Where the cost of a manual attendance list comes from
A manual list is more than copying names from a sheet of paper. Security collects the gate entries, the shift manager compares them with the roster, and at the shift change someone reconciles who has left and who has stayed. Each of these tasks takes a few minutes, but it repeats three times a day throughout the month.
At a railway workshop, service companies come and go at hours different from the core crew. The manual list most often falls out of step precisely because of their traffic, so the reconciliation takes longer than planned.
How a list built from scans changes this work
At a gate with scanning, every scan is written to the log, and the system sets the direction of the record: a green verdict and a person from outside gives an entry, a green verdict and a person inside gives an exit. The list of people on site is therefore built on its own, without copying.
The evacuation list shows who is physically on site, refreshes every 13 seconds and divides people into six groups, including external companies with tabs per company. A printout is one page per group, so the incident commander can hand the sheets to the coordinators at the assembly point.
The person does not disappear from the work: the control of exceptions remains, that is people who did not record an exit or who are not on the list. This is a few minutes per shift, not dozens of minutes.
Hours a month spent on the attendance list
Sample calculation: assumptions and result
We assume a workshop with 90 people per shift, three shifts a day and 30 working days a month, that is 90 shifts a month. Manual keeping of the list: 25 minutes of security and 10 minutes of the shift manager per shift, 35 minutes in total. List from scans: 5 minutes of exception control per shift.
Manually: 35 minutes times 90 shifts is 3150 minutes, that is 52.5 hours a month. From scans: 5 minutes times 90 shifts is 450 minutes, that is 7.5 hours. The difference is 45 hours a month. At an assumed rate of 80 PLN per man-hour this gives 3600 PLN a month, that is 43 200 PLN a year.
The values are sample figures. A workshop with different staffing or a different number of shifts substitutes its own numbers, and the result changes proportionally.
What the calculation does not cover
The calculation counts only the people's time spent on the list. It does not include the cost of an error in the list that surfaces only during an evacuation, nor the cost of equipment: the scanner at the gate and, where an access control system already exists, the integration through a webhook. InnerWeb does not make readers, so the equipment is bought separately.
The implementation cost depends on the number of gates and the scope of integration, and the quotation is individual. For purchasing, a comparison is sensible: the time saved from the calculation, the cost of scanners and the one-off implementation cost, counted over a two-year horizon.
How to present this to purchasing
Purchasing usually asks about return, so prepare three figures: hours today, hours after implementation and the rate. Add an argument that cannot be priced precisely but carries weight: an evacuation list from the log, refreshed every 13 seconds, instead of a list from a sheet of paper written an hour ago.
It is also worth calculating a conservative scenario, for example half of the savings from the calculation. If the decision holds even under this assumption, the argument is strong.
Calculation: attendance list manual and from scans
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| People per shift | 90 people |
| Shifts a month (3 shifts, 30 days) | 90 shifts |
| Manual time (security 25 + shift manager 10) | 35 min/shift |
| Time from scans (exception control) | 5 min/shift |
| Rate | 80 PLN/h |
Result: Saving of 45 hours a month, that is 3600 PLN a month and 43 200 PLN a year.
Note: Sample calculation on the assumptions above; the plant's results depend on its staffing and rates.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does a list built from scans completely replace human work?
No. Exception control remains, for example for people who did not record an exit. The time for this control in the calculation is 5 minutes per shift.
Does the calculation depend on the hourly rate?
Yes. We assumed 80 PLN per man-hour as a sample figure. The hours saved stay the same, only the conversion into zloty changes.
Do the readers in the existing access control system have to be replaced?
No. InnerWeb integrates with the client's existing access control system and receives punch events through a webhook.
Let's talk about the gate in your workshop
We will show the security panel on the example of a rolling stock maintenance depot and discuss how to connect it to your existing access control system.
Let's talk