples and serve to show the method. The plant should replace them with its own data: the value of production per hour, the number of permits for the service team per month and the average waiting time before the organisational change.

It is assumed that the formatting line in the board plant generates, for example, 4,000 zloty of production value per hour, that 20 permits for the service team on this line are issued per month, and that waiting for the signature on the paper process averages 45 minutes, falling to 15 minutes after the organisational change.

Result: what waiting costs and what can be recovered

Before the change: 20 permits times 0.75 hours gives 15 hours of waiting per month. At 4,000 zloty per hour this is 60,000 zloty of production value not achieved during the waiting time. After the change: 20 times 0.25 hours gives 5 hours, which is 20,000 zloty.

The difference is 10 hours and 40,000 zloty per month in this example. The calculation does not include the cost of the repair itself, nor the fact that part of the production can be made up on the next shift. It is an order of magnitude for discussion, not a promise of savings.

What a faster permit will not change

A faster permit does not shorten the required controls. In work involving fire the system enforces a monitoring period after the work is completed, in two stages, 1 h and 4 h, and closing the work is blocked until at least 3 hours of monitoring have elapsed. This time must not be counted as savings, because it is an element of safety.

What improves is therefore the time before the work, not after it. A plant that wants to measure this effect should separately record, for at least one month, the time from reporting the fault to the signature of the permit.

Example calculation

Waiting of a formatting line for service permits

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Production value of the line4000 zł/h
Permits for the service team on the line20 pcs/month
Waiting time on the paper process45 min
Waiting time after the organisational change15 min

Result: 60,000 zł per month before the change, 20,000 zł after the change; difference 40,000 zł and 10 hours.

Note: Example calculation. All values are assumptions; the plant substitutes its own data on production and the number of permits.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does the permit system shorten the time needed for the repair itself?

No. It shortens the time needed to clear the work to start, that is the waiting before it begins. The repair time depends on the service team and the scope of the fault.

Can the monitoring period after work with fire be shortened?

No. The system enforces monitoring in two stages, 1 h and 4 h, and closing the work is blocked until at least 3 hours of monitoring have elapsed.

Where can the plant get its own figures for the calculation?

From the permit register and production reports: the number of permits for the service team per month, the time of reporting and signing, and the production value per hour of the line.

Let us calculate permit waiting at your plant

We will put your data into the calculation and show on a demo what a template permit for a service company looks like.

Let's talk