Why rebuilding the list takes so many hours
An investigation after a contamination incident starts with establishing the circle of people who had access to the zone in a given time window. When guests, service staff and suppliers are recorded in several places, rebuilding the circle means collecting data from each of them and reconciling the differences. The work is repetitive, but it cannot be skipped or done in five minutes.
Typical sources are the entry book at the porter's lodge, invitations in the mailbox, the list of visits with hosts, printouts of declarations and the reports of the security shift. Each has a different format, a different precision of times and a different person who keeps it. Discrepancies have to be clarified by phone, which lengthens the time and increases the risk that someone is missed.
What the manual rebuild cost is made of
The cost has four parts, of which only the first is visible in standard hour accounting.
- Collecting data from several sources and copying it into one list.
- Reconciling discrepancies: entry times, names, companies, hosts.
- Verifying completeness, that is, checking that nobody entered outside the record.
- Indirect cost: delay in the decision on the scope of the investigation, including batches and rooms.
What reading the gate register gives
Entries are recorded at the gate, and a declaration is required to record an entry. The database holds one declaration row per person per day, with the person's data and a SHA-256 hash of the text the person actually saw in their language. The list of people is therefore read, not assembled after the fact. A planned visit has an assigned host, so the list immediately shows who was responsible for the guest.
Limits of this saving
The gate register shows entries recorded at the gate. It does not replace the investigation, the risk assessment or the quality department's decisions, and its completeness depends on whether all entries to the zone pass through the gate. Before counting savings, it is therefore worth checking with a test whether any route bypasses the gate.
QA hours to rebuild the people list
- Manually from several sources
- Reading from the gate register
Sample calculation: one incident
The assumptions below are examples, and each plant should substitute its own values: number of visits, working time per person and hourly rate. The calculation does not describe any specific plant.
Assuming 60 guest and service visits per day and an investigation window covering 3 days, this gives 180 people to establish. Manually, at 6 minutes of work per person, collecting and reconciling the data takes 1080 minutes, that is 18 hours. Verifying completeness is another 4 hours, for a total of 22 hours of work. At a rate of PLN 120 per hour of quality department work, this comes to PLN 2640 per incident. Reading the gate register and checking the result takes 1 hour under the same assumption, that is PLN 120. The difference is 21 hours and PLN 2520 per incident.
With three such events a year, including trials and exercises, the saving is 63 hours and PLN 7560. This is not the whole value: what matters most is the speed with which the quality department knows whom to include in the investigation.
How to check your own figures
The best calibration is an exercise. The quality department draws a day from the last month and measures how long it takes to rebuild the list of people from the zone using the existing sources. It records the result as a reference point, and after implementing the gate register it repeats the trial. It is worth running it also with the declaration requirement switched on, because then it shows whether the list contains only people who submitted a declaration on that day.
The declaration is valid for one calendar day in the Europe/Warsaw time zone, so the day boundaries in the record are unambiguous. In an investigation covering several days there is no debate about whether a declaration signed at 23:59 also applied after midnight: it did not. The EU GMP guidelines (EudraLex, Volume 4) cover the chapter on personnel and Annex 1 on the manufacture of sterile medicinal products, whose revised version applies from 25 August 2023.
Sample calculation: one contamination incident
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Guest and service visits | 60 people per day |
| Investigation window | 3 days |
| Manual work per person | 6 min |
| Completeness verification | 4 hours |
| Gate register reading and check | 1 hour |
| Quality department rate | 120 PLN/h |
Result: Manually 22 hours (PLN 2640), from the register 1 hour (PLN 120): difference 21 hours and PLN 2520 per incident; with three events a year, 63 hours and PLN 7560.
Note: Sample calculation. The plant substitutes its own numbers of visits, working time and rate; the result does not apply to any specific plant.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does the gate register list replace the quality department's investigation?
No. It shortens the stage of establishing the circle of people, but the risk assessment and decisions on the scope of the investigation remain with the quality department.
How does the register show who was responsible for the guest?
A planned visit has a host, meaning an active internal employee, so every visit has a person responsible.
Does changing the declaration text alter earlier records?
No. Each declaration stores a SHA-256 hash of the text the person saw in their language, so a later change does not rewrite history.
Sources
Let's count it with your numbers
We will put the number of visits, the working time of your quality department and the rate of your plant into the calculation. Book a conversation with InnerWeb.
Let's talk